Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.12.2008 9:01 pm

PostCards Live! Edmonds goes Ivy?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

GRAND CENTER — Both Chicago papers are reporting that Jim Edmonds could be a Cub shortly after he flies off waivers this week, having been released over the weekend by San Diego. A signature Cardinal — one of several members of the 2004 pennant-winning team to have a tough weekend (Julian Tavarez, for example) — is said to be attractive to the Cubs as an option other than youngster Felix Pie in Wrigley Field’s center field.

The Chicago Sun-Times Gordon Wittenmyer reports this evening that:

… multiple Cubs sources said the team plans to pursue Edmonds, and one said Edmonds has told his agent to talk to no one before he talks to the Cubs. The Cubs have considered a left-handed bat a need for weeks.

 On The Chicago Tribune baseball blog, Hardball, Cubs beater writer Paul Sullivan (and noted Mizzou alum), posited the possible move to readers and was hit immediately by this comment: “Once a Cardinal, always a Cardinal.” Sullivan outlined a few reasons, like Edmonds’ 17 homers at Wrigley (including the one that left Carlos Zambrano yelling at him as he rounded the bases), and:

Looking strictly at the numbers, it doesn’t appear to be worth the risk. Edmonds hit .178 with a .265 on-base percentage for the Padres, and seems to be past his prime, turning 38 next month. On the other hand, he does have a .298 career average against right-handers, and they’d only have to pay Edmonds the major league minimum.

Some thoughts from the Green Room here:

Max Leinwand: “Jimmy Ballgame, playing for the Cubbies? … That’s like the Montagues playing for the Capulets’ softball team.”

Jim Hayes: “If Edmonds thinks he can still play and if somewhere deep down he feels he’s was wronged by the Cards, it seems like the move for them. … I texted him to find out what he’s going to do, and I’ve gotten no response. So I’m waiting. Jimmy if you read this blog, text me.

“Talking with Skip Schumaker and Anthony Reyes, who worked out with him in the offseason, said he looked like he was in great shape. They said, that he was determined to show he can still play. Supposedly that’s why he went to San Diego because he wanted to be a starting center fielder. So obviously he did think he was going to play.

“I did talk to a bunch of Cardinals in Milwaukee and they all feel he’ll show up somewhere, on somebody’s roster. That report (the Cubs) had not surfaced at that point.”

Aside: One of the reasons the Cardinals and Edmonds decided to part company this offseason was because Edmonds wanted to start and the Cardinals could not guarantee that the rise of Colby Rasmus or arrival of Rick Ankiel would not mean the shift to part-time status for Edmonds. Late last season, one Cardinals official said that as he looked at 2008 he saw Ankiel as the starting center fielder, even if Edmonds was still on the team.

Pat Parris: “As long as he doesn’t mind his restaurant and club closing because there is no way Cardinals fans will patronize a Cub-players’ establishment. … I do not think he has it in him. If the Cubs are trying to get some veteran guy in there to spell Pie, I think that’s a mistake. Pie just has to fight through the mistakes of being a young outfielder. Why would you take the at-bats away from Pie?”

Hayes: “All I know, is if it were to happen it would spice-up the next series. It would make for good theater. Now let’s talk about Team 1380.”

-30-

23 comments

Comments are closed.

I think the cubs have better luck with Felix than jimmy. Jim has like 1 more season in him while Felix many left in him

— Eric
9:59 pm May 12th, 2008

For the last two-plus seasons, Edmonds has shown increasingly that he’s a strikeout machine, is injury-prone and suspect on defense. I think he’ll be patrolling a small patch of center field in Wrigley for the next 4-5 years! That’s Cub baseball as Cardinal fans have come to know and love it for generations. Seriously, this would be a classically bad move for the Cubs. Even better, he gets hot for a week or two when he first arrives, and then they’ll stick with him all summer! Imagine signing a guy who just got cut by the worst team in baseball.

— Fuhrig
1:32 am May 13th, 2008

The image of Jim Edmonds roaming center field of Wrigley is like trying to picture a beer vendor at Busch Stadium yelling “Old Style!” Jimmy will go down as one of the Cardinal greats, but something just feels wrong — almost sacrilegious — about the idea of him playing for the archrival. I do hope Edmonds finds a starting job again… but ANYWHERE besides the North Side!

— Patrick Morris
1:43 am May 13th, 2008

Could Edmonds and Zambrano share the same dugout? Hasn’t he always had difficulty patrolling CF at Wrigley? That said, if they only pay him league-minimum I don’t see how that would be a bad move for the profligate Cubs Organization if they need a LH bat.

— Nickols
8:23 am May 13th, 2008

Edmonds to the North Side could be just the thing for MLB to force the [four-letter word] out of Weeghman Park. With the way Edmonds plays defense and the lack of padding on the brick outfield walls, I can easily envision a career-ending, perhaps even life-threatening, injury.

— Geoff [not Blum]
9:06 am May 13th, 2008

I can think of no other team I’d rather see Edmonds pull down. Do it, Chicago.

— DStaigl
9:35 am May 13th, 2008

Cardinal Nation will never forgive you Jimmy.

— JLE
9:50 am May 13th, 2008

I really hope that Jimmy Ballgame doesn’t make such a foolish decision. It will be very difficult to cheer and support him if he does become a small bear, especially when they are playing against the Cardinals! I hope that he finds a place to play, and does well…but please, please don’t play for the rotten Cubs!

— JWS
10:14 am May 13th, 2008

I cannot imagine ever owning a Cubs shirt with “Edmonds” on the back. I am a Cubs fan, and trust me, I am just as unhappy as Edmonds fans about the talk of this move. But if this how Jimmy wants to get back at the Cardinals, then so be it. Lets watch how fast a dedicated fan base turns on him. And mark my words, if he doesnt produce the Cubs will not be afraid to cut their losses with this one. We have other options……..

— CubbieBear
10:34 am May 13th, 2008

Sheesh I hope the Cubs don’t bother with Edmonds. The last thing they need is a washed up old timer who can’t even make the cut in San Diego. Who’s next on the scouting report? Matt Morris?

— b
10:49 am May 13th, 2008

Pages: [1] 2 3 » Show All