Mark DeRosa & 3-Team Trade That Never Was, Yet Really Is
TOWER GROVE — On this past New Year’s Eve, the Chicago Cubs made a deal that surprised the industry and may have tripped one of the early dominos in their struggles to play up to their clear talent this season.
The Cubs dealt infielder/outfielder Mark DeRosa to Cleveland for three minor-league pitchers.
DeRosa, a fan- and clubhouse-favorite in Chicago known in the nickname currency of the day as “D-Ro”, had been an essential member of back-to-back playoff teams, the first back-to-back playoff teams for the Chicago Cubs franchise since, oh, about the time the Missouri School of Journalism was founded. (Hint: 2008 was the august school’s centennial anniversary.) As you’ll hear often in the wake of DeRosa’s arrival in St. Louis as the newest Cardinal, DeRosa had a career-high in homers and RBIs last season, but he also was a glue guy, a nomadic glove and a go-to quote who could take the press heat even on the ugly days.
But the Cubs were looking to trim payroll, whether it was to add Jake Peavy via trade (didn’t happen) or augment the exposed righthanded-heavy lineup with some lefthanded pop (did happen: meet Milton Bradley). To make moves the For-Sale Cubs needed some financial flexibility. That meant moves. That’s what general manager Jim Hendry said to a handful of reporters at the Winter Meetings.
Just as dealing Jason Marquis to Colorado helped, Dealing DeRosa shaved $5.5 million of the payroll.
It also started a chain of events that essential means the Cubs traded DeRosa to … the Cardinals.
Follow the trail: The Cubs sign former Cardinal Aaron Miles to a two-year, $4.9-million deal. That made DeRosa expendable. So the Cubs, looking to slice some payroll, moved DeRosa to Cleveland for three minor-league pitchers. On Saturday night, the Indians dealt DeRosa to the Cardinals for Chris Perez and a player to be named later (hereafter, PTBNL). The three minor-league pitchers, the Cubs got in the deal were:
- Chris Archer, RH starter … 2-2, 3.19 ERA in Low-A.
- Jeff Stevens, RH reliever … 0-3, 2.52 ERA in Triple-A.
- John Gaub, LH reliever … 3-1, 2.83 ERA in Double-A, now up in Triple-A.
Miles, the switch-hitting utility infielder, is hitting .203 with four RBIs for the Cubs this season. DeRosa has 13 homers and 50 RBIs for Cleveland this season. The deal wasn’t a straight swap at all, but over at MLB.com the lede of the news story about trading DeRosa nailed the actuality of the moves: “It won’t show up in the transactions as an even Aaron Miles-for-Mark DeRosa swap, but that’s what the Cubs essentially did on Wednesday.” That sort of sums up what happened Saturday night — the Cardinals completed a three-team with DeRosa as a PTBNL.
The tale of the transactions, told as if they were parts of a trade:
- Cubs acquire Miles from Cardinals, and three minor-league pitchers from Cleveland.
- Cleveland acquires Chris Perez and PTBNL from Cardinals.
- Cardinals acquire DeRosa.
Guess it will take some time before it’s clear who got the best of the three-team de facto swap. But for now, consider it the first (unofficial) trade before the division rivals Cardinals and Cubs since pitcher Jeff Fassero came south in a deal on August 25, 2002.
-30-


Derrick Goold said he was going to Mizzou for capital-J journalism, but after growing up in the Time Zone Baseball Forgot he was really drawn to MU sitting between two major-league cities. Goold joined the Post-Dispatch in 2001 after working for The Times-Picayune and Rocky Mountain News, covering sports from LSU to NHL and every level of baseball in between.
We can’t afford to lose Wallace for a bunch a washed up’s.
Call me “indifferent” to this move. The Cardinals couldn’t get Chris Perez to be their future closer so Cleveland now gets a try. The Cardinals get a veteran who can play as many positions as Tony LaRussa wants (see Aaron Miles) and a bat that is good enough for a middle infielder (see Khalil Greene). This move won’t make an impact if you are looking for the Cardinals to go on a winning tear now, but this move will best be felt over the course of the season, when Tony LaRussa mixes, matches, & can go to a Mark DeRosa instead of a Joe Thurston. A win here or there that might have been a loss for this club with its current record: that will be the impact.
Good deal, Mo—we get a guy that can play all over the infield and the outfield too. TLR likes this kind of guy. Decent BA, has some pop and is a solid citizen in the clubhouse. Good Deal, MO!!
Now let’s get greedy. How does this sound for an October line up? Schumaker(OF), DeRosa(2B), Pujols(1B), Tejada(SS), Glaus(3B), Ludwick(OF), Molina(C), Pitcher, Rasmus(OF). Tejada could be had relatively cheaply and knows how to drive in runs. He may hit only a few HR’s, but Glaus can pick up that slack. Throw in Carpenter, Wainwright and Loshe and we would have an excellent chance in any series.
Great move,Mo!…now let’s drop Thurston off in Memphis so he can be re-trained in baserunning and fielding on the way to Oakland for Holliday….or take him as trade bait….
Only the Cubs would think that acquiring Miles made DeRosa expendable.
And, I don’t get this infatuation with Holliday, he apparently cannot hit anywhere that isn’t in Denver.
havent opened a twitter account waitin till the clitter arrives i think ill like that better!