DG’s 10@10: Tipping Pitches & Setting Priorities
TOWER GROVE — The way Todd Wellemeyer describes it, he joined the St. Louis Cardinals at a vulnerable time in his career. He could not figure out why good stuff was getting bad results. He had just been hammered by the Detroit Tigers in consecutive games against them, and he was about to face the Tigers for a third time in four appearances after being a Cardinals’ waiver claim out of Kansas City’s pitching staff.
He thought the Tigers had his number. Wrong. They may have had his pitches.
“When I came in here,” Wellemeyer said during 2008’s spring training, gesturing around the room he shares with his Cardinals’ teammates, “half the clubhouse told me I was tipping my pitches.”
And there it was. Wellemeyer had really joined the club.
It has become a rite of passage for a new Cardinal pitcher: The Cleansing of the Tips. There are a handful of pitchers who have joined the Cardinals in recent seasons and after having some success — or, in a few cases, even before they have had their success — admit that they discovered, with the help of pitching coach Dave Duncan, manager Tony La Russa and Cardinals’ teammates, that they were … drum roll please … tipping pitches. John Smoltz is just the latest.
After the veteran’s nine-strikeout debut with the Cardinals on Sunday, one of the inevitable — and entirely plausible — explanations given for hims immediate success after sustained struggles in Boston was he tipped his pitches. From the stretch, Smoltz was doing something, most likely with his glove, to signal the hitter that an off-speed pitch was coming. Chris Carpenter helped identify it. Afterward, La Russa told reporters, per MLB.com: “It’s pretty clear he was tipping his pitches.”
The Cardinals make it a priority to pick up on these things.
Dating back to and beyond Jim Edmonds reading pitchers during live batting practice in spring training, Duncan has made a point of emphasis to eliminate tips. Duncan said the motivation for the awareness is simple: At some point a pitcher isn’t getting the production that matches the quality of his pitches. “That means there has to be another reason,” Duncan told me one spring training. Often, he and his players discover, that reason is a tell.
And, not to give away the theme here, is where today’s 10@10 begins …
1. Smoltz joins a laundry list of other pitchers who have had their tip deciphered and corrected by the Cardinals. That list includes three of the Cardinals’ current starters: Wellemeyer (on the DL), Joel Pineiro and Kyle Lohse. Pineiro was giving away his off-speed pitches with his glove. Lohse was tipping his off-speed pitches by flaring his glove. Wellemeyer would hold his glove lower toward his belt when he was going to throw a fastball. Some others who the Cardinals suggested were tipping pitches included Mike Maroth, who spent some time in the video room with Albert Pujols to learn how he was giving away stuff. “I know one thing,” La Russa said of the lefty. “They know what’s coming because we’re calling it from the bench.” Back in 2005, Matt Morris once explained away a funk by revealing that he, too, was tipping pitches with his glove position. He said it was something he had to fight a few times in his career. Even this past spring, Chris Perez learned he was tipping pitches. When he was about to throw a curveball, he looked into his glove at his grip. He didn’t check when he was throwing a fastball. Deadpanned Duncan one spring: “It makes a difference when the hitter doesn’t know what’s coming.”
