Stephen Mansfield on Obama’s religion
Stephen Mansfield, author of several delightful and short biographies—George Whitefield, Winston Churchill, Booker T. Washington—along with spiritual biographies of George W. Bush and Barack Obama, contributes the “On Religion” piece in today’s USA Today: “Obama’s faith fits our times,” with the subtitle, “His big-tent approach reflects his diverse spiritual journey. And he is perfectly in step with the country he now leads.”
Mansfield walks us through the religious biography of President Obama, noting how his mother “made sure he experienced every type of religious expression, from Jewish to Hindu and from native Hawaiian to Buddhist, to name but a few.” Mansfield explains Obama’s brief pre-adolescent Islamic practice, and his eventual landing at Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago.
Mansfield argues that Obama’s faith is very parallel to the spiritual leanings of America where “the vast majority also believe that there might be many versions of the faith they embrace and that their faith might not be the only path to God. Indeed, Americans are less likely to believe that any single faith is the only path to God, and they are more likely to believe that there is truth in religions differing from their own than at any prior time in the nation’s history.”
Mansfield offers no word of censure to the “many paths” idea of religious plurality. He speaks of Obama’s hermeneutics without offering a word of critique as he plays the words of Jesus off the words of Paul: “Indeed, [Obama] feels free to lean to one Scripture verse over another, to approach gay rights, for example, from the loving words of Jesus in the Sermon on the Mount but not the bigotry of Paul in his letter to the Romans.”
But Mansfield offers no rebuttal to the idea that Paul and Jesus held contradictory ideas. Mansfield just throws it up there as an idea worthy of consideration and embrace.
Mansfield ends the piece with the “people get the leaders they deserve” line, acknowledging it as a timeworn maxim. But Mansfield isn’t using the maxim as a critique or a challenge to the people to be more, to think more, to reject pluralism, to embrace Christianity.
Mansfield seems to be arguing that religious pluralism is now simply a matter of fact, President Obama is in step with this fact, and, well—nothing else needs to be said.


Scott Lamb pastored Providence Baptist Church in St. Louis for seven years, and now serves as Director of Research for the President of The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Kentucky.
U.S. News and World Report provides the following link about Obama’s faith “moments” since becoming President. Click on “NEXT” on each screen to see all ten faith moments.
http://www.usnews.com/listings/ten-obama-faith-moments/intro
It appears to me that Obama does not belong to religions. Religions belong to him.
Scott - I guess on a positive note, religious pluralism has at least got the various faiths having a dialogue rather than an “I hate you b/c your not my religion” type of thing. But I agree, that pluralism will certainly dilute many faiths, especially those that are based on weak theology. I think the later is more damaging to religion than the former is a force for good. Ecumenism should continue, but the faiths should further enforce to their followers what they believe, why they believe, how they are different from other faiths, and how that faith has the truth of Christ.
Btw…Obama is not a representative of the way people are today religiously. He’s probably the worst example the author could have picked.
Scott,
For me, this is your best post I have experienced. Thank you. Clear and without judgement. Yet, you share a personal concern. Very powerful.
It is clear to me that I am of the current model of acceptance, committed to scripture and not to dogma. Paul is a good demonstration of this, the beginning of human influence into Jesus’ church, and an important revelation of the Bible.
Our faith begins with God and Jesus, our work begins with Paul and the others. Many will quote Paul as if he is Jesus. He is not. He is a testament of Jesus’ among us. His word is inspired, not divine. In his word we get that he has the spirit and that it is available to us through Jesus.
It is Jesus’ and Jesus’ word that is the source. It is not available to us through Paul. We are present to it as it is in Paul. We must choose it for ourself directly with Jesus and within the conversation he has with us.
Each of us comes to Jesus, and Jesus to us, through choice. Each from our own place. For me, this is the many paths.
It is unfortunate that it is made to mean something else. In particular, that some of us are certain what it is for another. Jesus warns us against this.
It is high time we stopped bending to these social groups impersonating religion. Face facts these are politically motivated social groups that want power in order to enrich themselves. We opted for civil government many years ago. Remember it is the Tory party that supported Hitler and claims that god is sovereign. Our government though representative in nature claims that the people are sovereign. Many of these Tory parties are in Union internationally joined to Fascists of many different colors. Most mainstream Christian religions renunciated Holy War hundreds of years ago but the Tory party and other fascists still use religion to rally supporters for the purpose of Holy War. We should have stood against holy war during World War Two but negilected to. Remember it is the President who is Commander in Chief of our Armed Forces but it is Congresses Military no one elses especially current or former Fascists, Imperialists, Royalists, or Communists. See many of these folks are engaged in Socialism through religious organizations it seems a Communist now prays. So lest you forget no religious test for office holders.
Mike,
You state:
… pluralism will certainly dilute many faiths, especially those that are based on weak theology.
How more diluted can the Christian faith become already? Isn’t the combination of Easter with Passover/Resurrection Day one of the most serious dilutions of the Christian faith? Shall we even get started with the mockery and truly disrespectful Holiday Christmas is to Christ? These are the very type things that have diluted the Christian faith, not Christians having open discussion with others and respect for others.
No one is saying that it is good to become unequally yoked with others such as marrying outside your religion for that would be very un-Christian thing to do. But then again most Christians don’t pay attention to most of what is instructed in scripture. Christians do a great job of diluting the Christian faith themselves without placing blame on anyone else. It is written how far we can go with those who do not share our same faith. Most every religion has these same guidelines and we have been given many example of this throughout scripture.
