Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.28.2008 11:51 am

Balanced reporting welcome on U.S.-Venezuelan relations

St. Louis Post-Dispatch

Thank you for the piece on Venezuela and Chavez.  It’s very hard to find balanced reporting in American newspapers on countries and leaders our capitalist political leaders dislike.  The history of US-Latin American relations is a record played over and over.  We support the wealthy groups, whether landowners or business leaders, and oppose any attempt by the general population to secure a portion of the profits generated by their work.

But that is also the story in our own country, so I guess we shouldn’t be surprised.

I have a friend whose son was crippled in an auto accident a year ago.  Both parents work for employers who don’t offer health insurance.  They cannot afford a private health plan.  The son received one month of physical therapy paid for by Medicaid.  That is all he was “eligible” for.  The physical therapist said he COULD regain the use of his hands with the proper kind of long-term therapy.  So this 20 yr old sits in a wheelchair, unable to even scratch his nose or pick up the phone.  And this in “the richest country in the world” as we like to view ourselves.   In Canada or Venezuela, that young man would be using his hands and getting job training in order to become useful to his society again.

In Toronto, I saw early childhood/parenting centers in shopping malls.  Yes, right between the jewelry store and the shoe store.  That’s how important it is for them to make sure pregnant women and new moms get good advice.  These parenting centers are staffed by trained child development professionals and available whenever the mall is open.  That’s how much our neighbors to the north value their children.

The next to  last paragraph in your article could just as easily describe the US.  Have you driven through Huntleigh?  Town and Country?  Try the neighborhood just north and west of the Clayton/Baxter Rd. intersection.  Then come on out here to Franklin County and meet the people living in their cars and trucks.

Again, thank you for your article which is the most objective I’ve seen on the topic in a major city paper.

And, no, the idea of an American invasion of Venezuela to get its oil is not “ludicrous.”  Start with the Spanish-American War and follow the pattern through the 20th century.   And pity the poor Iraqis.  Their only crime was living on top of the oil we want.  There’s a “revolution” bubbling up in America, but it’s happening on the internet and in electoral politics.

Soon it will be too large and important for the mainstream media to ignore

Susan Cunningham

retired teacher of American history

Pacific

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (5 votes, average: 2.6 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...
23 comments

Comments are closed.

The problem I’m having with the young crippled boy story is that the other person’s auto insurance didn’t cover it? Or was it his fault for driving drunk, talking on the cell phone or reaching for a CD? The one thing I do know is that socialized healthcare would not pamper the boy as you hope. He will not get the specialist he needs but only the general care to keep him alive. The care you speak of in Canada didn’t happen over night either. It took baby steps and everyone’s participation not to milk the system. Even with Canada’s “great” system special cases get sent to the US because we can still do them cheaper and more effectively. If the US does something similar who will we go to?

— eagle scout
12:35 pm May 28th, 2008

Don’t worry, if Obamamessiah gets elected you won’t have to worry about “capitalist” leaders anymore. And what a surpirse to see a radical leftist teaching history. Maybe you could teach Obamamessiah that there are 50 states in the US (not 57 as he said), or that Auschwitz was in Poland and liberated by Soviet troops (not by his uncle as he has been saying for years).

Yes, the Post is very fair with anti-American leftist thug dictators like Chavez. A shame they don’t have the same tolerance for our troops.

Can you tell me why Canadians are coming to the US for medical care? Socailized health care (and socialism in general) has failed miserably everywhere it has been tried. If it’s so great, why aren’t you there? I blame you for this boy’s paralysis, you knew how to help but did nothing.

— tim jones
1:59 pm May 28th, 2008

Thank God Ms Cunningham’s retired. The last thing American schools need is teachers with as poor an understanding of history or current events as hers.

— Go_Fish
2:01 pm May 28th, 2008

The fact that this woman taught is frightening. She neglects to mention that if this were Venezuela and she disagreed this publically with the leader in power, she could be imprisoned or worse.

And if we went to war with those “poor Iraqis” for oil, where is it? Why aren’t my gas prices cheaper?

As a footnote, you use Capitalist as if it were a derogatory term or as if Socialist were the better route. This is a Capitalist nation built on hard work and determination, not handouts or socialism.

Like the note from the first blog - I’m having a hard tiem believeing the other driver didn’t pay for the rehab. Where is the rest of the story. But as all personal anecdotes go, they are only used or twisted to try and make an emotional point.

