Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.29.2009 1:58 pm

Who will win Lord Stanley’s Cup?

  • Email this
  • Print this

THE WATERCOOLER

QUESTION: The Stanley Cup Finals kick off Saturday night in a repeat of last year’s matchup of the Detroit Red Wings vs. the Pittsburgh Penguins. Who are you picking to win it all and why?

JEREMY RUTHERFORD
I will go with Pittsburgh in 6 games. I picked the Pens last year, but looking back, they just weren’t ready. They are this season. Pittsburgh goalie Marc-Andre Fleury will be a difference-maker. Injuries to Detroit’s Nicklas Lidstrom and Pavel Datsyuk could also be factors. Sorry Marian Hossa, you should have stayed in the Steel City.

TOM TIMMERMANN
If you had asked me pretty much any day all year who would win the Stanley Cup, I’d have said the Detroit Red Wings. But today, I’m going with the Penguins. They’re a more mature team than a year ago, and they’ll be a lot calmer in the finals than last year. They’ve got Crosby, they’ve got Malkin, who is not disappearing this year, they’ve got Fleury in goal. Detroit is banged up and with Games 1 and 2 back to back, a younger, better-rested team, which is what Pittsburgh is, will have an edge. I think Pittsburgh’s got a shot to snag a win at Joe Louis Arena and that could be the difference in a tight series. And unlike the conference finals, this won’t be a quick series. But it should be a good one.

ANDY STRICKLAND (Hockeybuzz.com, KFNS)
Have we heard enough about the Pittsburgh comparison to the Edmonton Oilers of the 1980s? I’ve yet to read a story that doesn’t make mention of it.

First off, Detroit is incredible. They have an unfair amount of depth that allows them to execute their style even without some of the best players in the world. They should be getting Lidstrom and Datsyuk back for Game 1 but how effective will they be? Niklas Kronwall and Brian Rafalski are more than capable of picking up the slack. If Detroit continues to score one out of every four chances on the power play it will make things very tough for the Penguins. Whether you like him or not, you have to give props to goaltender Chris Osgood, who is Detroit’s Conn Smythe candidate to date. Most pundits didn’t give this guy a chance and for good reason, his performance during the regular season was dreadful. Somehow Osgood finds magic in Hockeytown. I find it interesting that every player on Detroit has a Stanley Cup ring except for former Penguins Marian Hossa and Ty Conklin.

With all that being said, I think Pittsburgh will win this series and I expect it to go the distance. While Osgood has been great, Pens goalie Marc-Andre Fleury has been consistent. Pittsburgh is skilled enough to run and gun with the Wings and should be able to create high quality chances which will make things tough on Osgood. Sidney Crosby and Evgeni Malkin are the best offensive duo in hockey. Their D-men may not have All-Star names on the back of their jerseys but they’ve sacrificed and are very underrated. I spoke to Billy Guerin on Thursday and he told me he’s having the time of his life. It’s only going to get better as the Penguins will win in 7. Crosby takes home the Conn Smythe (MVP).

10 comments

Comments are closed.

The Penguins in 6! Just not a fan of the “Evil Empire” called Detriot!

— SW1970
2:56 pm May 29th, 2009

GO PENS!!!

— Mike
3:24 pm May 29th, 2009

Stuck in D-Town and lifelong Blues fan it sucks and its hard but the red wings will win in 5 as much as I hate it they are hands down the premire hockey organization in the NHL. Pittsburgh doesnt have the depth to match Detroits 3rd and 4th line. Osbad has been Osgood in the play-offs but his softball catchers mask is still gay.

— SC
4:01 pm May 29th, 2009

Detroit will battle hard and always get those rediculously lucky bounces but the Pens are dominating this time around. MAF is on fire and it’s going to take a ton to shut down the 2 headed monster of Malkin and Crosby. PENS IN 6!

— Malk'in Cookies
5:42 pm May 29th, 2009

SC….I know how you feel. Here I a Wings fan stuck in St. Louis where the Cubs of hockey play! Being that all of the media types and most of you readers are picking against my beloved Wings makes me feel much better about their chances of winning another Cup. Your jealousy of their winnig organization is really showing. If the Blues had players out the caliber of Lidstrom, Datsuyk and Erickson (they don’t have any players of that caliber) they would be crying about losing ice time from their best players-like they did this entire year. The Wings instead just plug in guys from the minors and never miss a beat.

Go Wings!

— Willie
5:59 pm May 29th, 2009

enjoy it while it lasts, Willie. Lidstrom is 38 Erik Johnson is 20.

— bnw
7:14 pm May 29th, 2009

Let’s get this straight. Detroit beats Pens last year in 6(a minute away from winning in 5). Then Detroit gets Hossa, who was outstanding for Pens, so you fools think Pens will win?? How much of your hard earned $$$ are putting on that prediction?? NOTHING!! You are ALL drowning in ENVY of the winged wheel. BTW,,,Lidstrom isn’t 38, he’s 39. Ericcson is a rookie and 25. Helm is 22…Here’s what you clueless ones haven’t figured out, but should have. You keep hoping against hope that as Wings stars age, the Wings will topple. Well, Yzerman, Shanahan, Federov…etc..gone, gone…but they keep coming up with the Datsyuk’s,Zetterberg’s, Franzen’s….that’s why they are the RED Wings…NOW BOW!!!

— escapedtovegas
8:13 pm May 29th, 2009

You guys talk about Malkin/Crosby. Where was Malkin last year? Nowhere to be found!! The Wings just got done with “Hat-trick Kane” and Toews.Hat trick wasn’t heard from until 7 minutes were left…in game FIVE. Datsyuk, the best defensive forward in the league will be ready to shut Malkin down again. That leaves Crosby and Stahl…against FOUR lines that can score. Detroit will again show their depth. They’ve already beaten the best competition they were going to face…the Ducks…two years removed from winning the cup…with new stars like Perry and Ryan. Wings in 6….would have been less, if the league and NBC didn’t pull this 3 games in 4 nites junk…LOL…try to get Detroit when they’re hurting I guess,,,,it won’t help!!

— escapedtovegas
8:24 pm May 29th, 2009

escaped to vegas…. something very bad is going to happen to you and the Wings. hahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahhahahahahhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

— Odoyle Rules
3:29 pm May 30th, 2009

IF the reffs ctually call afair game and the stupid commisioner will stop reversig calls then it will be a grat series, BUT the wings have it for ure, one thing we learned in this series you can only beat the wings if you lay dirty

— palmer
6:56 pm June 7th, 2009