Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
05.13.2008 8:50 am

Schlafly v. Mugabe: Degree or not degree, that is the question

St. Louis Post-Dispatch
  • Email this
  • Print this

mugabe_opt.jpgThe Boston Globe today reports that Jack M. Wilson, president of thephyllis_opt.jpg University of Massachusetts, may rescind an honorary degree awarded to President Robert Mugabe of Zimbabwe, who is facing international scorn and sanctions for his authoritarian regime’s bloody campaign against political opponents.

This makes Washington University’s problems with protests of plans to award an honorary degree Friday to Phyllis Schlafly pale by comparison. Whatever you might think about Mrs. Schlafly, she’s no Robert Mugabe.

63 comments

Comments are closed.

And to compare the two, even it was tongue in cheek, shows the Post Dispatch is not a credible journalistic enterprise.

Here’s a little history lesson for you: The Leftist intelligentsia in this country have ALWAYS supported dictators and totalitarians, no matter how economically distastrous, socially backward, or genocidal they are, so long as they use the word socialist in their party platforms. (The Left swooned over Mussolini, Stalin, and Mao for decades, and many so-called Progressives even admired Hitler right up to the moment we went to war with him.)Therefore it’s no great suprise a pillar of the academic Left would think nothing of honoring a blight on humanity like Mugabe. Conservatives in this country on the other hand, especially staunch supporters of classical liberalism and democracy like Phyliss Schlafly, NEVER have.

But by all means, continue to publish execrable smears against honorable people. When your readership finally plummits to zero, you won’t have to look hard for the answer why.

— Go_Fish
9:36 am May 13th, 2008

Mr. H, I surely hope that you are not trying to compare Mrs. Schlafly and Mugabe. Have you “Googled” Mugabe?

— A CENTRIST
10:23 am May 13th, 2008

Go Fish, you might want to learn how to read; the post clearly states that the two cases are not equivalent.

I agree Mugabe is a far worse person. However, Schlafly should also not get a degree because her stated positions are directly opposed to the commitment to diversity in WashU’s mission, and because she has insulted the women, foreign students, and members of the GLBT community who are graduating. If anyone wants to know what Schlafly thinks, just check out these quotes:

“By getting married, the woman has consented to sex, and I don’t think you can call it rape.” (speech at Bates College, 28 March 2007; WashU’s Student Life, 12 May 2008)

“Sexual harassment on the job is not a problem for virtuous women, except in the rarest of cases. Men hardly ever ask sexual favors of women from whom the certain answer is no. Virtuous women are seldom accosted.” (TIME Magazine, 4 May 1981)

“The flight from the home is a flight from yourself, from responsibility, from the nature of woman, in pursuit of false hopes and fading illusions.” (www.CampusProgress.org)

— Adam
10:28 am May 13th, 2008

My friends, surely you’re reading too much into this post. After all, I’m the one who started this whole Phyllis Schlafly-Washington U controversy on this blog a week ago yesterday and came out forthrightly in favor of academic freedom, even as applied to wingnuts.

Today’s post came about as I was doing some of my assiduous research and preparation for the day’s work and came across a link to the Boston Globe story on the National Journal’s “earlybird” news summary. I thought, “Hmm, Robert Mugabe. And Mark Wrighton thinks HE has problems.”

So I posted the story for all to enjoy. And now I’m getting insinuations that I’m part of the vast left-wing conspiracy. I tell ya, I don’t get no respect.

— Kevin Horrigan
10:33 am May 13th, 2008

Mr. Horrigan:

So, how’s this whole ‘reader feedback’ thing working for you?

Yeah, thought as much. Well, have a great day… oh, and keep your hand out of the crazy, will ya?

— tsquare
10:41 am May 13th, 2008

Tsquare–it’s working great. The more some readers write, the more reasonable and wise our opinions appear. Thanks for all your help!

— Kevin Horrigan
10:44 am May 13th, 2008

“Schlafly should also not get a degree because her stated positions are directly opposed to the commitment to diversity in WashU’s mission, and because she has insulted the women, foreign students, and members of the GLBT community who are graduating.”

I have stayed out of this Schlafly brew ha ha because I think it is just stupid, and quite telling of the left. Lets look at the above statement: The writer seems to make us believe the support this thing called “diversity”, but wants Schlafly’s opinions silenced. That is the lefts version of “diversity”, silence all who disagree. Then you mention that she had the audacity to INSULT people (again, by expressing opinions not in lock step with theirs)?

I see no better expression of “diversity” than to award an honor to someone who is “diverse” from WashU.

— Si Vis Pacem Para Bellum
11:26 am May 13th, 2008

Well said sir!

Might have been the best thing you’ve written in a long time.

Not that you’re right, of course.

— tsquare
11:26 am May 13th, 2008

Sorry Si Vis, forgot who I was dealing with. I’ll explain this very slowly for you; there’s a difference between (A) a university allowing a diversity of viewpoints, and (B) awarding its highest honor to someone who is opposed to the core commitments of the university. That is, you can have a university that allows all different kinds of viewpoints, without awarding its highest honor to all of those viewpoints, and in particular to those viewpoints that are demeaning to other members of the university. Most people understand this difference, which is why absolutely *no one* has called for Schlafly’s opinions to be silenced. See how that works! I know, thinking is a pretty amazing thing.

By the way, how did I end up in a freeper chatroom?

— Adam
12:08 pm May 13th, 2008

How dare you even suggest a conncection. Outrageous. This PC-baiting doesn’t deserve respect.

— flyover
12:09 pm May 13th, 2008

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7 » Show All