Carpenter: Wainwright Deserves Cy Young
DENVER — The last race left for the St. Louis Cardinals before the end of the regular season may have come to a sudden end Saturday night, too, as Adam Wainwright gained a hearty endorsement for his Cy Young candidacy.
It came from arguably his chief rival for the award: teammate Chris Carpenter.
“If that game right there doesn’t solidify him as the best pitcher in the league, then I’m can’t imagine what would,” Carpenter said, goggles perched on his forehead, sticky from the Cardinals’ clinching celebration. “I think that’s what it’s all about. That game, that eighth inning, and everything he did tonight. That’s what you want: Your big stud on the mound. Big game. Big situation. And he comes through.”
In a clear sign of his support of his most consistent starter and Wainwright’s place on the team, manager Tony La Russa left the righthander out to decide the game. Wainwright threw a career-high 130 pitches, and none bigger than a curveball to Jason Giambi that ended the threat in the eighth inning. Holding on to a one-run lead, Wainwright faced Giambi with the tying run at second base. The go-ahead run was at first base. The inning was sliding away from him — until it wasn’t.
He froze Clint Barmes for the second out of the inning, and on his 130th pitch of the game, he froze Giambi with a curve ball the former MVP would later argue was low. That was his 89th strike of the game. For perspective: Carpenter threw only 12 more pitches total Friday night than strikes Wainwright threw Saturday.
Third baseman Mark DeRosa and others likened it to Wainwright’s signature pitch: The curveball that froze New York back in 2006 when he K’d Carlos Beltran with the bases loaded to win the pennant.
Carpenter saw it as a clincher of another sort.
“He got 130 pitches into that game and he kept grinding and grinding and making big pitch after big pitch and then a bigger pitcher,” Carpenter said. “That is what it means to be the best pitcher in the league, and in a lot of ways that’s what his whole season has been like. He’s just been grinding out games like that all year.”
Wainwright held the Rockies 0-for-11 with runners in scoring position and he struck out 11 batters in his eight innings. The win gave him 19 for the season and gives him a chance to be the major leagues’ first (and likely only) 20-game winner in his final start of the regular season. He has a career-high 204 strikeouts to go with what will likely be a league-leading total in innings pitched, not to mention those lengthy streaks of starts he had with at least six innings and no more than two earned runs.
The Cy Young Award has been boiled down to a three-man race, with each having his say in the past three weeks or so. Just when San Francisco Giants ace Tim Lincecum would pull ahead, Carpenter would chase him down. Those two — both having won the award before — had been getting most of the press. Wainwright may have the better claim. As a scout recently told me about the three pitchers: “Consistency and being there for the team every five days has to count for something. Wainwright has done that.”
Sometime Saturday, a normal regular season game that really didn’t mean as much as it felt it did transcended its stature, and that probably had a lot to do with Wainwright staying in the game, staying in to close out his win and to clinch the NL Central title for the Cardinals.
That’s how La Russa saw it: “He might have won the award in the eighth inning.”
That’s how Carpenter sees it.
But not just because of the eighth.
“This is what he did all year for us,” Carpenter said. “Night after night, start after start, to do what he did and then did again tonight, 100 percent he should win it. One hundred percent he’s the one.”
***
Much more on this and the clinching in Sunday’s Post-Dispatch and online at StlToday.com
-30-


Derrick Goold said he was going to Mizzou for capital-J journalism, but after growing up in the Time Zone Baseball Forgot he was really drawn to MU sitting between two major-league cities. Goold joined the Post-Dispatch in 2001 after working for The Times-Picayune and Rocky Mountain News, covering sports from LSU to NHL and every level of baseball in between.
Good stuff. Thanks DG
I’m loving these piecemeal updates following the HUGE clincher.
The clincher will be if Wainwright wins his 20th game his next turn. Win it; he wins the CY. I have seen Lincecum pitch on MLB Extra Innings. I would vote Wainwright CY. Lincecum is a much smoother pitcher.
With all the talk of Carp - Lincecum - (maybe) Wainwright, I’ve been wondering when Waino would get his due as the leader. Looks like he has.
ESPN’s CY predictor has Wainwright pretty far out front, Carp at 3rd, and Franklin at 6th. Not too shabby.
Carpenter is about as classy as they come…Waino derserves the Cy Young but for someone with Carp’s pedigree AND performance this year to endorce him shows he is the leader and Ace of this staff. We’re lucky to have BOTH of them!
A strong & gutsy performance by Wainwright. 1589 pitches since the All Star break for Adam. While I would be really excited for AW to win the Cy I am hoping his manager gives him an extra day or two off followed by a short outing with a pitch count. Post season success and his future health are much more important than an award.
I hope Wainwright can come even close to matching Carpenter’s class and loyalty to the Cardinal organization and his teammates. Early signs look positive. What a great bunch of guys. I’m so proud of them. They are very talented, yet, but Carpenter’s is the kind of leadership and class that you just don’t see every day. I am smiling ear to ear with these guys. Stories like this should be reported more often.
Last night during the 8th inning I thought that the only reason Tony would leave him in was so if he got thru the inning it would be a defining moment where he could be regarded by the national media as a Cy Young caliber pitcher. I think it worked.
I was at the game last night and I am STILL in awe of this: They announced Giambi as the pinch hitter, the crowd is going nuts and the infielder gather at the mound to (presumably) discuss the Giambi strategy. I noticed quickly that Waino was easily 20 feet back behind the mound glaring at home plate. When the infielders went back to position, he still had the death glare and punched the ball into his glove and stalked to the mound to strike him out and WIN the game and the award……..WOW!
What a class move by Chris, to essentially give up his candidacy for Waino.
But notice what else this does, it removes the Cy Young as a possible source of division and unites the pitching staff and the team for a post season run.