Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.27.2008 4:59 pm

Did Obama’s other uncle sink the Bismarck?

WASHINGTON _ An interchange between the Republican National Committee and Barack Obama’s campaign this afternoon illustrates how closely politicians watch one another – and how today’s candidates respond quickly out of fear of being “swiftboated.”The story begins in New Mexico where Obama, in a Memorial Day speech yesterday, recalled the pain of a family member who fought in World War II.

“I had an uncle … who was part of the first American troops to go into Auschwitz and liberate the concentration camps. And the story in our family was that when he came home, he just went up into the attic and he didn’t leave the house for six months,” he said.

This afternoon, the Republican Party asserted that Obama’s “dubious” claim was inconsistent with history and demanded an explanation.

Indeed, it was Soviet troops, not American forces, that entered the Auschwitz complex, on Jan. 27, 1945, liberating 7,000 people, the RNC pointed out after a trip to the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum web site.

An hour later, the Obama campaign responded, saying their candidate, “mistakenly referred to Auschwitz instead of Buchenwald in telling of his personal experience of a soldier in his family who served heroically.”

The release, also citing the Holocaust Museum, noted that Obama’s great-uncle was part of the 89th Infantry Division that entered part of Buchenwald on April 4, 1945, the first Nazi concentration camp liberated by U.S. troops in Germany.

Besides showing the scrutiny and rapid-response tactics in presidential politics, this episode would seem to demonstrate how the Democrats’ never-ending contest breeds mistakes by worn-out candidates.

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...
21 comments

Comments are closed.

If Obama can’t take a few months of friendly campaigning, how on earth do you expect him to weather four years of much greater responsibility - and with much more serious consequences for mistakes - as President? The lesson to be learned here isn’t that the Democrats have campaigned for too long, but that Mr. Obama is not up to the demanding job of serving as President.

— Nick Kasoff
8:42 pm May 27th, 2008

Maybe he can pick that great humorist and perky D. Cheney for Veep

— Beatnikbird
11:10 pm May 27th, 2008

Obama makes an honest mistake, and the RNC goes bananas.

How about the latest news that McCain is up to his eyeballs in lobbyists?

(Link) McCain economic policy shaped by lobbyist

— Lisa12
11:29 pm May 27th, 2008

Lisa, Obama has many ties with lobbyists and PACs. During his Senate campaign he accepted contributions from insurance companies and their lobbyists.

Yep…I can see where he would make a mistake like that. Afterall, most of us don’t have a clue as to what our uncles, oops, great uncles did during the war. Didn’t he also say he was conceived during the civil rights march in Selma? Oops…he was born BEFORE that march. I can see where he would make a mistake like that. Didn’t he say that he wasn’t in church during Reverand Wright’s speeches? Oops… The list goes on. Yet it doesn’t matter to you Obama worshippers. Character doesn’t matter..and hasn’t since Clinton.

He just gave a commencement speech at Wesleyan University where he urged the students to not be so focused on getting high paying jobs and to “give back” to the community. Yet he and Michelle Obama only gave 1% of their income to charity prior to running and are very wealthy. You Obama worshippers can’t see this as hypocrisy because you are so focused on “change”. He offers NOTHING yet says EVERYTHING.

— Logicprevails
8:26 am May 28th, 2008

Just two things:
1. In the above tags, please correct “Holocause Museum” to “Holocaust Museum”.

2. Leave to those so blinded by their dislike for Senator Obama to miss the point of the story. Regardless if he remembered the story as being Auschwitz instead of Buchenwald, the point was his great-uncle was so profoundly disturbed by what he saw, that he retreated from the world for quite some time. This is the point on Memorial Day, to acknowledge that those who have served in horror zones sometimes are so affected they find civilian life difficult.

— RHarnack
2:24 pm May 28th, 2008

RH, it’s hard to take Obama at his word when his word is not good. I have no doubt that anyone liberating those camps was affected the rest of their lives and perhaps his uncle was. Yet don’t you find it odd that something that is so devastating to a family member was not mentioned in his “Audacity of Hope” book?? I do.

— Logicprevails
2:34 pm May 28th, 2008

Logic
“it’s hard to take Obama at his word when his word is not good.”

Do you apply the same standard to the current occupant of the White House and his Veep?

Just curious.

— RHarnack
3:47 pm May 28th, 2008

RH, you’re trying to throw out the rhetoric regarding Bush and Cheney “lying”. I have yet to see anywhere that they have lied. Go ahead: Iraq War. This has been vetted time and time again. You all hate the answers. What else do you not take them at their word for?

— Logicprevails
4:01 pm May 28th, 2008

Rove, Bush, Cheney all lied. Soldiers die!

You’d have to be brain dead not to see it. Oh! I forgot, your a right wing neocon Brown Shirt weblog echochmabering yobbo yapper! So for sic and vicious and all the other yappers, I award you my first ceremonial Black Hats, to commerorate your dead brains!

Please remember, only the bad guys wear Black Hats!!!

— Tim Hogan
4:44 pm May 28th, 2008

Tim, “Sic” is spelled “sick”, “your” should be spelled “you’re”. If you’re going to spew your rhetoric, check a dictionary. You obviously are not well educated and can only rant. I would like to see facts…but won’t be surprised if you cannot present any.

Good luck and get some education.

— Logicprevails
5:06 pm May 28th, 2008

Pages: [1] 2 3 » Show All