Is fat the new thin? “Hungry” model weighs in.
There’s a fine line between being “big and beautiful” and being fat. And I’ll admit that I don’t know where to draw that line.
We throw around the word “fat” so much that it’s lost it’s meaning. I’ll admit that I have “fat days,” but I try not to ever mention this to anyone ever, because I hate it when I hear people smaller than me with the same complaint.
I have a size 4 co-worker (who probably has a 26-inch waist) who routinely groans about her weight while munching on cookies, potato chips, chocolate or whatever else is in sight.
I have another co-worker who runs marathons counts calories religiously and yet deals with the reality of maintaining a toned plus-size form.
I come from a family of extra-large women, so I know the pain and struggle of weight loss and pain and embarrassment of watching strangers stare. I don’t make light of it.
I also know that being fat is relative.
Many of you (and many more men, I’d hazard to say) will call the woman on the cover of the book jacket to the right, “fat.” She’s clearly not your standard model size.
This last fact is something that many women will applaud.
The second picture is the same model. Her name is Crystal Renn. She is 23 years old now, but she was discovered by a model scout when she was a fresh faced 14-year-old. She describes her appearance then as being a “chubby cheerleader.”
She was encouraged to lose 50 pounds to model (about 40 percent of her body weight at the time). She was constantly hungry, consistently exhausted and her hair fell out in clumps. That’s her former self pictured at left.
Soon she rebelled and decided to settle into a comfortable, healthy weight. She landed at a size 12. And her modeling career thrives. She tells her story in the aptly titled “Hungry: A Young Model’s Story of Appetite, Ambition and the Ultimate Embrace of Curves” (due to be released Sept. 8 from Simon & Schuster, $25).
The last time I posted a revealing picture of a size 12, plus-sized girl from a Glamour magazine story on “feeling comfortable in your own skin,” many of the comments were appalling. The level of disgust and idiocy shocked me.
I had to police that blog post all day, because apparently there is a surplus of men with six-pack abs who are offended by any girl with a double-digit dress size.
And, yes, there is a point at which excess weight is unhealthy. And as much as I want people to feel confident and happy no matter what size they are right now, I want them to work on being healthy too.
But when people bring out the pitchforks for a girl who’s a size 12, I just get angry. No wonder girls have the highest rates of eating disorders and self-esteem issues.
But here’s the kicker. There are more overweight men than women.
A few years ago a global study revealed that 40 percent of men and 30 percent of women are overweight, while 24 percent of men and 27 percent of women are obese, according to research reported in a journal of the American Heart Association.
And right now, 66 percent of adults over 20 are considered overweight or obese, according to the Centers for Disease Control.
So why are so many people so mad? Is there really a raging, pompous, condescending 34 percent of the population making all the noise about weight control?
Newsweek recently published a report on “America’s War on the Overweight: Anti-fat rhetoric is getting nastier than ever. Why our overweight nation hates overweight people.”
Some of the answers from the article were pretty interesting. The article explains that much of this aggravated hot-air is coming from self-haters, who struggle with weight but consider their missteps to be legitimate excuses, while the missteps of others are foul acts against will power and discipline.
The article also explains:
“People actually enjoy feeling angry,” says Ryan Martin, associate professor of psychology at the University of Wisconsin, Green Bay, who cites studies done on people’s emotions. “It makes them feel powerful, it makes them feel greater control, and they appreciate it for that reason.” And with fat people designated as acceptable targets of rage-and with the prevalence of fat people in our lives, both in the malls and on the news-it’s easy to find a target for some soul-clearing, ego-boosting ranting.
And here’s a final note from the article: Yelling at people to stop being fat doesn’t help.
Anyone with a brain will tell you that for one thing — it’s rude! And for the second thing, when did humiliating and belittling anyone ever make a situation better.
So we have to learn to live with each other for thinner or fatter. I can only hope that familiarity will breed a new acceptance without tipping the scales in favor of our nation’s other favorite past time: verbally abusing the skinny.
The Glamour feature attracted so much attention and controversy that according to the New York Post, the magazine will “feature a slew of large, nude models in the November issue.”
