Fireballer Miller “no slam dunk” to sign for Cardinals
DOWNTOWN — The St. Louis Cardinals broke with one tradition when they took a high school pitcher with their first pick in the draft, and now they must be willing to break with another to get their pick into the system.
Shelby Miller, a strapping righthander with a Texas-oil-burning fastball, has committed to Texas A&M and VP/farm director Jeff Luhnow acknowledges that it will not be easy or quick to finalize an agreement with the Brownwood, Texas, high schooler. The Cardinals have been an obedient team when it comes to following the slot bonus-system quietly passed around by Major League Baseball for draft picks, but Miller is the kind of player that could — and certainly will — command more than the players immediately around him.
“We’re willing to take a player and a gamble that we can get him signed,” Luhnow said just moments ago here at Busch Stadium. “The talent was the best talent available on the board. …
“It’s no slam dunk that we are going to sign him quickly or sign him at all. We want to make a best effort to sign him.”

Cardinals' first-round pick Shelby Miller, RHP, from Brownwood, Texas. (Courtesy: ESPN.com)
Miller, 18, is a 6-foot-3, 195-pound righthander from a small town three hours outside Dallas. According to a blend of scouting reports — including the Cardinals’, from Luhnow, and Baseball America and others – Miller 90 mph to 97 mph and sits regularly at 92 mph to 93 mph. Luhnow called his fastball “electric” for its lateral and downward movement. Though a few scouting reports have him pegged as a high-ball pitcher because of the overpowering nature of his fastball.
The righthander has a developed curveball that he uses as a put-away pitch and a changeup that will have to be refined in the minors.
In 77 2/3 innings for Brownwood High this season, Miller struck out 153, walked 38 and alloed 38 hits. He went 10-2 during the season with a 2.00.
“He does look like a big-league pitcher already and has the stuff that should play up here,” Luhnow said.
Some reports from around the Web on Miller:
- A slide show on Shelby Miller. (Check out the number he’s wearing)
- Dallas Morning News looks at how the Texas Rangers eyed Miller.
- MiLB.com’s scouting report on Miller.
- Keith Law’s scouting report on Miller, complete with video at ESPN.com.
- Most mock drafts had Miller going 14th to Texas Rangers.
Area scout Ralph Garr Jr. was the point man for the intelligence gathering on Miller, and over the course of the past year has spent time gauging not only Miller’s talent on the mound but his work ethic and personality off the mound. Luhnow was poker-faced about what the team knows concerning Miller’s signability. A year ago, 13th-overall pick Brett Wallace said himself that he wanted to sign and get playing, erasing even the hint of signability trouble for him.
Ditto with all of the other first-round picks under Luhnow’s watch.
In 2005, the Cardinals had deals in place with Colby Rasmus and Tyler Greene before selecting them at 28th and 30th overall, respectively.
Luhnow said no such deal is in place with Miller. Not only is Miller committed to a college program — a major college program — but he is … CLARIFIED: also of an age that he would be sophomore eligible, Luhnow said. … (This fact has been cross-checked and it is not the case, though the Cardinals originally said so. Miller would next be eligible for 2012 draft.) … The Cardinals, meanwhile, would get the 19th pick in next year’s draft if they don’t sign Miller but would also go the first 66 picks of the 2009 draft without a player.
Luhnow said they team would supplement the missing picks with international signings or late-round overspends. But that was premature talk.
“We’ve had quick signings the last couple years, and this is probably not one of them,” Luhnow said. He added about drafting a prep pitcher that could take awhile to develop: “We have a chance to be patient here without a pressing need to get him to the big leagues in the next two years.”
-30-


Derrick Goold said he was going to Mizzou for capital-J journalism, but after growing up in the Time Zone Baseball Forgot he was really drawn to MU sitting between two major-league cities. Goold joined the Post-Dispatch in 2001 after working for The Times-Picayune and Rocky Mountain News, covering sports from LSU to NHL and every level of baseball in between.
Get it done Mo. Although sounds like we are onto that Dom Rep Centerfielder. That kind of move might go a long way with Albert…
When DG wrote about Roger Clemens being drafted as the 19th pick, I wondered if the Cards would take a big hard-throwing righthander from Texas.
Yeah. Certainly. He’s going to be expensive. 4+ million dollars?
DG, just wanted to say you’re doing an awesome job with draft coverage. Get some sleep tonight, though.
Unless MLB.com has the wrong DOB…Miller will not be soph-eligible.
This is what someone wrote in the comments section in the Dallas Morning News article;
“I saw this kid get lit up against Wichita Falls High School……It was UGLY!!!!!! He is a cocky little SOB as well……”
I know you don’t have to be likable to be good but I sure hope our scouts know what their doing. Nolan Ryan passed on this guy.
Picklefork,
Good eye. We’re working to confirm exactly what that means. Luhnow mentioned that Miller would be sophomore eligible — i.e., ready for 2011 after two years in college. That doesn’t check out with his DOB, nor with other sources, but it was a factor brought up in his signability.
Will have firm explanation shortly and get back with the info, as always.
dg
-30-
Bud Wiser,
The Rangers only had one pick in the first round and went with Matthew Purke. They chose what may have been the best LHP in the draft. That’s not necessarily a knock on Miller.
I like where Mo is going with this pick. He’s a great prospect first and foremost, so you draft him and then you figure it out. Someone else was going to have to do the same thing. Not as though the kid would go undrafted. And not as though the kid just got selected by the Pirates. This will get done. I trust in Mo.
If it’s going to take $$$ to convince this kid to sign I’m not sure that is in the front office’s playbook. Quite odd they would pass on can’t miss pitchers in the past because of $$$s (Porcello with Boras) and now they are going to go out of slot to pay this kid. Don’t see it happening.