Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
11.19.2008 3:41 am

Is “Twilight” twaddle?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

My horror-buff colleague Kevin Johnson will be reviewing the vampire romance “Twilight” in Friday’s paper; but I saw the much-hyped movie tonight and I am free to make a prediction: It will only appeal to a limited audience, an audience that definitely doesn’t include me.

Then again, i said the same about “Sex and the City,” and that audience forked over about $150 million. ”Twilight” is aimed at their daughters, many of whom have read the “Twilight Saga” books by Stephenie Meyer. Among them is my niece, Angela, whom I took to the preview screening at Ronnie’s.

Angela thought hunk-of-the-month Robert Pattinson was dreamy as the vegetarian vampire, and she thoiught the movie itself was good, if not as action-packed as the book on which it was based. Me, I thought it was a snooze. The mopey teens and cheap effects were more suited to a series on the WB network than a feature film.

Director Catherine Hardwicke once made a frighteningly realistic coming-of-age film called “Thirteen,” but this was soft-focus fodder for the tweens who only recently grew tired of “High School Musical.”

Maybe I’ll be interested by movie #4, when I reckon that Bella (played by talented young actress Kristen Stewart) finally succumbs to the vampire’s highly symbolic bite. But for now I have to shake my head and lament that the millennial generation is so toothless.

Tags:
11 comments

Comments are closed.

it looks like total crap on the trailer…but as you said, it obviously appeals to a female teen audience.

Look at it this way–it keeps the kids out of other movies where they usually grow bored and end up disturbing the audience with chatter and texting.

— don
7:19 am November 19th, 2008

I don’t think the studio cares that much about what movie critics think of the film. They care about money, and teen girls certainly don’t read movie reviews. Actually, most movie-going people don’t really care about reviews. If they did, Adam Sandler movies would not be hits, and scads of movies that were total flops would have been hits.

— DonPat
7:31 am November 19th, 2008

Thanks for the spoiler on Book #4

— Kristin Cullen
8:52 am November 19th, 2008

My 6th grade son and I have read all 4 books and loved it. There is always a risk of not getting the full effect of the books that are produced into movies. Harry Potter had some empty scenes that were left out however, the good thing is that use of the imagination leaves room for the experience no matter how big or small. Alot of adults lose their innocence in imagination because we have experieced things that of the “real world” vs. that of teenagers still in high school. So when attending a movie that is based for a younger crowd not just females for this book/movie, remember to bring your imagination and youth with you. It is best to leave the criticism of the preview at home and see the movie before you judge.

— Melissa
8:52 am November 19th, 2008

Perhaps you should have “slept on it” before writing your review. It had so many typos, it looked like it had been written by the same pre-teens that you insulted in your review.

— joedeelee
10:07 am November 19th, 2008

Seriously. Thanks for the spoiler about book 4. Uncool.

— Lisa
11:00 am November 19th, 2008

Hey, brainiacs, he didn’t spoil anything, he made a guess. Don’t just read the words — try to comprehend.

— ConnieIHAD
1:18 pm November 19th, 2008

Giving information about books that have been on the shelves for months now shouldn’t be considered “spoiling.”

— Kate
4:49 pm November 19th, 2008

OMG–what is up with bitching about the “spoiler?”

Re-read it, people–when someone says “When I reckon…” THAT means he is guessing. Also–based on what I have seen or heard about these books, we aren’t talking Agatha Christie here…can’t imagine that what Joe “reckons” would be that much of a real shocker to anyone if it DID happen.

Jaysus Kree-rist–the way some of you snapped, you would think they guy revealed that Kevin Spacey’s character was Keyser Soze in “The Usual Suspects.”

Sorry for the spoiler on a movie from like 10 years ago (LOL).

— don
4:21 pm November 21st, 2008

definitely not as good as the novel written by Stephanie Meyer. They may have done better letting her write the screen play.

Characters had no depth. There was definite chemistry between Rob and Kristen, but their lines always seemed rushed - like they had to hurry through each scene.

No matter your age, if you’re a woman, you would appreciate the handsome young stars. Eye candy - yes. And for all the young Twilighters out there - New Moon - cooming soon - maybe they’ll do more with the special effects and script.

For what it was, it was good. Too bad it’s not what it could have been.

— Forever Mom
12:47 pm November 24th, 2008

you are so wrong! the movie was amazing, even though the books were 10 times better. you just dont get it because your not a girl.

— Paige
3:15 pm November 25th, 2008