This time Lizzie Miller, who sparked a mix of accolades and vitriol, will be joined by “fellow full-figured femmes”: Kate Dillon, Jennie Runk, Amy Lemons, Crystal Renn (above), Ashley Graham and Anansa Sims. Apparently all the girls were photographed nude by Matthias Vriens.
I’m sure plenty of folks will be sharpening their pitchforks over that, but I can only hope that one or two will realize that demonizing fat isn’t part of the solution. It’s part of the problem.
ALL COMMENTS WILL BE MODERATED BEFORE THEY ARE POSTED. BEING DISAGREEABLE IS FINE, BUT THIS IS A FAMILY WEBSITE. THIS WILL ALL BE DONE AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE. THANKS FOR YOUR PATIENCE.



A wayward soul from Las Vegas, Nevada, who now calls St. Louis home and believes that fashion is relative and capricious, but style is always in favor.
Body image and social norms is such a hard thing for women. I am a slightly curvy size 4 and I feel pressure from both sides. Society says you should be thin- but not too thin and still have a big butt and chest. Music videos say that you should be thick. I was a size 14 before I lost weight to become a size 4 and the whole time I was larger, I felt pressure to be smaller. Now that I am smaller, I feel pressure to gain some weight. I even feel that being petite can be a flaw in the professional world. Other women and some men- I think- don’t take me as seriously as they did when I was larger. Society and others always make things so complicated. I give props to the model who is comfortable in her own skin. That is a feat in itself.
What ever happened to intellect?
Is physical appearance become the most interesting thing anyone has to talk about?
For female models, I think an “hour glass” figure is what is desired…be that a size 14 hour glass or a size 3 is of no concern of mine.
Crystal is absolutely stunning in the first and last photos. The middle photo looks like she has the body of an 12 year old boy.
*Side note: What’s with the size 0 in women’s clothes? How can anyone be a size zero? They have no size?
A: From a guys perspective, I think you are being overly concerned about how a dress size relates to co-workers taking you seriously. I think a moderate work out and eating healthy, and then letting your body decide what size it should be is the right approach. As for being taken seriously, I believe that goes directly to your own self confidence. I know that one of the first things I notice about a women is her self confidence. I don’t like it when a woman is over confident and “cocky”, but a moderate level of self confidence is very sexy. From a career standpoint, co-workers will take you as seriously as you expect them to. It is up to you to set the level of expectation from them…and they will usually abide by your standard. So, in short, don’t let your dress size be the benchmark that determines your respect. And, let your body be the size it needs to be. I think women who take good care of their appearance, but are happy with themselves, and are not stressed out these things are very attractive. A size 4 vs whatever…that is not the key factor.
There are so many things besides body type to consider. Education, personality, common interests…but with that said….that girl is smoking hot.
Clearly the thin image looks like you are sick. The curves are better,plus according to most men they like curves. The ones who don’t probably been seeing the models on the run way and everyone who’s and ah’s them because the clothes they wear not the appearance of the model. The models are to try to sell clothes for the designers and what better way then to have a walking manequin.
The portion of society that rather implicitly sets standards for how women should look is ridiculous. Besides, I can’t even think of more than one friend who wouldn’t prefer a curvy woman to the “little boy” look seen in picture two above.
We live a society where we are expected to be tolerant, even embracing, of everyone else’s race, religion, ability or disability, political views, skin tone, national origin, sexual orientation, etc. Why is body shape and size a different category - one which is an acceptable means of judging people? I was taught, and I tried to pass along to my children, that it’s what is inside a person that matters not their outward appearance. Crystal Renn is beautiful, as are many women her size and larger. As women we accept our men, who may be overweight or balding or have hairy backs, without a second thought. Yet we are held to a different standard, and even have that standard for ourselves. Attitudes in general need to change, but that can’t happen until we change our own, and then pass it along to others.
She’s not fat - she looks healthy. And I doubt more men than women would think so - women are far more catty. Don’t let a couple of image-obsessed male anorexics spoil your opinion of all of us. Besides, anyone who can only appreciate a boy-bodied, plastic version of beauty may not turn out to be straight . . .