How would you change the immigration bill?
UPDATE: The bill is dead.
A few weeks ago, the hotly debated bill that would radically reform immigration law looked dead. Tuesday the Senate voted to revive the bill. Here’s the story.
The bill would create a temporary worker program, strengthen border security and institute a new system for weeding out illegal immigrants from workplaces. Here’s an interactive chart with info on how it would change current immigration law.
President Bush is highly supportive of the bill, which he called “a good piece of legislation” and “a careful compromise” that involves give and take from both sides. Surprisingly, the democrats are the ones most supportive of the bill and the republicans are generally against it. (Here you can see how each senator voted.) This is an issue with many conflicting opinions, even within parties.
If you were a U.S. senator, what would be your stance on this bill? Would you support it? What changes would you want to see before you voted for it?
POLL: Who should be held responsible for illegal immigration?



1. Build the 700+ miles of fencing signed into law last year. Since we are building 700+, lets just finish it: FULL FENCING AROUND ALL OUR BORDERS!
2. Militarize the border. We have reports of Mexican army personnel crossing the border while armed and escorting illegal aliens. Border Patrol personnel are not equipped or trained to deal with that type of invasion.
3. Any employer caught knowingly hiring illegals will face fines of historic levels. The CEO, plant manager, and the company itself can all be charged.
4. Have an ID system that works. All illegals must come and register. Failure to do so will result in immediate deportation when you are caught, NO EXCUSES. No felonies permitted, if you have committed a felony, leave now and save us the time. Fines will be assessed for misdemeanors, including illegally entering the United States.
5. Must pay back taxes at a rate of 35%.
6. No chance of EVER being a US citizen.
7. No funding for sanctuary cites.
8. Any illegal who has failed to register will receive NO social services. Arm get cut off in a terrible accident? The hospital will sew it back on, and as soon as you are medically cleared, you get a free plane ride out of the country. Come back again, we take the arm (that is a joke)