Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
07.02.2009 10:43 am

What do staged questions say about Obama’s health care plan?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

With public and congressional support dwindling for the proposed health care plan, President Obama held a town hall forum in Virginia Wednesday to gain support. It might have had the opposite effect.

According to Fox News, there has been criticism that the questions asked at the forum were staged and asked by individuals who were members of groups that supported his health care plan. The article also cited reporters who said that the forum was an attempt to control the media.

“I’m amazed at you people who call for openness and transparency,” said veteran White House reporter Helen Thomas at a White House press conference.

“And you haven’t heard the questions,” White House spokesman Robert Gibbs shot back.

“It doesn’t matter. It’s the process,” CBS’ Chip Reid argued. “Even if there’s a tough question, it’s a question coming from somebody who was invited or who was screened or the question was screened.”

Here’s a video of the White House press conference from YouTube.

Fox News reported that the White House web site solicited Americans to submit questions for the town hall via social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter and YouTube with hundreds of entries received.

Do you think it is problematic that questions were posed at the forum even if they were tough questions?  Does this attempt to control a public forum and/or the media influence your view of Obama’s health care plan? Has Obama broken your trust?

38 comments

Comments are closed.

Helen Thomas and Chip Reid were spot on.

— Wowee
11:22 am July 2nd, 2009

I for one am completely suprised that the President would only take planted questions.

— Amazedbythelunacy
11:38 am July 2nd, 2009

Liz,

-Don’t get too comfortable over there asking questions like this. The Obama’s brown-shirts don’t like it. It is not “useful” for the social revolution.

-If you really dig though, you will find that this is just the latest in attempts to “control the news”.

-Look up Mitch Taylor, and his exclusion from global-warming conference, despite being THE polar bear expert. Reason, his view was cited as “unhelpful” to the CAUSE…www.telegraph.co.uk/…/Polar-bear-expert-barred-by-global-warmists.html

-Trust is an earned thing. You can’t break something you’ve never had.

-I want to find just ONE journalist who will ask the Obama why he won’t unseal the mountain of school, business, medical, and personal records that all previous administrations are forced to turn over. JUST ONE!

-Let us SEE the truth, if he’s got nothing to hide.

— dr-debunk
11:40 am July 2nd, 2009

“What do staged questions say about Obama’s health care plan?”

What do your daily talking points tell you it means?

It is nothing new to me, I have known he was a figurine for some time now. Everything he does is staged; get him off script and he has trouble speaking his name.

He cant debate the merits of his plan against a worthy adversary, so he uses the media to shut off debate by only allowing his side to be heard.

— Si Vis Pacem Para Bellum
12:42 pm July 2nd, 2009

Obama’s sermonizing about having fair and honest debates about anything are BS. He makes Clinton and Nixon look like models of honesty.

Obama doesn’t resort to cheap stunts and canned messages as a last resort. They’re a deliberate part of his act. His handlers know he’ll get ripped to shreds in an open forum, which is why they rarely allows even the mildest skeptic to participate in his goat and pony shows. He’s been burned several times and come off as complete boob.

Unfortunately we’re likely to see more of this stuff as it becomes clearer that his policies stink and more Americans reject them. Control over the press is a well known tactic among fascists.

— Go_Fish
12:56 pm July 2nd, 2009

It is amazing how concerned Fox News is about staged questions. Why weren’t they as concerned during the previous administration? Heck they wouldn’t even let moderate Republicans ask questions.

— GetReal
12:57 pm July 2nd, 2009

It is amazing how concerned Fox News is about staged questions. Why weren’t they as concerned during the previous administration? Heck they wouldn’t even let moderate Republicans ask questions.
— GetReal
12:57 pm July 2nd, 2009

Psssttt!! The previous administration is “previous” as in they are no longer around.

How you defend corrupt behavior by pointing to other corrupt behavior boggles my mind.

— Amazedbythelunacy
1:22 pm July 2nd, 2009

Obama is still running for the office, and this is because he knows he will not get anything substantive accomplished during his term in office. He therefore continues to promise and guarantee so that the same pinheads that elected him this time will elect him again, hoping his dreams come true. This guy is a bake sale organizer, not presidential material. He needs these shills and plants in public meetings and conferences to give him the opportunity to say what he wants without interruption by the “other side”. This is the way he and the republicans are approaching everything from talk radio to healthcare. The “one man-one vote” premise is dead, but hopefully not forever.

— Huck
1:26 pm July 2nd, 2009

Bush was stupid and way too silent. This guy is dangerous and talks way too much.

— Huck
1:28 pm July 2nd, 2009

And they said Bush was bad when speaking off the cuff. If it was something Bush was passionate about he delivered it from the heart and did it very well. When you get Obamaprompter away from the canned messages he’s less than believable. I’m not surprised they are spoonfeeding him the questions and scripting the answers for him.

— AJ
1:30 pm July 2nd, 2009

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 » Show All