Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
08.04.2008 1:31 pm

“Breaking Dawn”: Teens respond and is the saga really over?

Post-Dispatch Book Editor
  • Email this
  • Print this

partybreaking_opt.jpgSt. Louis teens who stayed up for “Dawn” (if not until dawn) seemed delighted Monday with the final book in the Stephenie Meyer paranormal romance series.

Rosie Ruzicka, who bought her copy of “Breaking Dawn” at a Borders at South County mall, hadn’t finished the book but said she is happy with the final book.

“It’s amazing. I didn’t think someone could stretch a vampire love story out four books but she could. It’s suspense all the way through.”

Rosie is going to be a sophomore at Kirkwood High School this fall. She said there were at least 200 people waiting to buy “Breaking Dawn” Friday night and some were dressed as characters.

“It was pretty fun . . . strangers were hugging other strangers. People were grabbing empty boxes that “Breaking Dawn” was in. They were taking the box home with them. “I was happy enough with my book.”

Another sophomore, Sierra Horton, “made a rose out of black duct tape” at a smaller party at the Kirkwood Public Library Friday night. Sierra finished reading the book Saturday afternoon and now her mom is reading it.

“I’m a quick reader.”

The story features Bella a human teen and her two love interests, Edward the vampire and Jacob the werewolf. “Dawn” is basically PG-13, says Sierra. (But we’re not giving away any more of the ending on this blog).

Sierra says her boyfriend, an 18-year-old at Fort Leonard Wood, has started the four-book series and says fellow Army recruits are asking to borrow “Twilight.” He wants her to ship him the rest of the series.

Across the country, the final book in the “Twilight” saga - which has been the hottest book series since the end of “Harry Potter,” sold about 1.3 million on Aug. 2.

Publishers Weekly reports that is a record first-day sales performance for a Hachette publishing group book and that Little, Brown Books for Young Readers went back to press for a second printing of 500,000 copies just before publication of the title, bringing the total number in print to 3.7 million.

Publishers Weekly also reported Monday that among the major bookselling outlets, only Borders reported first-day sales figures for “Breaking Dawn,” announcing that it sold about 250,000 copies of the book. The first three titles in the “Twilight” saga have sold 8.5 million copies in the U.S. (Borders is reluctant to give info on specific stores, but observers in the St. Louis area have so far reported 200-500 or so attendees at parties.) These aren’t the numbers of “Harry Potter,” but still, nothing to sniff at.

The book series has not had the publicity support of movies, but that will change in December when “Twilight” comes to the screen. For Sierra, who “loved the ending” of “Breaking Dawn,” the movies don’t improve a good book series:

“The Harry Potter movies ruined the books for me.” She knows she might be in the minority of fans, but she says: “I’m not going to see the ‘Twilight.’

meyer_opt.jpgMeanwhile, the saga may not be totally over: Meyer says she is working on “Midnight Sun,” which tells the story of “Twilight” from Edward the vampire’s point of view. And Little, Brown says it will publish “The Twilight Saga: The Official Guide” on Dec. 30. The hardcover will include new material, character profiles and genealogical charts to provide Meyer’s fans with more insight into the series, according to PW magazine.

Edward certainly seems to be St. Louis teen readers’ favorite between the guys vying for Bella. Without giving away the ending, please, what do you think of the new book and which supernatural lover would you end it with: Edward or Jacob?

ABOVE PHOTO: From left, Bailey Richardson, 18, of St. Charles, Tori Hamric, 19, of St. Charles, Kacey Shoemake, 17, of St. Peters, Colleen Holden, 18, of St. Charles, and Taylor Trice, 15, of St. Charles, play with bubbles while waiting for the start of the Stephenie Meyer “Breaking Dawn” book release party Aug. 1 at Border’s in St. Peters. Photo by Sarah Conard

11 comments

Comments are closed.

I am not a fan of Twilight, but I bought the first book and I will give it a try. Can y’all tell me if Breaking Dawn was a good ending to the series? I heard MANY bad reviews of it.

— not a fan
2:26 pm August 4th, 2008

Restless and unable to sleep Saturday night, I woke up and decided to go downstairs for a drink of water. I discovered it was actually Sunday morning — 2:15 a.m. — and a light was still on under my daughter’s door.

Yep. She was buried in this book after gobbling up the first two over our vacation at the beach the week before.

I had to insist that she turn off the light and get some sleep!

— Kurt Greenbaum
2:36 pm August 4th, 2008

Hi ‘not a fan’
You’ve heard bad reviews of the final book? Sierra Horton, a teen I interviewed, said she really liked the ending. She said it seemed like a true ending to the series. I wonder what folks said who didn’t like it - that they wanted a different future for Bella, a different guy, or what?
Anyway, I asked Sierra to give me the scoop on what happens and I must say I was surprised. It wasn’t what I would have predicted.

— Jane Henderson
4:45 pm August 4th, 2008

My honest review of the book was that it was good, had lots of unexpected twists, and was a little overrated. I read through the first 3 books quickly because of all the hype and with the exception of “twilight” i was more disappointed with each one. I am an older fan and have high expectations (but being an avid fan of the Harry Potter, I tried this series hearing they were somewhat similar).

Now don’t get me wrong, the book has it’s good qualities. Stephanie Meyer is a genius at portraying the love story in parts of BD, but leaves much to the imagination, something she did not do in the first novel. The reference quotes before chapters were intriguing and at one point you are left watching Jacob change roles entirely and laughing out loud as he does it. Yet sadly the climax is anticlimactic and then the aftermath is done with the reader wanting more (the resolution only takes up about 10 pages). To sum up a series in that few of pages and with so many new questions, makes you wonder if she left it open to write more in the upcoming edward cullen series…

Again for many Im sure the finale was a success because they wanted it to be and they wanted the couple to live happily ever after. Yet for me and for others who take a good look at the writing and look past the obvious, they might take another viewpoint entirely.

