St. Louis Cardinals’ All-Prospect Lineup: Pick a Catcher
JUPITER, Fla. — With the first off day of spring training here for the St. Louis Cardinals, there’s time to ride some tangents — when you’re not riding the birthday boy’s “tsunami,” that is.
While working on a blog entry that you will see up in this space shortly about outfielder Colby Rasmus and how to read the recently released Baseball America Top 100 Prospects, I was intrigued by how BA took the depth charts us correspondents file and merged them into depth charts from across the minors. It’s a new view on familiar names and further helps crystallize exactly where the Cardinals rank in the development universe.
As you know, we’re always looking for new ways to add context to prospects — remember the rankings by the NL Central and how revealing those were. This is similar.
The Cardinals to crack the Top Prospect depth charts in the current issue of Baseball America were:
CATCHER
15. Bryan Anderson
CENTER FIELD
1. Colby Rasmus
THIRD BASE
4. Brett Wallace
17. David Freese
CORNER OUTFIELD
13. Daryl Jones
SHORTSTOP
14. Pete Kozma
RELIEVER
3. Chris Perez
As semi-telling as those spots in the depth charts are, what is more revealing is where the Cardinals didn’t have a prospect place. There were 35 righthanded starters named on the BA depth chart, and 20 more lefthanded starters listed. There isn’t a Cardinal named in those 55. Not one in the “top” 55 starting pitching prospects, according to the trade publication. Around the campus this spring, there has been considerable needling for the depth chart that appears in this year’s Prospect Handbook. While not belaboring the background, the depth charts lists Jess Todd, for example, as the No. 2 starter in 2012. There is a method to the mention, just as there is ample evidence and belief that Todd will find a home in the major-league bullpen.
The overall depth charts and the questions about the 2012 lineup, got me thinking: What would be the lineup of the Cardinals’ best prospects? How would compiling that show where the team is stacked for the future — and where it is hurting? If not one of the starting pitchers they have in the pipeline cracks the 55 mentioned above (and Jaime Garcia, if healthy, would have, no doubt), what does that say about the long-range projection for the rotation?
Seems like an excellent next exercise to tackle here with the power of the poll.
We’ll start with catcher and work our away around to starting pitcher. There is no need to throw up a poll on center field, but we will talk specific positions, and yes some will be eligible at two. Today: Catcher. Could be cut and dry, but there are some names on here that deserve a chance to surprise:
Back shortly with the detailed look at Rasmus’ place — and others’ — in the Top 100. Enjoy the off day.
-30-


Derrick Goold said he was going to Mizzou for capital-J journalism, but after growing up in the Time Zone Baseball Forgot he was really drawn to MU sitting between two major-league cities. Goold joined the Post-Dispatch in 2001 after working for The Times-Picayune and Rocky Mountain News, covering sports from LSU to NHL and every level of baseball in between.
I would have put Anderson but I don’t think he will stay a catcher if he stays with the Cards.
Twelve months ago I’d have been skeptical of Anderson’s chance to remain behind the plate, but after his outstanding numbers in 2008 (40% CS in AA, 36% in AAA, all at age 21), I’m quite comfortable with his defense.
By the way, Anderson made it to AA at age 20, AAA at 21. For a sense of context, let’s see what age BA’s current top catching prospects (in descending order) were when *they* reached AA:
Wieters 21/22
Posey (over 20, not there yet)
Santana 22 in high-A
Montero (18 in low-A)
Arencibia 22
Castro (over 20, not there yet)
Marson 21/22
Ramos (not there yet)
Teagarden 23
Ramirez 23
Skipworth (18 in rookieball)
Flowers 22 in high-A
So you see, those who’ve been disappointed by Anderson’s batwork so far, are in my opinion failing to *fully* appreciate how unusually young he’s been compared to his level of competition. Catchers do not play in AA at age 20, or AA at 21.
Anderson can hit. And he’ll get better.
DG, is Anderson in Cards’ camp this spring? Haven’t heard his name a lot these first couple weeks.
He’s here, and he’s set to play plenty with Molina at the WBC.
Thanks. Thought that was most likely how things were going to shake out. Looking forward to having the chance to see him with the big club.
I voted for Anderson as the obvious choice but unless St. Louis wants a Molina/Anderson platoon then Bryan ends up as a starting catcher in another organization. My choice with the most staying power is Steven Hill, because he can hit & also play 1st base and possibly a corner OF spot, in which case he could earn more looks as an option off the bench before settling in as a backup catcher.