May 22: Tony La Russa’s House of Lineups
Good evening from Busch Stadium …
1. WELCOME TO TONY LA RUSSA’S LINEUP EMPORIUM: Sometimes I think the skipper likes to mess with people, I really do. I think at times — as much as he wants to win — that TLR gets a kick out of knowing that his lineups will drive the fan base nutso. When La Russa unveiled his lineup for Thursday night’s game vs. the Cubs, it was met with raised eyebrows and snorts. I posted it online in two different settings, and the reaction was one of bewilderment. What’s TLR trying to do? He has a chance for a SWEEP of the CUBS. Is he trying to FORFEIT? I’m not knocking any fan for being puzzled; more than anything, I think it’s funny. But he seems to know what he’s doing.
This was La Russa’s 37th different lineup of the season, in 41 games. And this was La Russa’s finest bit of head-scratching yet. He had Yadi Molina, Nick Stavinoha, Brian Barden and Joe Thurston batting in the 4 through 7 spots … and the four of ‘em had combined for 8 RBIs this month. He had Thurston, an infielder, playing left field. He hit the pitcher 8th and batted shortstop Tyler Greene 9th. Brendan Ryan was the leadoff man (career leadoff BA: .227). No Skip Schumaker, no Chris Duncan. Well, it all worked out. Greene and Ryan covered a lot of ground in the middle infield to support the first-rate pitching of Adam Wainwright. Barden homered and singled. Thurston tripled (though was stranded at third). Greene doubled and scored a run. This Pujols fellow hit a long homer and I, I, I, just don’t know how to describe it. With Wainwright pitching like a bully, a few runs was all La Russa needed from this group. And they delivered. The manager knows best. He’s been winning games with these kind of lineups since he came here in 1996. He’s 24-17 with this team, and with all of the injuries and lineup straining, I don’t know how he does it. Except for maybe this …
2. STARTING PITCHING CAN CURE JUST ABOUT ANYTHING: The Cardinals’ starters were remarkably good in the three-game sweep of the Cubs. Joel Pineiro, Chris Carpenter and Adam Wainwright combined for 22.2 IP, holding the Cubs to one run and 11 hits. Derrek Lee went 4 for 11 in the series. But look at how the other Cubs were shut down: Fukudome (1-9), Soriano (1-12, 6 Ks), Theriot (1-11), Bradley (1-10), Soto (2-9), Fontenot (1-10). It’s another reminder that good pitching can cover a lot of weaknesses. The Cardinals haven’t had Rick Ankiel or Ryan Ludwick available, together, since May 4. And during that time the team has batted .220 and averaged 3.4 runs per game. But they’re 7-9 since May 4. No, that’s not great, but the Cardinals have scratched out enough wins to hang in thereto stay in the thick of the NL Central race. Before the Cubs came to town, the Cardinals had just gotten swept by Milwaukee and the town (but not the team, and certainly not me) were panicking. The freefall would have turned even more severe if the starting pitchers caved in during the Cubs series. Instead, the starters came through with masterful outings. And the home team won all three games despite batting .205 and scoring 8 runs in the three memorable nights against the Cubs.
3. NEXT UP, THE VISITING KANSAS CITY ROYALS:
The Royals (21-20) are improved. They have a fine GM in Dayton Moore. They have a fighting chance in the so-so AL Central.
Let’s have a quick rundown…
- Where the Royals are strong: Run prevention. They’re giving up around 4.24 runs per game, the lowest in the American League. It isn’t all just Zack Greinke, either. The KC bullpen is No. 5 in the majors in ERA, and rates well in other key categories, such as fewest baserunners per nine innings (ranked 10th), strikeouts per batters faced (4th), and K/BB ratio (6th). The bullpen isn’t quite as fearsome with closer Joakim Soria sidelined a couple of more weeks with a rotator-cuff strain, but there’s plenty of power pitching in the house with the likes of Juan Cruz and Kyle Farnsworth. Consecutive late-inning disasters against the Indians on Wednesday and Thursday inflated the bullpen’s numbers a bit, but they’ve done good work overall.
- Where the Royals are mediocre: scoring runs; 11th in the American League and 21st in the majors at at 4.56 per game. They’re 11th in homers per game, 10th in slugging, 9th in OBP. Second baseman Alberto Callaspo (.332 / .392 / .505) is an emerging hitting star. (Through Wednesday he’d created more runs than Boston 2B Dustin Pedroia this season.) But the lineup, even in missing Alex Gordon, shouldn’t be underestimated. Guys like Coco Crisp, Mark Teahen, Billy Butler and David DeJesus are effective hitters against RHP, and the Cardinals will start three RH against the Royals this weekend. Mike Jacobs has driven in 24 runs. Jose Guillen has the occasional flurry. But it’s not a formidable bunch. In terms of OPS, through Wednesday the Royals had only three positions that are ranked among the top five offensively in the AL: second base (3rd), catcher (5th), and center field (5th.)