If I may, I can provide a nice anecdotal story. I know a man that has duel Canadian/American citizenship. His elderly father couldn’t get timely treatment for a condition in Canada so he had to come here for treatment. It wasn’t life threatening, but it wasn’t cosmetic or “performance” based either. It was a chronic uncomfortable problem and the estimates were that it would take him up to 3 years for full treatment.

So you know what, these stories exist on both sides guys. Lets stop tugging on the heart strings and start deciding what is FAIR and cost efficient.

— RCJ
8:19 pm May 28th, 2008

Some FACTS re:Single Payer >>>

– Canada spends 1% of healthcare dollars on overhead
U.S. spends 31% of healthcare dollars on overhead

– Switching to Single Payer would save the U.S. more than $350 Billion per year

– Covering the 48 million uninsured would only cost $85 Billion per year

– Studies show .1% to .5% of Canadians coming to the U.S. for care

There would be no “long lines” or “waiting lists” in the U.S., because we spend way more money on healthcare than they do in Canada.

And for the bazillionth time, Single Payer is not “free”.

INSTEAD OF writing a check for $12,000 to an insurance company, I would pay probably $9,000 in taxes. Is that so hard to understand?

Wanna know the best part? If I get sick, the government isn’t going to cancel my policy and keep my $12,000 x 28 years worth of premiums.

— Lisa12
11:12 pm May 28th, 2008

RCJ: She neglects to mention that if this were Venezuela and she disagreed this publically with the leader in power, she could be imprisoned or worse.

You mean kind of like what happened to former Alabama Governor Don Siegelman?

— Lisa12
11:22 pm May 28th, 2008

eagle scout: The problem I’m having with the young crippled boy story is that the other person’s auto insurance didn’t cover it?

Ms. Cunningham didn’t say there was another person involved in the accident.

— Lisa12
11:53 pm May 28th, 2008

Lisa, that’s why I also questioned how the accident occurred. Could this poor person’s injuries arisen from a stupid mistake from the list I originally wrote?

Lisa you also mention things about long lines. Now with doctor’s offices your lucky to get in the appointment an hour or so from the scheduled time. With socialized medicine how are the lines going to decrease? I can only invasion the lines getting longer, and the quality of the practice becoming something like a jiffy lube drive trough. Line up, get in, impersonal interactions, and then trying to sell you things that don’t come in the basic package.

I guess the moral of my response is that we can all mention a sob story that will invoke a big emotional response. Only when the story is really looked at and research can the truth come out.

— eagle scout
7:11 am May 29th, 2008

Lisa - Are you kidding me? You’re comparing Siegelman to Chavez dissidents? First, the testimony about Roves involvement, which comes from one person has been incredibly conflicted. Second, he was tried and convicted by a jury and not summarily tossed in prison. Finally, thanks to appeals and outside involvement he has been released pending appeal. We have numerous avenues in this nation for seeking justice. If Siegelman were in Venezuela, he’d still be sitting on a prison cot with no hope of reprieve. In Cuba he may be dead. And beyond all that, we’re still not sure if he was guilty or innocent or what Karl Roves true involvement is. But fortunately thats being investigated.

— RCJ
9:29 am May 29th, 2008

eagle scout: The one thing I do know is that socialized healthcare would not pamper the boy as you hope. He will not get the specialist he needs but only the general care to keep him alive. … Even with Canada’s “great” system special cases get sent to the US because we can still do them cheaper and more effectively.

Your attitudes are baffling to me. Have you talked to Canadians? I used to participate in a blog for people on dialysis. Many of the participants were from Canada. The quality of their dialysis clinics was much better than ours. They were appalled at the stories they heard from dialysis patients here. Also, Canada was doing a new form of dialysis, Slow Nocturnal Hemodialysis, long before we were, and it has a much better result for the patient.

As far as Canada sending patients to the U.S., that does happen, but you do realize that Canada is paying for the travel costs as well as the treatment? A recent case involved a woman who had multiple births. It wasn’t that they didn’t have the facilities in Canada, but in a freaky coincidence, all of the neonatal facilities in Canada were full. The single payer haters were screaming … that poor woman had to come here to have her babies. They neglected to mention that Canada paid for the helicopter and all of the medical bills.

I have seen Canadians on other blogs talk about their healthcare, and I have only heard good things. Sure, they have to wait for some procedures, but that doesn’t mean we would have that here.

— Lisa12
10:27 am May 29th, 2008

Pages: [1] 2 3 » Show All