Health care protests –heartfelt or “fake”– are called worth covering
UPDATE: Protests over health care reform disrupted Rep. Russ Carnahan’s town hall forum on aging Thursday night in south St. Louis County. Six people were arrested outside after the forum, including St. Louis Post-Dispatch reporter Jake Wagman. Here’s a link to developments to that story.
UPDATE: The University City School District, citing safety reasons, has canceled Sen. Claire McCaskill’s health care reform forum that had been scheduled for Tuesday evening. As a result, reporter Jake Wagman’s live blogging from that event won’t take place. However, Wagman will report live on the Political Fix blog from McCaskill’s town hall meeting Tuesday afternoon in Hillsboro.
Al Tompkins of the Poynter journalism training center suggests that the press cover the town hall protests over President Barack Obama’s efforts to reform health care, even though some Democratic lawmakers are calling the protests “fake.”
In an article titled “Why It’s Worth Covering the Protests over Obama’s Health Care Plan,” Tompkins writes:
In my more than 30 years in the journalism industry, I can’t remember a time when Congress’ summer adjournment has produced more news…
I recommend that journalists cover these protests and not write them off as the actions of a select few. Protests are an important part of democracies. It was not long ago when those who protested the Iraq War were being written off as lunatic fringe groups.
But I am less interested in the protests themselves than I am in what people are protesting about.
The St. Louis Post-Dispatch plans to cover some local town hall meetings, including Sen. Claire McCaskill’s health care forum Tuesday afternoon in Hillsboro. Reporter Jake Wagman plans to offer live coverage on the Political Fix blog.
In his article, Tompkins writes:
Members of Congress are having to face angry crowds who are protesting government spending, bailouts and health care reform, and who don’t like the direction the country is heading in.
Some lawmakers say the protests that are popping up around the country are “fake.” But a new national poll said the sentiments expressed in the protests are real:
“American voters, by a 55 — 35 percent margin, are more worried that Congress will spend too much money and add to the deficit than it will not act to overhaul the health care system, according to a Quinnipiac University national poll released today. By a similar 57 — 37 percent margin, voters say health care reform should be dropped if it adds ’significantly’ to the deficit.”
A group called Conservatives for Patients’ Rights, which published a schedule of Congress members’ Town Hall meetings around the country, said the new poll is proof that the protests are not manufactured.
But, as Tompkins noted, many in Congress have a different view of the protests. Here’s a synopsis of a Real Clear Politics article, courtesy of the Daily Beast Cheat Sheet:
A series of town-hall meetings disrupted by anti-reform citizens has Democratic leadership crying foul. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid characterized town-hall dissenters as “loud, shrill voices trying to interrupt” and “throw a monkey wrench into everything.” Both the White House and Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi say the dissent is being “manufactured” by political and corporate organizations; Pelosi dismisses town-hall dissent as “astroturf,” or artificially generated faux-grassroots movements. Regardless of their inspiration, however, the citizen protesters mean business: ABC’s Steven Portnoy reports that, at a town-hall event for freshman Rep. Frank Kratovil (D-MD), the congressman faced an image of himself, hung in effigy, and enraged, booing crowds. Portnoy reports that a visibly unnerved Kratovil “pleaded” with constituents; a Blue Dog Democrat, Kratovil is officially “undecided” on his health-care position. At least one congressman-Rep. Brad Miller (D-NC)-has been forced to forgo the town-hall format after a threat on his life forced staffers to clamp down on public access to the congressman.


Steve Parker is the deputy managing editor for news, and oversees the Post-Dispatch's front page. STLtoday's online news editors are on his newsroom team. Parker has been at the paper since September 1980.
What proof of there that these outbursts at town hall meetings are in any way faked, staged, or other wise not truthful? Where is the proof that these people are bussed in, financed by pharma or other special interests? And why are democrats now opposing the same type efforts they are famous for?
Poor Dumbocrat. Saw himself hung in effigy. Maybe they’ll make a movie about him being assassinated like the left wing extemists made about Bush. See how he likes that.
Fake or real, they are certainly ignorant being so disruptive and disrespectful of others who do want information. If I were in attendance at one of these meetings, I would be so disgusted with these people because of being unable to learn anything about the healthcare reform bill because of these ignorant people. They are absolutely pathetic, fake or real.
Dog walker and other misanthropes, Steve…
ABC’s Political Punch reported that a town hall in Maryland did not have any industry plants:
ABC’s Steven Portnoy reports:
There were no lobbyist-funded buses in the parking lot of Mardela Middle and High School on Tuesday evening, and the hundreds of Eastern Maryland residents who packed the school’s auditorium loudly refuted the notion that their anger over the Democrats’ health care reform plans is “manufactured.”
“I went to school in this school,” a man named Bob told me. “I don’t see anyone in this room that isn’t from Mardela Springs right now.”
“We’ve been quiet too long,” said a woman named Joan.
————————————————————————
–This is what is happening all over the country, and libs lament “nazi” tactics and “paid protestors being bussed in”. It’s only because that’s how they get their crowds to protests. They can’t imagine real grass-roots organization from anybody else.
dr-debunk,
Is that term “dog” being used as aterm of endurement as Randy Jackson so often use on “American Idol” or, are you being an IGNORANT FOOL?
Now, watch how fast the numbers change once Obama actually have a paln in hand that he endoses. You brilliant ones do realize that Obama have not done such a thing yet, don’t you?
The Democrats are toast if there isn’t a public option within the whatever plan that is finally endosed by Obama.
“Fake or real, they are certainly ignorant being so disruptive and disrespectful of others who do want information.”
D–, what if the congress critter isnt giving real information? What if those disruptive folks have done somthing the congress critters havent done, READ THE DAMN BILL!!!
Because sheeple like you dont mind eating a crap sandwich, doesnt mean others have to sit ideally by while others are forced to eat the crap sandwich.
Oops,
Correction: Should have spelled [endearment] and not endurement incorrectly above.
Si,
If what you state is the case then those critters as you call them should act as if they can read and not as a bunch of illiterates.
Si,
Correction: that should have been if, what you state is true concerning the disruptive folks should act as if they can read and not as a bunch of illiterates.
Also, who in the Republican Conservative Party have the nerve to refer to anyone as sheeple? Not our little Si, go figure. (lol).
Thugs have rights, too.
Dissent, even the churlish kind, is part of the (little d) democratic process.
Sic biscuitus disintegrat.