- Where the Royals have problems: defense. Through Wednesday they were 21st in the majors in defensive efficiency. 2B Callaspo and SS Mike Aviles each have a below-average profile in UZR. Royals catchers have allowed 29 stolen bases in 35 attempts. In right field, Guillen’s UZR is minus 6.9, and runners have taken an extra base on him 15 times in 17 opportunities. Crisp is generally fine in CF, but runners have taken the extra base 25 times in 42 opportunities. The Royals are 9th among 12 AL teams in fielding percentage. The Royals receive little offensively from the shortstop position, and it isn’t a strength defensively, so you’d have to think that Moore will upgrade there.
4. KEEPING AN EYE ON THE DRAFT: In a mock draft that appeared on the Baseball Prospectus web site, three local pitchers seem to be in terrific shape for the first round on June 9. Westminster Christian Academy’s Jacob Turner is projected to go 6th to the Giants; Mizzou pitcher Kyle Gibson is projected to go 4th to the Pirates, and former Mizzou pitcher Aaron Crow is projected to go 11th to the Rockies.
5. BERNIE BYTES: Brendan Ryan (2B) and Tyler Greene (SS) looked sharp as a combo in Thursday’s win over the Cubs. At some point, when he gets some offense back, La Russa will likely take a hard look at putting his best glove guys the in the middle of that infield. It’s one thing to sacrifice some defense for offense in LF, as many managers do — but the Cardinals have a groundball pitching staff, and it’s imperative to maximize that skill by deploying better range in the middle of that defense… if the Rams are serious about signing cornerback Roderick Hood, the team’s fans should hope that he’ll play better here than he did the last two seasons in Arizona. According to STATS, Hood was burned for 16 TD passes over the last two seasons. Quarterbacks completed 60 percent of their passes when targeting him last season… hat tip to Matthew “Pip” Philip for pointing out that Cardinals’ centerfielder Colby Rasmus is leading major-league rookies in runs created.
Finally, a bonus note on the Royals-Cardinals rivalry: since meeting in the 1985 World Series, the franchises have taken wildly divergent paths. Starting with the 1986 season, the Cardinals have the 5th-best winning percentage (.525) in the majors in regular-season play, and the Royals are at the very bottom in winning percentage (.457) among teams that were in existence in ‘96. Only the Yankees, Braves, Red Sox and A’s have won more games than the Cardinals. If you want to throw in the expansion teams, only the Tampa Bay Rays (who entered in 1998) have a lower winning percentage than the Royals.
Thanks for reading … comments section is now open.
-Bernie


My vote is for a black eye to replace the I for the season.
I like it… good idea!
You kind of said it. The pitchers look better when there is better middle infielders. Rasmas will only get better in center.
Yah I’m going to drop 50 bucks a ticket, 20 bucks to park, a hundred bucks in beer and hot dogs to watch 6 rookies take the field. Give me a break.
I don’t know what the statistic is…but it has to be a statistical impossibility…a near zero return…has any team starting 6 rookies ever made the post season, let alone win the World Series? If the answer is no then you’re left to ask the question, what the @#%Q#@$^ are you doing Bill DeWitt? Ridiculous. Almost as ridiculous as the Cubs scoring 2 runs 27 innings of baseball…and what’s almost as ridiculous as that is that the Redbirds scored 8 runs in that 27 inning span…and swept the little bears.
If I knew the pitching staff was going to perform the rest of the season like it has the last three games, I’d be OK with a rookie lineup. But I would think that will not be the case. …and if it is not the case, the pitching staff is going to grow weary knowing they have to go out there and keep the opposition down to two runs or less every time they take the hill. Perhaps they may be up to the task, but I sure would’nt bet on that hand of cards. Nope,I’d be telling the dealer to hit me with some cards so that I Might come up with a better hand to play with.
How can you complain about anything fresh off a sweep of the Cubs? Baseball is an up and down game-enjoy the good times! I personally prefer the energy of the younger players. Hope my mood is still this good after the series in wis. Happy Memorial day.
Interesting lineup last night. I think they may have been in danger of being fined for not bringing enough “starters” had they used that lineup in a Spring Training road game. The guys got the job done so thats all that matters!
What in God’s name constitutes “runs created?”
A Chicago area cemetery owner built a likeness of Wrigly Field where fans can wait all of eternity for the Cubs to win the World Series. He didn’t realize such a place already existed. It’s called The Bleachers.