2. Especially when it’s an effective split-finger fastball. Revisiting Smoltz’s debut one more time, it was striking how many times he fired a filthy split-finger fastball and one of the San Diego Padres swung over it. He had his signature pitch humming, and the numbers bear that out. The muscular stat web site FanGraphs allows us to compare the effectiveness of his pitches as a Cardinal (in five innings, granted) vs. what he did with the Red Sox this season. Leave it to you to decipher the tell in these statistics:
Fastball … in BOS: 42.1 % effectiveness, 91.3 mph … in STL: 41.3%, 92.1 mph
Slider … in BOS: 36.2% effectiveness, 84.6 mph … in STL: 40.0%, 84.5 mph
Splitter … in BOS: 9.7% effectiveness, 85.7 mph … in STL: 16.0%, 86.9 mph
3. On Bernie Miklasz’s radio show Monday, Cardinals general manager John Mozeliak made reference to shifting gears after the signing of Shelby Miller – who will be introduced to the media and Duncan today at Busch — and the courtship of Smoltz to the in-house stack of pending free agents. He said he would hoped to have some “dialogue”, at least, before the end of the season. (You can hear the interview by clicking the above link.) There are seven players of note who will be free agents at the end of the season, from breakout starter Joel Pineiro to backup catcher Jason LaRue. If we accept that outfielder Matt Holliday is the big free-agent fish that the Cardinals will attempt to hook and that the pursuit will likely seep into the offseason, then the remaining six pose an intriguing lineup of priorities for the Cardinals. That inspires two polls (take note of the verbs):
4. And, of course, the follow-up poll:
5. Adam Wainwright takes a second shot tonight at setting a new career high with a 15th victory of the season. That’s not the only number of note tonight. With six innings in tonight’s start, Wainwright will have 25 consecutive starts of at least six innings, and the only Cardinals in the past 55 years with longer streaks are Bob Gibson and Chris Carpenter. Wainwright also has allowed two earned runs or fewer in 11 consecutive starts. That ties Gibson for the second-longest streak by a Cardinal since 1954. In his game-changing MVP/Cy Young season of 1968, Gibson had 11 consecutive starts with two or fewer earned runs. The longest streak by a Cardinal in the past 50 years started in 1987 when John Tudor began 15 consecutive starts of two or fewer earned runs.
6. The Cardinals went 5-2 on the West Coast despite getting minimal, even lethargic, production from the middle of their order. The trio of righthanded batters that hit Nos. 3-4-5 in the Cardinals’ lineup went a combined 14-for-73 with three home runs and 10 RBIs. They hit .192 as a trio. Two of them can take comfort in a return home for a nine-game home stand that begins tonight at Busch Stadium:
No. 3 Albert Pujols … on trip: 4-for-24, 2 HR, 2 RBI … .167/.355/.417
@ home … .328 BA, .707 SLG
No. 4 Matt Holliday … on trip: 4-for-23, 1 HR, 5 RBI … .174/.355/.391
@ home … .472 BA, .830 SLG
No. 5 Ryan Ludwick … on trip: 6-for-26, 0 HR, 3 RBI … .231/.286/.231
@ home … .238 BA, .356 SLG
7. FARMNIK REPORT: Troy Glaus, starting at third base, was part of a power show for Class AAA Memphis on Monday. Glaus, the rehabbing former All-Star, hit the second home run of his rehab assignment, and his was one of five that the Redbirds hit in a 12-7 victory. Four of those home runs were hit in consecutive at-bats. All off former major-league relieve Armando Benitez. The others who hit homers included Nick Stavinoha, his 11th; Allen Craig, his 23rd; Mark Hamilton, his sixth; and Daniel Descalso, his second. The four batters who hit homers in consecutive at-abt were Glaus, Craig, Hamilton and Descalso. … Glaus went 1-for-4 with the homer, two runs scored, two walks and a strikeout. On his rehab assignment with Triple-A Memphis he’s hitting .194 overall. He’s batting .148 on his current rehab assignment. … Hamilton, one of the few lefthanded-power options the Cardinals have at their highest level, went 3-for-4. He’s hit 14 home runs total this season, split over two levels. … Jaime Garcia, who missed most of the season to recover from Tommy John surgery, got his first Triple-A win of the season in the same game. He pitched five innings and allowed six runs (one earned) on four hits. He walked two and struck out four. … Andrew Brown hit a two-run home run in the 11th to power the Class AA Springfield Cardinals to a 5-3 victory at home. Brown went 2-for-5. … James Rapoport reached base five times. He went 3-for-5 with a couple doubles and he walked twice to go with two RBIs. … Jesse Simpson struck out eight in his start for short-season Batavia. Simpson, a Baton Rouge native, was a 40th-round pick in this summer’s draft. … Scott Schneider, a 20th-round pick in the recent draft, also struck out eight. The St. Mary’s College alum did so in his seven innings of work for Low-A Quad Cities. He walked none, gave up four hits and took the loss because he allowed one earned run and the QC River Bandits couldn’t answer against Peoria. Schneider, a righty, has a 1.08 ERA in his first 58 1/3 pro innings.
