Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
12.23.2008 5:05 am

“Slumdog Millionaire”: too much (or not enough) for Oscar?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

A reader has scolded me for not warning her in my review that “Slumdog Millionaire” contains some harrowing sequences, especially the images of police brutality and the abuse of homeless children. I thought that I had. But I’ll take this opportunity to reiterate: This is a tough film, with some scenes that will make the faint-hearted shudder.

Yet it’s also arguably the most beloved film of the year, and several Oscar-handicapping sites (such as The Envelope) rank it as the favorite for Best Picture. That goes to show you the power of a happy ending to erase our memories of everything that preceded it.

I maintain that “Slumdog” is too small a picture, and too foreign, to win over the Academy, which tends to favor big films that employ many members of its American electorate. That’s why my money is on “The Curious of Benjamin  Button.” But I must admit, “Slumdog” is a phenomenon. Maybe it will spark a craze for all things Indian, and Ben Kingsley can finally get around to making “Gandhi, Part II: The Payback.”

4 comments

Comments are closed.

You are very right. I think Benjamin Button stands a better chance to win.

— Saju
11:56 am December 23rd, 2008

Joe,
I wanted to love Slumdog, but just didn’t. I’m sure I liked it though. And I will say it was beautifully shot and acted.
I think it’ll get a Best Pic nomination but not a win.

— Kevin C. Johnson
11:43 pm December 23rd, 2008

Just watched this ’slumdog Millionaire”, I am speechless, it is a one of the masterpieces in the history of cinema, though, it is as said ‘tough’ but it is a very couragous attempt, I feel this is a ‘tough’ competitor for the oscar. I wish it wins.

— Maryam S
10:24 pm December 24th, 2008

I liked Slumdog better than Benjamin Button. I think there was so much hype about it being the best movie of the year and it didn’t live up to the hype for me.Slumdog had me hooked from the minute the movie started. It might be too foreign, too small, but for me it was the best film I’ve seen this year.

— Beth Wuesthoff
11:43 am December 27th, 2008