Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
02.01.2008 12:43 pm

Decisions 2008: Who’s on second?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

TOWER GROVE – Although the snow is a nice sendoff for those of us heading south shortly, it’s only further confirmation that spring training is approaching rapidly. The only thing coming faster and with more anticipation is Super Tuesday. And that’s got everybody thinking about voting.

So why not combine the two big February events and hold the Cardinals Nation primaries?

Manager Tony La Russa and his coaching staff will have plenty of Decisions (in) 2008, from who fills the outfield, to who bats leadoff, to who’s on his bench, to who plays second base. Those players will have to sway the coaches with their play, their commitment and, yes, their experience. Sounds almost like an election. 

This PoliSci major — once dreamed of covering the Supreme Court, don’tcha know — was watching the cozy Democrats debate last night and thought maybe it’s time for the Cardinals candidates to take their campaigns to the constituency.

Today, in the first of a series of primaries over the next few business days, the candidates for second base present their cases, in their own words*, to the electorate.

Here’s the ballot, and rock your vote below.

(* Not really. The facts are real, but they aren’t actual quotes.)

*** 

ADAM KENNEDY (From the Left): None other than La Russa himself has said that last year was a blip in an otherwise strong and consistent major-league career. There were a lot of factors weighing it down, not the least of which was a knee injury — that was not the cause of early struggles but had to be repaired. The .219 average is a wart on the baseball card, to be sure, but it does not define the player. A career .275 hitter with a strong glove and winner’s savvy, has more experience than any other candidate. Sure, there are the recent quotes from La Russa and KMOX host Kevin Wheeler’s rather clinical assessment, but all that is motivation, reasons to reclaim a misplaced reputation. Just two years ago, this infielder had Win Share totals like Ian Kinsler, a .300 average, and back-to-back seasons of 70 runs. A career doesn’t plummet that rapidly. T’s crossed, I’s dotted, and that makes a starting second baseman.

Kennedy campaign button

AARON MILES (Swing voter): Each spring it’s the same thing. Come to Jupiter. Try to win a starting job. Never the favorite, but always the eventual winner. Happened with Junior Spivey. Happened with  Kennedy. Why not bet on it happening again? Started 134 games at second base over the past two seasons and it would have been more except for some moonlighting turns, when needed, at shortstop. Flirted with hitting .300 last year until a late-season skid. Still, batted .292 and slugged .353 from the left side of the plate, while posting a .368 on-base percentage from the right side. That number, at least, supports a platoon chance. Probably deserved more at-bats in 2007, a fact La Russa admitted recently when he said Kennedy got the benefit of the doubt even when there were others playing better.  Not the polished glove that others are, or the upside hitter others are, but has played the best when given the opportunity. Why delay the inevitable and just vote now for this starting second baseman. 

Miles campaign button

BRENDAN RYAN (From the Right): Stepped out of the prospect label last season and played well enough for the Cardinals to accept some of his unpolished attributes and attitudes. Was mentored by Scott Rolen and David Eckstein in the ways of being a big leaguer — from tipping the clubbies, to when to show up for groundball practice — and was famously yanked from a game after swinging at a 3-0 pitch. That kind of green won’t win the position, but his athleticism could. Adept at both middle infield positions, though most of his amateur experience (i.e., college) was at second base. Strong arm. Quick feet. Has been more a more consistent glove each season. Speed is a plus. Bat could be. Hit .354/.407/.456 in 79 at-bats against lefthanders. Plenty of promise. Will have to overcome perception he needs another year of Triple-A seasoning to be the starting second baseman.

Ryan, No. 13, campaign button

JARRETT HOFFPAUIR (From the Right): An underdog candidate who could play John Edwards* in this mix, reminding everyone: “This isn’t a two-person race.” Hoffpauir had his breakout minor-league season in 2007, hitting .300 or better at stops in Double-A and Triple-A. As a Springfield Cardinal, the second baseman had an OPS of .938, was the league’s batting average leader at the time of his promotion and was an All-Star. Remember the Prospect SATs? Hoffpauir: Bo Hart: Kinsler, which is to say at his high end he could add a low-order, line-drive punch. Has the best strike-zone judgment in the organization (fewer Ks than walks in every pro season) and could take some swings at leadoff sometime this season. His defense is average, but his bat got him drafted and his bat carries his candidacy to be the starting second baseman.

Hoffpauir, the underdog, campaign button

(* Not to be confused with Jon Edwards, the rocket-arm right fielder.)  

D’ANGELO JIMENEZ (Swing voter): First of the non-roster candidates who enter the fray. Has been with three other teams since his heyday as the second baseman for the Cincinnati Reds. In 2004, he hit .270/.364/.394 with 12 home runs, 99 strikeouts (!) and 67 RBIs. Bounced around and landed with Washington in 2007 before being outrighted at the end of the year. Signed to a minor-league free agent deal but cut from the mold of the experienced infielder who can play a lot of positions. Edges Miles with a 0.00 ERA in 1 1/3 innings of mopup, which might be enough to make him the starting second baseman.

Jimenez campaign license plate

BRIAN BARDEN (From the Right): Plucked off waivers last season from Arizona, Barden won college’s equivalent of the Gold Glove for his work at third base for Oregon State. Shortly after he arrived as a Cardinal, he explained how he saw his calling: It wasn’t at third base. Though he cracked 31 home runs in 2005 and 2006 combined at Triple-A, Barden said he didn’t have the pop to stay at third. He’d have to roam and increase his versatility. Second base could be the calling. Gifted with the glove, Barden is a career .296 hitter in the minors, and his past two full seasons in Triple-A he hit steady — .298/.361/.478 and .307/.363/.483. There’s a lot to like about his reliability and his potential, but spring may not be enough time for him to win the starting job at second base.

