Does Macy’s tell Gimbel’s?
I was in Grand Center and the Central West End this afternoon making the rounds as someone newly back in town, checking in with more people whom I consider to be especially thoughtful and who have a record of getting things done.
My travels took me to ostensible competitors — Dr. Donald Suggs, publisher of the St. Louis American, the influential community weekly, and the editorial staff of The St. Louis Beacon, the new non-profit news site led by distinguished journalists who spent long careers at the Post-Dispatch.
I have followed Dr. Suggs for some years and I have had a chance to talk with him before at length, and always liked him — found him to be fiercely intelligent, reasonable and genuinely interested in community life.
I have read press reports about an unhappy turn in relations between Dr. Suggs and Mayor Francis Slay (whom I also like), but Dr. Suggs and I spent most of our time talking about big picture history, trends, and challenges confronting the city and the region.
Dr. Suggs made an especially interesting observation about Barack Obama, drawing a comparison with Bill Clinton that I had not heard before:
Both men could have made a lot of money at a young age doing other things, but took career paths that had ridiculously meager prospects of national influence or personal wealth.
Clinton with his Georgetown, Yale and Oxford degrees, and Obama having graduated from Columbia and then Harvard Law School (where he was president of the law review), could have written their own tickets on Wall Street, as lawyers or investment bankers.
But rather than pursuing almost certain and substantial wealth, one decided to pursue state political office in a small, relatively poor southern state. The other became a community organizer in Chicago, then a law professor and civil rights lawyer.
After visiting with Dr. Suggs I swung by The Beacon’s fabulous newsroom in
KETC-TV/Channel 9’s building in Grand Center.
Some press watchers have breathlessly posed The Beacon as a Post-Dispatch competitor, but I don’t see it that way.
To the contrary, I see the P-D, the American, and Beacon as natural allies in a competition against Facebook, NetFlix, and PlayStation.
On the business side, I think of the old saw about how, when a town has just one lawyer he or she typically starves. But when a town has two or three lawyers they all thrive.
There always is room for more well-informed community discussion, the livelier and wider and more interesting the better — for everyone.


Eddie Roth writes about education, social justice, public safety, transportation, legal affairs and historic preservation. He joined the Post-Dispatch editorial page in 2008 after six years as an editorial writer with the Dayton Daily News. But he is not new to St. Louis. Eddie grew up in Webster Groves and south St. Louis County. He's a lawyer who for many years practiced with a downtown firm, and was active in civic affairs, including serving a term on the St. Louis Police Board. He and his wife, Jeanne, and their three daughters, Emily, Julia and Alice, live in the Shaw Neighborhood.
When it comes to community organizing, he endorses Quentin Crisp's advice: Rather than keeping up with the Joneses, it's better to pull them down to your level.
Clinton and Obama know there’s no payday like the former President’s payday. Personally, I am sick of seeing our leaders come from the same places. I would love to see a President from UMSL or SIUE or SLU (sorry, I would probably not want to see one from intolerant Wash U). I also follow the Beacon. It doesn’t really seem to have any news. A lot of opinons, not much news. They also leave the “stories” up forever. It will be very interesting to see how they evolve and if they display the slant the Post has. With support from KETC, they will have to walk a fine line or it could alienate contributors to those incessant fund drives.
Is Mr Suggs trying to tell you that Mr Clinton and Mr Obama are not in it for the money? Has Mr Gephart or Mr Clay come back to St Louis?
The only two politicians who walked away from the big money of politics that I am aware of are messrs Eagleton and Danforth.
As a resident of Chesterfield I pick up the American weekly to see if I will read anything encouraging. All I read about is the consistent complaining about the replacement of Sherman George.
It’s none of my business but are any of your three daughters going to attend a city school?
I just hope that the PD will air what the costs of change will be under Mr Obama.
not exactly competitor with Facebook if Beacon has a page on it? just a thought.