— lc
7:03 pm August 4th, 2008

I loved the previous 3 books. However, I have to say that I am struggling to get through book 4. She lost her momentum at the beginning of the book. After the birth it was all downhill. I don’t want to read about Jacob! I want to read about Edward. He seems to have lost his personality in this book. Bella has gained strength and Edward has become a secondary character. Just not a good way to end the story!!!!!!
Very disappointed!!!!!

— tammy
1:21 pm August 6th, 2008

Totally a fan, read the first three books within the last two weeks and finished Breaking Dawn last night. A little predictable in some parts but still truely breathtaking. Oh for true love.

— Amanda
9:59 pm August 6th, 2008

Apparently there is an uprising of sorts against “Breaking Dawn.”
A lot of fans are disappointed in the book. But keep in mind that people who complain are often more vocal than those who are satisfied. (see the forums at http://www.thetwilightsaga.com)
Here’s part of a report from Publishers Weekly:

By John A. Sellers — Publishers Weekly, 8/7/2008 8:20:00 AM
Last weekend, Breaking Dawn, the highly anticipated fourth book in Stephenie Meyer’s Twilight Saga, broke some sales records, but also, it seems, a few hearts. According to Little, Brown, the novel sold 1.3 million copies on its pub date, August 2, the largest single-day sales in the company’s history, while BookScan reported that the book sold 834,000 copies last Saturday through the accounts it measures (usually about 70% of a book’s sales).

The novel went on sale at the stroke of midnight, and devoted fans crowded hundreds of bookstores nationwide at late-night release parties. However, Breaking Dawn didn’t meet the stratospheric expectations of every fan, and anguished and, in some cases, angry outcry has arisen this week—though the book appears to have just as many ardent defenders. The recently reopened message board on the Twilight series Web site has been very active, and on Amazon—where the novel remains ranked #1 in sales—the book has generated more than 1,600 reviews (nearly twice the reviews of the previous book, Eclipse) and more than 1,000 “customer discussions.” Unhappy readers expressed a variety of opinions, including incredulity with certain plot points or the way threads were tied up, while others felt the writing wasn’t as strong as in the previous books.

— Jane Henderson
10:39 am August 7th, 2008

The first three twilight books captivated me. I really grew to know and love the world of Forks and everyone in it. After reading Breaking Dawn, I was truly disappointed. What had happened to the characters that I had fallen in love with. It seems like their personalities got lost somewhere in between the upcoming deadline and the unbelievably high expectations of the fans themselves, including me. It was a “good” book, just not the “incredible” one that I had been counting on.
And, to “not a fan”:
Try reading the whole series and then Breaking Dawn for yourself. Everyone has different opinions.That was just mine. :)

— Debbie
4:28 pm August 14th, 2008

I started reading twilight out of pure boredom. I will honestly say from someone who really doesn’t enjoy reading all that much i was very surprised to find myself reading every chance i got. When i finished the book (thankfully so late in the series) i immediately went out and bought the second and then third book. I had finished the three in a matter of weeks and the proceeded to wait the year for the final. Now two days after finally having the time to buy the book i have finished and again, from someone who could care less about reading i am so disappointed to know that the story has, however good as it was, has come to an end. Its officially a sad day.

— beatless heart
4:47 am August 15th, 2008

Beatless Heart: It’s great that you found a series that was really captivating. Don’t give up on books: There are certainly more out there (and new paranormal romances in particular seem to be on the shelves every day).
Here’s a list of Stephenie Meyer “read-alikes” offered by the Kirkwood Public Library. Of course each author’s voice will be different. Maybe it won’t have the same appeal as Meyer’s, but on the other hand, you might find one you like better:

“Bloodline: Reckoning” / Kate Cary

“Blue Bloods” / Melissa de la Cruz

“A Certain Slant of Light” / Laura Whitcomb

“Freaks” / Annette Curtis Klause

“A Great and Terrible Beauty” / Libba Bray

“Jinx” / Meg Cabot

“Masquerade” / Melissa de la Cruz

“Midnight Predator” / Amelia Atwater-Rhodes

The Midnighters series by Scott Westerfield

(”The Secret Hour,” “Touching Darkness” and “Blue Noon”)

“The Minister’s Daughter” / Julie Hearn

“Poison” / Chris Wooding

Abhorsen series / Garth Nix

(”Sabríel,” “Lírael” and “Abhorsen”)

“Sunshine” / Robin McKinley

“Sweetblood” / Pete Hautman

The Uglies series / Scott Westerfeld

(”The Uglies,” “The Pretties” and “The Specials”)

“Valiant: A Modern Tale of Faerie” / Holly Black

“Wicked Lovely” / Melissa Marr

— Jane Henderson
4:27 pm August 15th, 2008

breaking dawn was her best book. the series was intriguing but if I read the word “forever” one more time…… teenagers are not in realty as it is, so the continuously read that vampires can be good and love and live forever. Well take them further into delusion. Further more, Stephenie Meyers is no J.K. Rowling. J.K. could/can write without being redundant. Her imagination is unequaled. Stephenie Meyers can pretend to write a series but really what was the series about? boy meets girl….girl continually questions her identity. And a teen age boy holding back physically until marriage? rare, but it happens. I’ll give Stephenie one thing, she didn’t do a bad job portraying the bonds of friendship among the werewolves. Read Breaking Dawn and forget the prior three books.

— paulette
12:16 am August 16th, 2008