Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
11.27.2008 12:50 pm

The St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

TOWER GROVE — After more than 8,500 votes, 173 comments, dozens of spin-off threads, a few lively exchanges over at the Facebook page, and the hours of one talented Post-Dispatch illustrator, it is time to unveil the monument that you helped chisel:

The St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore.

Back during the limbo between playoff series, Bird Land asked the simple question: What four members from Cardinals’ history would you carve into a Mount Rushmore of the franchise? We called it The Rushmore Project. There were no rules, though some demanded that it be kept to players only. There were no guidelines as far as time served, though some insisted that Albert Pujols not yet being eligible for the Hall of Fame should mean he not yet be eligible for Mount Cardsmore as well.

From Stan Musial to George Kissell to Branch Rickey — there was only a list of 15 candidates and the invitation to write in more. Dizzy Dean and Mike Shannon, who should have been No. 16, gained the most write-in votes.

Tom Borgman, a designer and graphic illustrator at the P-D, took the results of the poll, and crafted a photo illustration of what the four winners would look like, blasted into the rock of Rushmore. As a Thanksgiving Weekend treat for Bird Land readers, here is the debut of Bird Land’s Cardsmore:

The St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore

Fab Four: The St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore (illustration by Tom Borgman)

A total of 8,552 people voted, at least check, on the Rushmore Project, and each of the four faces above received at least 40 percent of the vote. Three of the players featured above are Hall of Famers, and the third is well on his way after just winning the second MVP of his career. Musial, of course, led the way, with 8,274 votes, begging the question who were the 3 percent of voters who left him off? Bob Gibson received 7,728 votes (90 percent). In a show of strength from the current generation of Cards Nation, Pujols received 5,087 votes (59 percent), and Ozzie Smith received 3,523 votes (41 percent).

It can be argued that the Cardinals’ Rushmore above features the franchise’s best player, best pitcher, best hitter and best fielder — the four very definitions of the disciplines it takes to play baseball.

Hall of Famers Lou Brock (34 percent), Jack Buck (32 percent), Rogers Hornsby (21 percent) and Red Schoendienst (11 percent) completed the top eight.

The Real Rushmore (Washington, Jefferson, Roosevelt, Lincoln)

The Real Rushmore (Washington, Jefferson, Roosevelt, Lincoln)

With the exception of Mr. Buck, players did the best in the poll, as many voters wrestled with the definition of who belongs on a Rushmore. The most comment approach suggested that only Presidents appear on the real Mount Rushmore, so only players should appear on the Cardinals Rushmore. There’s no Ben Franklin carved into South Dakota, so why should there be a Branch Rickey carved into the Cardinals? Rickey, who helped build the Cardinals from approving the Redbird logo to establishing a farm system to even encouraging the growth of The Knothole Gang, received 164 votes. George Kissell who coached generations of Cardinal received 150 votes. Current manager Tony La Russa received 193 votes, and former owner August A. Busch Jr. received the most of any non-player save Mr. Buck.

The bios of the four members of Cardsmore (from Washington to Lincoln):

After the press conference to introduce Pujols as this year’s National League MVP, several of us — including Maurice Drummond of Fox 2 and P-D columnist Bryan Burwell — sat in the media room and talked about how Pujols has clearly become the face of the franchise. That spawned the question of who is “Mr. Cardinal”? There are really only a handful of candidates. For his play and his personality and his presence still in the public eye, Musial is the obvious answer. Schoendienst has a claim because he still wears the uniform before home games, is a annual visitor and attraction at spring training and was both a Hall of Fame player and one of the franchise’s winningest managers. Now, it’s Pujols. On TV. In video games. Featured in ads. On the field.

The vote above probably gives us the answer.

It certainly identified the cardinal Cardinals.

Let the debate resume once the turkey settles.

-30-

51 comments

Comments are closed.

I argue that there should be consideration for Curt Flood due to his influence on free agency and the way he played center field. Ted Simmons was the face of the cards in the seventies and a great catcher, not skilled defensively but made up for it by hitting, toughness and the way he handled his pitchers. Lou Broke broke Ty Cobb’s stolen base record until a speedy Vince Coleman came along. How about Ken Boyer, Joe Torre, Tim McCarver, Orlando Cepeda, Roger Maris, Bob Forsch, John Tudor, Matty Mo, etc. etc. The way I figure it, you need room for at least twenty faces on that mountain. Cardinals are so rich in history.

— roger from lake tahoe
7:04 pm November 27th, 2008

I love them all. Four Great picks. But it bothers me that Lou Brock is not up there. I don’t know if you bump Ozzie or Albert, probably Ozzie. Lou is St. Louis. He’s definitely one of the top four… probably number 3 after Stan the Man and Gibby. Difficult choices. Maybe we expand Rushmore to 5 faces??? GO CARDS!!!!

— TK
8:05 pm November 27th, 2008

From Wikipedia: Hornsby is among the greatest hitters in baseball history. He is the greatest hitter who regularly played a position other than outfield or first base, and he is arguably history’s best right-handed hitter. He is the only player to win the National League Triple Crown twice. His career batting average of .358 is the highest in National League history, and also the highest in major league history for any right-handed hitter. His batting average for the 1924 season was .424, a mark that no player since has matched. The Baseball Hall of Fame elected Hornsby in 1942. He has also been given a star on the St. Louis Walk of Fame.

Hornsby MUST be on the Rushmore Mountain…. :-) joel

— joel
10:26 pm November 27th, 2008

This was a great poll. It wasn’t a question of which players deserve to be etched in stone … they all do. All I can say is our Mt. Rushmore can beat the Cubbies Mt. Rushless any day of the week!

— chaos2020
1:01 am November 28th, 2008

It’s sad to see the quality of baseball/Cardinal fans go down. Come on fellas, Ozzie Smith over Rogers Hornsby? Let’s go now, it’s a jokr right. The greatest right handed hitter ever, only guy to hit for the triple crown over a decade. Seriously, it’s embarassing. Hornsby’s the greatest player to ever wear a Cardinal uniform, you can argue that he wasn’t the greatest Cardinal ever, but player manager on the ‘26 team and his complete dominance easily puts him on this little Rushmore thing.

— Tony
1:07 am November 28th, 2008

how is it possible that Stanley Frank Musial wasn’t named #1 on every ballot? only 8274 out of 8550? how soon we forget.

— Joe Giliberti
4:31 am November 28th, 2008

I think the fans got it about right based on the limitations. While Horsby is cetainly deserving, it’s hard to argue about Ozzie who, afterall, played in three World Series as a Cardinal while earning a ticket to the Hall of Fame.

— Alan of Valley Park
5:17 am November 28th, 2008

What about Uecker!!!

— avreader
5:38 am November 28th, 2008

Stan the Man is rightfully at the forefront, but many others from days of yore have been forgotten, and that’s a shame. And how about a VERY honorable mention of John Tudor, who may not have been a lifelong Cardinal, but as I recall pitched 10 complete-game shutouts for us in a single season, and took several other games as shutouts into extra innings. Rather remarkable, and memorable, I’d say. And how the hell did Whitey get lost in this hasty shuffle?

— Larry Stout
6:29 am November 28th, 2008

Joe Medwick is not on the list .His achievements are legendary.He is in the hall of fame.About 15 or 20 years ago the Post had a vote for the greatest cardinal starting line-up of all time .He was one of the outfielders. Also Ken Boyer was voted the best 3rd basemen was not on the list.If you want a person who succeeded in making the Cardinals a national team you have to name Harry Carey to the list.

— stephen c fuchs
7:02 am November 28th, 2008

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 » Show All