Pottery barn schools

Rick Sullivan (right) talks with parents and teachers at a meeting in 2007. Huy Richard Mach | Post-Dispatch
Gov. Jay Nixon is a key figure in the stability of St. Louis Public Schools. There’s no avoiding it — the district’s hard-fought battle to restore its credibility depends on Mr. Nixon’s early support for its leadership.
When the state Board of Education invoked the state’s takeover law and stripped the district of its accreditation in 2007, Gov. Matt Blunt appointed Rick Sullivan, former chairman of McBride & Son, a national homebuilder, to head the Special Administrative Board that oversees the district. Mr. Sullivan took over on June 15, 2007.
The other two members are Melanie Adams, a program director at the Missouri History Museum appointed by Mayor Francis Slay, and Richard Gaines, an insurance executive appointed by St. Louis Aldermanic President Lewis Reed.
Mr. Sullivan’s three-year term comes to a close in less than a year. It may seem as though there’s no urgency for Mr. Nixon to reappoint him or make his intentions known. But if a lame-duck chairman heads the SAB, the district’s momentum could be halted. The steps the district has taken toward regaining its accreditation could be reversed.
Mr. Sullivan has earned the opportunity to continue the steady progress in the district. Mr. Nixon should not let the issue linger unless he’s prepared to take full political responsibility for the district’s success or failure.
The SAB inherited a district riddled with vacancies in top positions, hemorrhaging students and facing deficits as far as the eye could see. Mr. Sullivan and his colleagues have had to make deep budget cuts, $53 million in the coming school year alone.
They have led an open and inclusive debate on the future of the district’s school buildings — culminating with the closing of 17 buildings. They reached a new collective bargaining agreement with teachers; successfully defended a lawsuit challenging their authority; developed a comprehensive school improvement plan (as they are required to do under state law) and hired a well-regarded new superintendent, Kelvin Adams, who has a made a big impression since starting work in November.
Above all, Mr. Sullivan and his colleagues have brought order and seriousness of purpose to the district’s public proceedings, a desperately needed change from the conflict and chaos that preceded the district’s loss of accreditation.
The SAB members don’t agree on all matters. But they’ve engaged in a constructive give and take. They have freed Mr. Adams from distractions, enabling the superintendent to focus on the central mission of raising student achievement.
As Mr. Nixon weighs his options, he should reflect on the conditions that contributed to the Board of Education’s decision to pull the district’s accreditation: “poor academic performance, frequent changes in executive leadership, declining enrollment, deteriorating finances, loss of public confidence and persistent conflicts within the board of education and between the board and a series of superintendents.”
To leave Mr. Sullivan in limbo or, worse, to replace him would invite more disruption, as yet another leader would try to surmount the steep learning curve of this complicated institution.
Former Secretary of State Colin Powell famously invoked the “Pottery Barn Rule” when he argued against military intervention in Iraq with President George W. Bush: “You break it, you own it.”
So it goes with Gov. Jay Nixon and St. Louis Public Schools.


I don’t know what Mr. Sullivan gets paid, if anything, whatever it is it’s not enough. The mere fact he’s willing to take on this job is amazing.
“So it goes with Gov. Jay Nixon and St. Louis Public Schools.”
How is it that the pottery barn rule applies to Nixon, but did not apply to the City of St. Louis?
If any member of the SAB were to suddenly disappear tomorrow and that caused the district to fall into instability, that would show their failure, not their success. Board members change, just as legislators and governors do. Legislatures, states, and our country survive(s) changes in leadership all the time. Many people like Mr. Sullivan, but he won’t be the CEO of SLPS forever. The system has to be able to transition, whenever that time comes.
All the King’s horses and all the King’s men, can’t put city schools back together again.
THE SAB is in a bizarre position. It’s unreasonable to believe that in such a short time they could reverse the systemic, long-term problems of SLPS. On the other hand, the deed restriction issue is an example of a sort of ridiculous misdirection: the fact that time was spent marking their territory while kids are passed out of SLPS without diplomas is like painting the nails of a heart attack victim.
Katherine Wessling’s point is astute, and I agree that the SAB’s main objective was to get the school system to a place where they no longer NEEDED an SAB board, and help a local board transition into real and effective leadership and take responsibility for their community. What is in place to serve future boards in completing a plan to make STL schools effective long-term, and not just curbing some of the nastier problems?
I know they’ve tackled downsizing and money management, but I don’t know how they’ve improved the situation for children growing up in STL city today.
To have to stretch and somehow pull President Bush via Colin Powell into this is pathetic. I just read today (July 3, 2009) that Chris Wright (former Riverview Gardens superindenint) is now the new Missouri commissioner of education. And then I saw that she is married to Mr. Nicastro, my gym coach at Riverview (class of 1984). Good for him, good for her. I am truly happy for her, Coach Nicastro, and the state of Missouri. But I dont’t see how George Bush fits into any of this. Give up the BDS (Bush Derangement Syndrome). This issue is a local / state issue. Give up the Bush hate for a few days.