Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.30.2008 5:00 pm

Driving while black can get you pulled over

  • Email this
  • Print this

The Associated Press is reporting that black drivers are more likely to be stopped by police in Missouri than are white drivers, and minorities are twice as likely to have to be searched.

From the story: “Black drivers are more likely to be stopped in Missouri than white and Hispanic motorists, but minorities are twice as likely to be searched and arrested than whites.

An annual state report released Friday by the attorney general’s office shows that in 2007, black drivers were 66 percent more likely to be pulled over than white motorists. A Hispanic driver was slightly more likely to be pulled over than a white one.”

Most disturbing was that while whites were less likely to be searched, they were more likely to have contraband.

As a daughter of a former police officer and someone who was pulled over for being white (no joke), I have mixed feelings about these reports. I have a difficult time believing that in most cases police know the race of a driver before switching on the strobe lights, but anecdotal and statistical information seems to contradict that.

Carolyn Tuft, now an online reporter for the Post-Dispatch, did an investigative report on alleged racial profiling by the Belleville Police Department when she worked for the Belleville News-Democrat. Her report, done in the early 1990s and picked up by “60 Minutes,” indicated that police were targeting black drivers in a tony west-end neighborhood of Belleville.

Missouri has been compiling information on racial-profiling in Missouri since 2000. Law enforcement agencies track stops by race, age and gender of the driver and by whether a ticket was issued. Agencies that don’t comply could have state funds withheld.

Read the AP story here.

9 comments

Comments are closed.

The reports are misleading. It isn’t that the police are “targeting” blacks, it is that a disproportionate number of blacks don’t properly register their vehicles (valid reason to stop) and a disproportionate number of blacks don’t pay their tickets and therefore have warrants issued (reason for arrest). Of course, there are other reasons to stop/arrest, but that’s a big one. Regardless, you have to be able to articulate a valid reason for making a stop and the traffic analysis report does not give you the full story.

And yes, sometimes people get stopped because they don’t “belong.” White people get stopped in North City or certain parts of North County because white people don’t generally frequent those areas unless it’s for drugs. It swings both ways.

— Clipper
5:52 pm May 30th, 2008

One thing, of course, that could be said of racial profiling is that it seems to work. In almost every case, the police officer is not purposely with intent smd malice looking for minorities to stop. The statistics indicate that blacks commit most violent crimes. I wish they would stop.

It is kind of like not profiling Islamo-killer muslims who want to board aircraft in the USA. Some things just should not occur.
Once again, political correctness errors on the side of moronic lunacy.

— conrwing
6:58 pm May 30th, 2008

It can also work in reverse. I am white and often volunteer in the inner-city. I’ve been pulled over twice by the cops “wondering what I was doing there?” And don’t get me going about St. George, they are definately an equal opportunity community.

— flyover
8:30 pm May 30th, 2008

Why not quit jabbering about this issue and let the police do their jobs? Many of us are eager to bend a little in favor of the black members of our community, but the fact remains that a few of them need to be pulled over and searched, particularly young males, and their “contraband” can be far more serious stuff than what other people are likely to carry.

I respect the input by “BoB St. Louis” as to who runs lights and stop signs the most, but am not sure that I agree. That’s done a lot in the lily white suburbs.

— Senior citizen
9:39 am May 31st, 2008

Where my office is, I see a disproportionate number of African-Americans being pulled over. Sometimes it is because of something is wrong with the vehicle, but other times the reason is not as apparent.

Recently, however, I have noticed an increase in tickets being issued to Caucasian drivers.

My pet peeve are those people who drive an expensive silver car who seem to think that no traffic laws apply to them. It is more so if the are blond. How’s that for profiling — if they are blond driving a silver car, pull them over, they have done something wrong most likely.

— RHarnack
12:35 pm May 31st, 2008

That “expensive silver car” is probably either a humongous Lexus SUV or a Bimmer convertible, driven at 20 mph over the limit through a school zone by a bleached blond who thinks American cars aren’t fit to seen at her golf outing. She’s driving with a cigarette in one hand, a latte in the other, and a cell phone under her jaw. Somehow, she’s also reaching for a compact to fix her face before arriving at the club. Now that’s multi-tasking!

The cop may be profiling her but the ticket won’t hold up because she’s going to get her third husband, a lawyer, to fix it as usual.

Tell us you’ve never seen something like this happen.

— Senior citizen
4:20 pm May 31st, 2008

Ok, I’ve never seen something like this happen. I also have never seen anyone of any stripe pulled over from my office window much less an abnormal amount of it.

— slamfist
8:51 am June 1st, 2008

In the category of one’s expectations being met:
Yesterday, as I was driving home, I noticed a silver car (a sports convertible) being driven by a blond (male in the case), swerving back-and-forth as if they wanted to drive around me.

Now I was on Manchester where it narrows down to one lane each way, so there was not enough room, and, I was driving the 30 MPH speed limit. This particular yahoo had no room, insisted on speeding up, trying to pass on the right where there were parked cars, etc. When he finally got to the corner he apparently where he wanted to turn, he takes off at 45 - 50 MPH (on another residential street).

Sadly, no patrol cars were around.

— RHarnack
10:58 am June 2nd, 2008

Slamfist -
Does your window face into the office pool area?

— RHarnack
11:00 am June 2nd, 2008