I love the open dialogue and the attempt to understanding of others. I think back and remember all the incorrect understanding that I had long ago about many different faiths that were such error. It’s fine not to believe in what others believe but at least we should not believe lies about others. For example, I did not even know that Jesus was even part of the Muslim faith nor did I know what they believed about Jesus. I did not know that they believed Jesus was born from the Virgin Mary among many other things. Learning these things did not cause my faith to grow weaker, it grew stronger as a Christian.
http://www.scribd.com/doc/14726700/What-Do-Muslims-Think-About-Jesus-
Knowing Muslims and learning things about their faith has made me more understanding wiser and less fearful of their beliefs. Muslim worship certainly is not the worship of some other god as so many Christian leaders have made claim. As I have stated knowing these things have only made my Christian faith grow stronger. In fact, I know many Muslims who have come to accept Christ as their Lord and Savior. There’s much that Muslims and Christians have in common just as we all have much in common with the Jewish religions. For me everything makes more sense through my understanding of who Christ is as disclosed in the Bible. It is very interesting learning who Jesus was through the Jewish, Muslim and Christian faiths and is certainly no reason for anyone to hate another because of the different beliefs that they hold.
I truly believe that Christians not worshipping God and Christ in spirit and in truth is what have disgusted others about Christians. Many of the practices and beliefs that we have taken on are unscriptural and untrue and we know it but treat it as true. Can you imagine how this causes others to see us? We live many lies as Christians and that is never of good. When non Christians actually pick up a Bible and start reading and studying it, then look at how Christians worship Christ and our behavior they see so much that is not real and much error or outright hypocrisy that it will not allow them to respect us or take us serious. It’s a very sad situation.
Scott,thanks for linking this article for us. I actually went and read the entire column, and I draw a somewhat different conclusion:
Mr. Obama’s faith journey is remarkably parallel to many middle aged Americans. The baby boomers were one of the first groups to be told to look at, embrace, study, and ‘find your faith home’. Whether it was the Jesus People or what I call “eastern-lite” of the Hari Krishnas and the Ba’hai, those of us who grew up in that period know exactly what was going on.
And, it’s not a bad thing in a world leader to be able to converse readily with people of other beliefs.
For myself, my interactions with people of other faith traditions have dramatically affected my life…in good ways. Those who go through life refusing to interact with, or to try to understand those different from themselves are the poorer for it.
Within different religions there is more than just pluralism. If you look at just one particular faith, if you can truly define it, you’ll find lines back in time to something that we wouldn’t recognize as the faith that exists, today.
There are at least 34k different divisions within the Christian faith. The Shiit, Kurds, Wahabist, and thousands of divisions within the Muslim faith are at odds with each other, all of the time. Catholics and Protestants were killing each other in Northern Ireland only a few years ago.
Christians, Muslims, Jews all have the Pentateuch as part of their holy books.
Who can say what it means to be Christian? I think that it’s something very personal and doesn’t need to be explained other than to say, “I am one.”
D-
I would really caution you on the “pagan holiday” thing. Little will distance you further from the world you are here to reach than this type of approach. It is true that these were pagan holidays. Whether the holidays were put on the days to mix paganism with christianity or to compete against the pagan holidays, the effect has been the same for both days you mention - those days have become stumps to stand on and declare the truth of Jesus to the world. They couldn’t be further from the original pagan purposes, and the idea that the use of the specific date dilutes christianity is difficult for me to accept.
Look, Paul’s use of the statue to the “unknown god” to declare the truth of God and Jesus should show us that this type of redirection is not only acceptable, but a useful tool.
The real issue is the contemporary diluting of what are now fully christian holidays with commercialism and secularism. I think the real tragedy would be for us to sit out of the holidays, allowing secularism to be god, and forget to use the days for declaring truth.
milkew,
It only takes one to look at each of these holidays to see where the focus truly is during these holidays to prove you incorrect. That is exactly what Christians need to learn to master, “distance from the world” while living in it at the same time without compromising things of spiritual nature, (God).
You are so wrong if you think for one second that these Pagan holidays have served to become stumps to stand on and declare the truth of Jesus to the world you do not recognize truth.
These two days serve as nothing more than a mockery to Christ and His memory with the exception of few who follow Christ. Very little focus are placed on Christ on either one of these days, it is more focused on worldly things and others not Christ.
How can one make so little of Christ by serving Him by things built on lies and Paganism? To believe this is to reject the truth that we are suppose to believe in contained in scripture. We are called as Christians to serve Christ in Spirit and in truth.
Many Christians get along in this world just fine without celebrating Christmas and, without Easter Eggs and Bunnies in keeping with Christ instructions on how to observe the Memorial of His death and to say away from and reject all these of Pagan origin.
I only hope that all who desire to serve God/Christ above all things in their life will be convicted in their hearts to worship Christ in spirit and in truth the ways in which we have been commanded to within scripture. I have been convicted in heart concerning these two holidays and know the decisions I must make concerning these holidays.
The struggles that am having breaking away from these two traditions have shown me the realities of the strongholds that they are and the spirit behind what is driving these two holidays and it is not the Spirit of God. It is no joke or anything to be taken lightly, they are truly strongholds and once anyone become convicted of this truth and go through the breaking away process of their conviction, they will see what a stronghold it truly is and the force behind these holidays.
One other thing milkew,
Think about what you stated above:
“The real issue is the contemporary diluting of what are now fully christian holidays with commercialism and secularism”.
Do you think it is ever possible to turn what God has declared as bad into something good? Or, mix something God has declared as not good with things that are of God or intended as worship to God/Christ?
In my search for these answers within scripture, I read and understood and was guided into God’s truth that anything birth from things of Pagan nature/Satan, it can never be made acceptable to God or be included in the worship of God. My research and study of scripture disclosed to be the very serious sin that such doing is.