8. Quick links: SI.com’s Jon Heyman ponders what would be the best World Series matchups that he’d like to see. There in his top five is one with the Cardinals and without any historical significance. He’d like to see La Russa square off against Mike Scioscia. … St. Louis native and Philadelphia Phillies slugger Ryan Howard, who has begun is annual surge to and through September, became the fastest player to 600 RBIs since Ted Williams, according to the Elias Sports Bureau. Howard got his 600th career RBI in his 693rd game. Williams got there in 675. … For the record, Albert Pujols got to 600 RBIs in his 752nd game. … Chicago Tribune columnist Rick Morrissey puts the blame for the Cubs’ chaos on the manager Lou Piniella and his patience, and across town at the Sun-Times Rick Telander gives a list of suggestions for the Cubs new owner. Check out No. 4.
9. One other quick thing from Elias: Smoltz is the ninth former Cy Young Award winner to pitch for La Russa. Smoltz actually tips the balance. La Russa has now managed more Cy Young winners after they won the award then during the season they won the award. Four of the pitchers have won the Cy Young with La Russa as their manager — Carpenter (2005), Dennis Eckersley (1992), Bob Welch (1990) and LaMarr Hoyt (1983). The four other pitches that La Russa managed after their Cy Young seasons were Sparky Lyle, Tom Seaver, Fernando Valenzuela and Pat Hentgen. The latter two were with him as Cardinals.
10. It was a stream of consciousness line way at the bottom of his weekly and lengthy missive on the NFL, but something Peter King wrote in his Monday Morning Quarterback got some mileage yesterday here in Baseball City. King wrote: “Said it before and I’ll say it again: Derek Jeter’s the best baseball player of my lifetime.” Take that and misquote it Jim Rice. We baseball writers have been accused of romancing and moralizing on our beat — in general, I suppose, being the A&E to our colleague’s Spike TV — but when I was told that I may be asked about this Jeter pronouncement on a radio show yesterday it got me thinking. Perhaps the esteemed football writer is younger than we thought, or maybe he values championships over all things. The latter certainly has merit. You all know I’ve been accused of being a Jeter honk/apologist/campaign manager in the St. Louis press box. As I thought who the best player of my lifetime is, however, it’s hard to shake the image of Ken Griffey Jr. skating through Seattle’s center fielder or sweetly upper-cutting a ball into the seats. And that’s just to start. Heck, there are a few guys in their prime right now that fit the definition.
Still, it’s an interesting question: Who is the best player of your lifetime?
-30-


Derrick Goold said he was going to Mizzou for capital-J journalism, but after growing up in the Time Zone Baseball Forgot he was really drawn to MU sitting between two major-league cities. Goold joined the Post-Dispatch in 2001 after working for The Times-Picayune and Rocky Mountain News, covering sports from LSU to NHL and every level of baseball in between.
Griffey is a good one, but I’m going to be a homer and say Pujols. He needs to keep doing it, but so far, he’s the best baseball player I’ve seen.