“At some point, when he gets some offense back, La Russa will likely take a hard look at putting his best glove guys the in the middle of that infield. It’s one thing to sacrifice some defense for offense in LF…”
I’m assuming you’re referring to Skip here. FSN showed a graphic last night with Skip’s stats and how he ranks among other 2B’s in MLB. I don’t remember the exact numbers, and maybe you can dig them up, but it sure seemed like he was holding his own. I’m not saying he’s better in the field than Brendan Ryan or Brian Barden, but so far he ain’t been no slouch.
RE: Skip’s stats…
I guess I should have specified *defensive* stats. Here’s his line so far this season at 2B:
G: 31
GS: 30
INN: 225
TC: 121
PO: 46
A: 74
E: 1
DP: 18
FPCT: .992
RF: 4.79
ZR: .684
There is never a shortage of irony on these blogs. TLR is BLASTED for YEARS on these blogs for not being able to work with young players. Now he is embracing young players, using them to win three excellently played and managed games against the small bears, and keeping in the playoff hunt while riddled with injuries…and what do we have? Criticism that we can’t keep it up with young players, puts too much pressure on pitching, open De-Wallet, etc. Priceless… Let’s keep an eye out for one or two key additions (3B?), but this team is exciting and we’ve got some great stories developing: Albert’s continued assault on baseball excellence as we thought we knew it, Carp’s return, the maturation of Yadi as the finest catchers in baseball, the Rookie Birds, Skip at 2b, Franklin outrageous success/beard and on and on. FUN SEASON.
Dude, everybody has to chill out… I’m so sick of reading these tired whiney posts about the organization spending money. While I agree the prospect of 6 rookies starting day in day out is not great, it’s a temporary predicament. We have Ludwick and Ankiel coming back, and as long as Tony and Dunc keep making it work while developing these prospects for the future, why not go with it? The Rays did pretty well with young unproven talent last year, and getting these guys playing time now makes things look pretty bright for the Cards for the next several years. But my bigger question is, who in the hell is everyone suggesting we go out and spend money on? should we go get another Kahlil Greene? How about Manny, should we have spent money on that POS? I’m all for going to get DeRosa to play 3rd, but that’s not a big-money transaction that everyone keeps crying about. I’d just love to know who we’re supposed to go out right now and get.
I think Albert was trying to send a message last night to the fans… there is no “I” in team. I love watching this group, and if they all keep playing with heart and contributing, this is a team we’ll all enjoy for a long time.
my bigger issue is if Wellemeyer sucks it up tonight, when are we shipping him to the pen (or otherwise) and keeping Boggs up for good?
He hasn’t had to do a damn thing the last few nights with the pitching performances the team has had so he had to find a way to make his mark on last nights game. The poor pathetic man was just not getting enough attention so he had to create some.
Just a random thought but could Thurston’s start in LF be a way of showcasing his versatility for possible trade partners? I am no way suggesting he would be the centerpiece in a trade for a 3rd baseman but if we trade for someone like DeRosa the Indians might want an IF/OF as part of the return package.
I like the showcasing Thurston thought. I would go a little further than DeRosa and try for someone like Jose Reyes. He’s in the Mets (fans’) doghouse and would be a perfect way for Mo to stick it to Tony (TLR doesn’t like laid back fun loving players). The Mets need pitching but don’t have a ton of minor league prospects so we could help them land Peavy by offering up a few guys. Not really sure who, maybe Motte or Perez along with McClellan, Wallace and/or a few other youngsters. Just a thought…
Snag, what an idiotic statement! The skipper wants to win, period. He is always deflecting praise to his players. With a lefthander going last night, he replaced his lefty hitters with right handed hitters. Makes sense to me.
sportsfanjr: Why on earth would we want to “help the Mets land Peavy”?!!
Real Baseball Intelligence (RBI), a leading resource in the evaluation of amateur baseball talent and draft coverage, offers its 2009 Baseball Draft Guide. The Guide includes RBI’s Top 400 draft prospects, scouting reports of the top ten players at each position, a mock draft and more. It is available at withthefirstpick.net/guide
But on the 24th, you write a glowing piece about LaRussa. Can’t ever figure out what side of the fence you sit.
Not sure why you’d be confused, other than the fact that you’re a Media Critic wannabe who nitpicks everything … my comments on La Russa’s lineups were not criticisms, as any intelligent person would realize.
You think this passage might have been the tipoff?
“The manager knows best. He’s been winning games with these kind of lineups since he came here in 1996. He’s 24-17 with this team, and with all of the injuries and lineup straining, I don’t know how he does it.”
And you perceive that as criticism? Wow. You’re really reaching. Not surprised.
-B