Why do hunters get such a bad rap?
Today’s Talk of the Day is inspired by a couple of things that have intersected in the last few days.
1) This week, we ran a story about a Sedalia deer hunter who shot a deer — and was subsequently mauled by the same animal before he finally finished him off. That story, as I write this, has 247 comments on it. Many of them run in favor of the deer and against the hunter.
2) I’ve noticed a steady flow of photos into our reader-supported IWitness “hunting and fishing” photo album. Every day, we get several more photos from hunters who have bagged a deer.
My colleague, Teak Phillips, a hunter himself, has also blogged about the Sedalia incident on his Hook and Bullet blog. I’m not a hunter, so I’m fairly ignorant about these matters. Teak gave me a lot of insight into the Sedalia case and hunting in general:
> Hunters were scornful of the hunter in that case. He should have let the deer alone for an hour, then approached it with his gun ready. If it’s eyes were closed, he should have shot it again; deer don’t die with their eyes shut.
> Hunters are very scornful of others that don’t follow the rules, which include abiding by state-imposed limits, getting licensed, hauling out what you kill, finishing off wounded animals, etc.
> A deer’s defense is more powerful than a hunter’s offense. They can smell a person a long way off, and hear them, too. They spend all their time surviving; actually finding a deer in the wild isn’t as easy as you might think.
> Critics complain that it’s not a fair fight. Deer don’t have opposable thumbs or a large brain; hunters have guns. But Teak says that once a deer is in a hunter’s sight, it’s NOT a fair fight. It isn’t designed to be. Hunting is designed for thinning overpopulated deer populations and providing food for those who want it. Again, hunters who drop deer and leave them to rot are scorned.
So, the question is, then, why do hunters who follow the rules get such a bad rap?


Kurt is the director of social media for the Post-Dispatch, where he has worked since August 2002. He's been a journalist since 1982, covering municipal government, courts, education and two hurricanes as a reporter before becoming an editor.
I haven’t done any hunting in years. I’ve never done any deer hunting, mainly pheasant in Champaign and rabbits and ducks in Carbondale. I know squat about deer hunting but it seems 100,000 deer down in a weekend would suggest that they are not that hard to find after all. I do know, of course, a ton of deer hunters and I have yet to hear them get together and say “Well, it’s time to go do our civic duty and thin that menacing herd for the good of our neighbors.” They do seem to take on a strangely superior attitude that I don’t see during other hunting seasons. I have nothing against hunting at all. The reason I don’t hunt any longer is a simple one. It always takes place in the damned cold and I hate winter with a passion. I prefer fishing.