ST. LOUIS: MEET JOHNATHAN A. SMOLTZ
By: John Traveler
SPECIAL TO STLTODAY.COM AND THE ST. LOUIS POST-DISPATCH
At exactly 1:33 p..m. local time in San Diego, future Hall of Famer John Smoltz (1-0) took the mound on Sunday afternoon to make his St. Louis Cardinals debut. There were no parades, no live TV look-ins from other broadcasts and to be honest not really more press fanfare than usual for a Sunday afternoon game in San Diego. Despike the like of national exposure, what did walk onto the mound with Smoltz though were the hopes and dreams of every Cardinal fan currently living. Aginast the Padres Smoltz was good, you could even argue that he was great with the exception of the amount of innings he threw (five) in what would wind up being his first win as a Redbird and more importantly the capper game for a first-place club rapping up a 5-2 west coast road trip. Most people know the Smoltz who had been awarded a Cy Young while with the Braves, won over 200 career games and closed out over 150 in a magical 20+ season career. Those things are great to explore, but in today’s column we will take a closer look at some of the other moments involving Smoltz as a Major League ballplayer.
Before Smoltz ever threw a pitch in the big leagues, he was traded from the Detroit Tigers to the Atlanta Braves in exchange for the aging Doyle Alexander. Smoltz, who had played both baseball and basketball at a very high level while in high school, was actually disappointed at the time of the trade as he had been thrilled to be drafted in the 22nd round of the 1985 amateur draft by the Tigers who were his favorite team growing up. None-the-less, Smoltz had been traded from a contending franchise to a club that had been on a down-swing for several seasons.. Little would Smoltz know that in his prime, the Braves would actually be the club who would rise to the top and Detroit would go on to struggle throughout the nineties.
Many people know or at least would recall that Smoltz was one of the starting pitchers on the Braves’ 1991 team that lost to the Minnesota Twins in the World Series (clue Jack Buck’s call “And we’ll see you tomorrow night”) but what they might not know is the little fact that even though Smoltz had been in the majors for a couple of seasons already, he was almost sent down to the minor leagues mid-season that year. Smoltz had started 1991 with a 2-11 record, which was at the time the worst record by a big league pitcher in the winning percentage statistical column on the year. He began to struggle with his confidence and question his control when he was encouraged by manager Bobby Cox to consider seeing a sports psychologist. Rather than biting his manager’s head off at the time, the pitcher who would be later known as a bit of a bulldog, bit his tongue and sought out professional help. After doing so, he turned his season around to finish 14-13 overall (12-2 down the stretch). From that point on, Smoltz was the one other people began going to for advice when they struggled with anxiety or general problems on or off the field…
Smoltz went on to become the pitcher we all know and think of today. In doing so, he became an individual who most ballplayers consider to be one of the best golfers and bowlers playing in the big leagues. Off the field, Smoltz is a family man and a born-again Christian whom is very active in his Georgia Presbyterian church. He is friends with guys like comedian Jeff Foxworthy, Boston Celtics head coach Doc Rivers and has assisted in multiple political campaigns in support of Georgia politicians. But the reason I have always liked and respected John Smoltz has nothing to do with what he’s accomplished on the field or as a celebrity. In 2007, Smoltz was awarded the Branch Rickey Award for exceptional community service. At the time of the award ceremony, which was presented at the 2007 Baseball Winter Meetings in Nashville, Tenn., Smoltz said he was more happy to receive the Rickey Award than he was the day he was awarded his only Cy Young. As I sat in the crowd with a cold meal in front of me that management had paid for as part of the winter meetings, I learned more about Smoltz over my salad turning brown than I had ever known to that date. He spoke about how humbled he was just to be given a chance to make a difference and how honored he was to just be considered for the award. Smoltz reminded me a lot of (to localize it) a baseball version of what Kurt Warner does away from the spotlight..
I guess what I’m getting at with all of this is one simple fact: the Cardinals have done it again. Time after time this ball club has brought in classy players who do it all. Of course we know about Albert Pujols, but don’t forget about what a lot of the other guys on the club do as well to help the community. And of course, do NOT overlook the wives of many Cardinal players who go the extra mile to help the area when they don’t have to. Thank you Cardinal management, for bringing in another star who is also a gentlemen. If Smoltz never has another shining moment with the home team, he’s already been a bargain. I figure with Chris Carpenter making just over 13 million this season, that’s right around $100,000 per strikeout. Smoltz signed for $100,000 and has struck out nine (just over $10,000 per K). I’m not saying anything negative on Carpenter, he should win another Cy Young Award this year in my opinion, I’m just demonstrating exactly what a bargain both on AND off the field Smoltz is. In a perfect world, he continues to excel this year and helps St. Louis win another World Series and retires…that’s the exit party he deserves.
