Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.27.2009 12:26 pm

Poll: Did you know reusable shopping bags breed bacteria?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

It seems that everywhere you look these days, people are carrying those reusable fabric tote bags when they go shopping. But while those totes are better for the environment than plastic bags, a new report raises questions about potential health hazards of reusing them for food shopping.

The study by Sporometrics, an environmental microbiology lab based in Toronto, Canada, found reusable food shopping bags and packages can contain a high level of bacteria, yeast, mold and coliform counts which pose a significant food safety risk. The study was funded by the Environment and Plastic Industry Council, which is a committee of the Canadian Plastics Industry Association.

Food safety fears focused on the risks of cross contamination of food placed in bags contaminated by previous use in successive trips.  Also contaminants could be transferred from one bag to another in the check-out packing process.

“The moist, dark, warm interior of a folded reusable bag that has acquired a small amount of water and a trace of food contamination is an ideal incubator for bacteria,” the report said.

Researchers also raised concerns about the use of multiple-purpose totes, particularly if the same bags are used to transport such items as gym equipment or diapers.

If consumers shop with reusable bags, researchers suggest that meat should be double packed in a first-use bag to prevent accidental leakage or drips into the reusable bag.

Reusable bags can be cleaned, but researchers said drying them can be a problem. They warned consumers not to dry the bags by laying them out flat. Instead, the bags should be turned inside out and suspended in order to properly air them out.

Do you carry reusable fabric bags for grocery shopping

View Results

Loading ... Loading …
Loading ... Loading ...
10 comments

Comments are closed.

You forgot to mention WHO sponsored this study.

It was a Canadian organization of plastic manufacturers. You know, the companies whose bags are being replaced by reusable bags.

Of course plastics companies want you to be afraid of environmentally-friendly reusable bags. Then you’ll go back to getting 20 plastic bags that end up in the trash every trip to the store.

Please be aware of who pays for “studies” before reporting it. I’d say this “study” is one of the more laughable in recent years.

— trimetrov
12:59 pm May 27th, 2009

Sorry, I see now that you mentioned the Plastics Industry Council.

Nevertheless, is it really worth getting in a lather over yet another totally invented fear?

Who carries diapers and groceries in the same bag?

— trimetrov
1:02 pm May 27th, 2009

Just common sense — like any other household item that is used and re-used (such as a dishtowel vs. a paper towel), they need to be washed.

Just fear-mongering from plastics manufacturers.

— Beth
1:27 pm May 27th, 2009

I use plastic and I be sure to throw ‘em out after I get home. Studies have proven shopping cart baskets are actually dirtier than the floor of a public restroom. The person that used that cart before you had their little kid with his/her dirty diapers and shoes pouncing all around right where tonight’s supper is going to be carried, so no wonder the crud ends up in the bag. Uh, there’s a reason why Schnucks has those sanitizer wipes next to the cart corral inside the store. And with swine flu going around right now??? That’s OK though; the enviro-nuts think they’re doing all this good by pulling up in their little Priuses and getting out their reused baggies just to save the world, but in effect they might make themselves or their families seriously sick with all this liberal nonsense. How ironic.

— Burt F.
1:39 pm May 27th, 2009

Study the exact number of hands as they did shopping bags…I BET the hands are more dirty! And we eat with them…

— nonendd
2:28 pm May 27th, 2009

I glanced at this. There was a large number of bags studies…..29. A couple of the bags were 2 or 3 years old. No wonder they were “dirty.”

http://www.cpia.ca/files/files/A_Microbiological_Study_of_Reuseable_Plastic_Grocery_Bags.pdf

— nonendd
2:33 pm May 27th, 2009

Ok so should I listent to people attacking a study that says my family might get sick or do I do something constructive. I take constructive!

Easy solution…since most $0.99 bags cant be washed in a machine and lord knows most people don’t, why not just take the plastic bag but on the next trip take them back to be recycled? This way we always get a sterile plastic bag and nothing goes to the land fill.

Heck I rarely take my reusables anyways (about once in 10)
What will I do with my old reusables cant recycle them(I have had three rip in two years)
Dierberg’s and Schnucks both recycle and Dierbergs bags are even made from recycled material…

So why risk the study being true or false. I think the fact that the guy in the study used to work for the Canadian health department is enough for me to make an easy choice to recycle and error for the caution of my family.

–from Shiloh and Scott AFB wish you all the best and dont forget your troops.

— ShilohReader
7:38 pm May 27th, 2009

This is another example of confusing the consumer. Green…………..that’s what the cloth bags are all about. Nothing is more irritating than having a bag of plastic bags accumulating on your back porch, till you remember to take them bACK to the store. Now, my bags are always in the back of my car ready for groceries. I will admit to appreciating the fact of drying out the bags.

— Marie
10:20 am May 28th, 2009

Okay, great… So we get sick or we kill our planet… Hmmm. Not really a fair choice. I think the resuable bags a great, but you should definatly wash them. You wouldn’t dry dishes with an unwashed dish rag, would you? Same theory. Yes, I do see it was paid for by the plastic industry and that may have something to do with it… But it’s also common sense that if you put food into a bag and it leaks or spills it is a good way to grow bacteria and mold. Also once the bags give off the odor of food they can attract bugs. But come on people, just wash them every few uses and get on with it!

— Allison
11:02 am June 1st, 2009

I’ve been taking my own bags to the grocery store for over 20 years and have had no problems. Bacteria are everywhere– inside us, on our skin, on every surface we touch. Most are harmless, some are beneficial. I wash my bags occasionally, particularly the canvas ones. I prefer the mesh type of bag, since nothing gets trapped in it. Aren’t most foods packaged anyway? Are supermarket shelves any cleaner than the insides of bags? This sounds like a scare-tactic put out by the plastics industry.

— M Hagood
4:09 pm June 1st, 2009