Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.05.2008 11:02 am

It is time to let Kirkwood rest?

St. Louis Post-Dispatch

I received three calls objecting to Sunday’s detailed look at the troubled life of Cookie Thornton, whose shootings at Kirkwood City Hall on Feb. 7 ended with six dead, including Thornton.

(The three-level headline read: Charles Lee “Cookie” Thornton. BEHIND THE SMILE. Everything was “fan-tas-tic” — even when falling apart.)

I suspect the authors of Sunday’s story — reporters Stephen Deere and Doug Moore — and Sunday Editor Ron Wade heard from more readers. I’ll ask them to add comments if so.

One reader told me that he thought Sunday’s story was intended just to sell papers, “by stirring it up.” He said the article was in “poor taste,” and that it was time to let the matter rest.

Another reader questioned why we would devote much of the front page and two pages inside to an examination of a killer. Disrespectful to the victims, she said.

“Enough is enough,” another caller said. He said everyone at the Derby Party he went to Saturday thought the space devoted to the subject was excessive and — again — disrespectful to the victims’ families. (The story was posted on STLtoday about noon Saturday, and was available in early editions of the Sunday Post-Dispatch at stores  starting Saturday morning.)

A former editor at the Post-Dispatch sent an email praising the reporting job. The subject field was “attaboy.” He said: ” What an eye-opener for so many of us Kirkwoodians. “

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet)
Loading ... Loading ...
3 comments

Should Kirkwood be allowed to rest? Not if the City Council and others in Kirkwood are simply going to allow thnings to continue as before.

The sad thing about Mr. Thornton’s rampage is that it serves to continue the distraction from some very deep and troubling situations in Kirkwood.

— RHarnack
11:24 am May 5th, 2008

Reporters Stephen Deere and Doug Moore say they’ve received positive reactions to the Thornton article. But I received another objection, via email. (I am puzzled that an in-depth analysis of Thornton is seen as “glorifying” his actions.)
The reader’s email:
“I can’t understand why this story was put on the front page of a once-highly regarded newspaper…or, perhaps, that’s why it’s not so regarded any more. This is sensational reporting and a form of “glorifying” the actions of this individaul, possibly to show sympathy of his “cause”? Thanks, but no thanks. My and associates and I do not solve disputes by shooting responsible citizens.”

— Steve Parker
11:37 am May 5th, 2008

I thought this was an example of really solid reporting — in a day when readers very rarely make it past the first few grafs of a story, I read every word of it. Props to Deere and Moore for this one.

— Nate Becker
12:56 pm May 5th, 2008
Steve Parker