From one John to another…Good luck sir!
Thank you for reading today’s column, tune in again tomorrow on the 10@10 to read about some of the baseball announcers from the west coast (5-2!) road trip the Cardinals just came off of.
JT
johntraveler@rocketmail.com
-30-
Wow John-not often is a “comment” longer than the posted story.
I was only 2 when Musial retired. Griffey was great no question. I don’t care, as far as I am concerned Albert Pujols is the greatest player of my lifetime. Look at his stats and then remember - he is the best player and he works as hard or harder than any guy on the team. He brigs so much more to the game than just his stats. He is the baseball equivalent of Michael Jordan - he has the talent and the drive to go with it. Albert is the best. On top of all of that he is a good man, don’t discount that when talking about great players.
I know the Cards could always use a day off, but days without 10 @ 10 seem to have wayyyy more than 24 hours in them.
Nicely done Mr. Goold.
BTW, I’d like to see the Cards put Glaus on the roster come 8/31, replacing Joe Thurston, for a potential DH spot. It isn’t fair to Thurston and Glaus may not be ready, but Thurston has zero chance of contributing in the post season so why not?
Derrick — RE: Smoltz tipping his pitches…
If all the AL hitters could see how he tipped his pitches (apparently they did, that’s why they pounded him), and if Carp and Duncan spotted it immediately… Why didn’t Boston’s hitters see it, ane even more so their pitching coach and fellow pitchers? Was Boston really the only clueless group out there? Seems rather hard to believe…
My lifetime is longer than most. During the 40s and early 50s, think you’d have to say Stan Musial and ted Williams (although Williams only as a hitter). In the later 50s and early 60s, think you’d have to say Willie Mays (Mantle a distant second). I think of the rest of the 60s as a pitchers’ decade, so Gibson and Koufax. 70s, probably Johnny Bench and Frank Robinson. Not sure who would be the pick in the 80s. The best player in the 90s was Barry Bonds, even before he became larger than life, somewhat above Griffey. And I think Albert is the player of this decade, with Rodrigues slightly behind. Two other names worth mentioning in this pantheon — Steve Carlton and Roger Clemens.
There is no question that if Pujols continues reasonably close to his current pace, stays out of the glare of steroids and plays for say a minimum of 12 - 15 season with good health….forget about anybody else…he is the “mang”
Firstly, it seems to me that checking for pitch tipping should be something EVERY team does. It’s amazing to me that no one in their previous organizations caught this before we did. I think we can add Izzy to this list of pitch tippers. If I recall, he was tipping his pitches when he got here and even then was virtually unhittable. Yes, that Izzy. Secondly, did we just give away a great secret. After the spectacular debut of Smoltz, how many managers are scrambling to set up procedures to catch tippers?
You paint with a wide brush on the question of best player of a lifetime. Just watching Jeter, he’d have to be a great teammate for sure. Pujols brings alot to the table. Gibson was a great pitcher, didn’t look like a good teammate. No doubt having Mays on your team was a fantastic assest. In the end it has to be Pete Rose, (scratch what he did as a manager) but what he brought to the team is, “play hard and win”. I absolutely hated watching him play against the Cardinals but he was a player to never under estimate or over look. I can imagine he was a horrible teammate but you were darn glad he was on your team. And played where ever he was needed.
24yrs 4256 hits .303 lifetime avg. 3562 games 746 doubles 15861 plate appearances to only 1143 k’s are some amazing numbers.