For kicks.

Next primaries Monday: Former Cardinals. 

-30-

51 comments

Comments are closed.

Mr. Goold,

Excellent column. Kennedy or Miles will get the early nod from LaRussa. Jimenez will not make it on the club, and Hoffpauir will be sent back down to the minors. Ryan will be kept as an utility infielder.

I would definitely like to see Brian Barden get an opportunity at 2nd. From the article, Barden appears to have the greatest potential to be a complete player. You say he is “gifted” defensively, and he has hit consistently at the AAA level. His offensive split indicates better OPS than either Kennedy or Miles.

I would also like to see Brendan Ryan given an honest shot at SS. Izturis needs to be a defensive specialist at this point. The advantage/disadvantage of veterans is that you have a pretty good idea of what they are capable. Izturis has shown you his range, I’d like to see Ryan’s.

— Elliott
3:22 pm February 1st, 2008

With the options listed for second base, we’re going to need a Rookie of the Year or Comeback Player of the Year from our second-baseman to maintain some respect at the position. I hate the idea of platooning players. That’s for teams that aren’t able to afford a legitimate player and are forced to combine the service of a over-the-hill position player with a youngster that would be in the minor leagues in most other organizations.
Bottom line: The Cardinals will be sold before 2011.

— Brooke
3:40 pm February 1st, 2008

These primaries will be fun and better than the political primaries. First off, if a mistake is made by the chosen starter, one can always pull the guy and switch to a backup. The final decision will be made by one guy that has a dearth of knowledge on the subject instead of a wide base of people that think they know whats what.

With that said I’m going to reluctantly hold my nose (John McCain?) and vote for Kennedy. He’s the paid and experienced player and there is at least some sanity to the idea that last year was an aberration. As far as the “VP” goes? I’d give that to Brendan Ryan. If Kennedy fails that who I want starting next. I love Miles, but off the bench filling in at both middle infield spots. I think Ryan will need to eventually settle at either second or short. With regard to Hoffpauir and Barden I think they need a little more experience before the starting spot (Obama?). In a year I could see Ryan at short and one of those two gentlemen at second if Kennedy fails. But for now Ryan has the experience to be the main backup to both middle positions should Kennedy or Izturis fail.

D’Angelo can go the route of Junior Spivey.

— RCJ
3:46 pm February 1st, 2008

I believe that the job is Kennedy’s to lose. If Kennedy does lose the job then I would give Brian Barden a good hard look. We can use Miles and Ryan for help at shortstop and third base.

— John Skourup
3:55 pm February 1st, 2008

Pardon me for one moment of sour grapes…this question would be moot if we had not botched the signing of Davey Eckstein.

For all the carping about his lack of range and arm at shortstop…looks like he would have been perfect for a shot at second base.

He’s a winner…played on multiple championship teams and a playoff MVP. I’ll take Eckstein on my team any day.

— Leonard Childs
4:25 pm February 1st, 2008

I say give it to Brendan Ryan and Aaron Miles both. Let them swap it back and forth. They’re both good.

— LETSGOCARDS
5:10 pm February 1st, 2008

I have been an ardent Cardinals fan for 35 years, through good times and bad. 2B should be Adam Kennedy’s job to lose. 2007 was a bad season for him, but a lot of players have been down the same road. If he hits Spring Training and proves himself, he deserves the shot. If he can’t pull his weight, Aaron Miles is more than adequate and Brendan Ryan is reliable.

Let Kennedy and Miles battle for the 2B job. Shortstop is a bigger concern. I doubt Izturis will make the opening day roster. Mozeliak said, “I’m not Walt Jocketty Jr.”, and has proven it with his reclammation signings. Mo dumped Jim Edmonds, traded even for Troy Glaus to ease clubhouse tension (provided he’s healthy) and scrounged around the bottom of the dumpster to sign Izturis and Matt Clement. The owners are ham-stringing though.

I would love to see Clement and Izturis rebound and be productive, and I hope they prove me wrong.

Platoons have never worked well for the Cards in the past, and I don’t see that changing.

May the best men win.

— chaos2020
5:51 pm February 1st, 2008

I think Ryan’s future is at short, so he should be eliminated from this discussion.

I think Miles is a good back-up, and like Franklin in the bullpen, should be left to fill that very important role.

I think Kennedy should be given the opportunity to win the position, but put on a short leash.

I like the idea of Barden being given a shot. If his defense is at least adequate, his offensive potential is enough at a position you don’t expect offense from to give him a big edge over others. The fact that he can play all 3 infield ( 1st? ) positions and pinch hit if called upon, also adds to his value. His attitude also sounds very commendable.

Thanks for a forum to express our thoughts on this and other issues. I enjoy hearing what others think, knowing TLR will make the final decision.

— b_hern
5:56 pm February 1st, 2008

Hi Derrick,

I really enjoy your online column and wish you wrote every day. I’ve learned so much about the Cardinals and baseball from you. I think you have a great sense of humor and it shows in your writing. You are a breath of fresh air for the readers of Stltoday.

Wanda

— wanda Christopher
6:11 pm February 1st, 2008

I’m gonna go out on a limb and say number 19 is some dumb 16 year old with emotional issues. I’m also gonna go out on a limb and say that post will and should go away. DG - Make sure to erase this one too because it will make zero sense. I hope that guy gets therapy.

— RCJ
7:30 pm February 1st, 2008

Pages: « 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 » Show All