The Great Conciliator takes on financial regulation
If Ronald Reagan was the “Great Communicator,” Barack Obama is the “Great Conciliator.” It may always have been thus.
“Obama is always disappointing people who feel that he gives too much respect or yields too much ground to the other side, rather than fighting aggressively for his principles,” wrote Larissa MacFarquhar in a New Yorker profile in May 2007, 18 months before he was elected president.
He has done nothing since to disprove that notion. Continuing a massive troop presence in Iraq; upping the number of troops deployed to Afghanistan; leaving a place at the table for private insurers in his health care reform plan and industry in his climate control plan.
On Wednesday, this practitioner of domestic realpolitik unveiled the most massive overhaul of financial regulation since the New Deal. It will be said of Mr. Obama what was said then of Franklin D. Roosevelt: He didn’t go far enough.
It may also be said, as it was said of FDR, that he aims at the possible, not the perfect. Mr. Obama told reporters on Tuesday, “We want to get this thing passed, and speed is important. We want to it right. We want to do it carefully. But we don’t want to tilt at windmills.”
As to the importance of speed: It has been nearly a year since the financial markets imploded, and only now are the president and Congress preparing to make sure it doesn’t happen again. And inasmuch as Congress is expected to spend the summer and fall debating climate change and health care reform, it may be well into 2010 before serious debate begins on regulatory change.
The greatest shortcoming in Mr. Obama’s regulatory plan is its failure to address the immense political power of the banking and financial industry. All the regulations in the world — and there are a lot of new ones in the plan — cannot control an industry that owns as much of Congress as this one does.
Consider this plaintive reaction to Mr. Obama’s plan from House Minority Leader John Boehner of Ohio,“I think it’s just going to be too big of a foot on an industry that already is having financial problems.”
The industry will whine, but its influence is seen in Mr. Obama’s plan. Much of the current regulatory structure is left in place. Bankers still will be able to find friendly ears in high places. Limits on executive compensation are mostly theoretical. The proposed first-ever regulations on hedge funds are absurdly mild.
That said, Mr. Obama’s proposal offers many distinct improvements, chiefly the creation of a Consumer Financial Protection Agency. With the right leadership and the right rule-making ability, the CFPA should be able to prevent a recurrence of the kind of deep-rooted mortgage fraud and credit card abuses that some in the financial industry practiced.
We like the idea of turning the Federal Reserve into what Derek Thompson of The Atlantic’s business blog called a “free safety,” roaming the field to identify and deal with systemic risks to the economy. The proposal to extend regulation to all “Tier 1 FHCs” — that is, big financial holding companies that act like banks even though they aren’t technically banks — is long overdue. The derivative and credit default swap markets would be policed.
The coming months will offer ample opportunity to discuss this plan in detail. For the time being, the key question is whether it would prevent what happened last year from happening again. The answer is: Maybe. With this president and this Congress, maybe is as good as it gets.


Here’s a scathing Post editorial like so many others: President Obama is beset by powerful interest groups that control (a) the Congress, (b) the economy, or (c) the regulatory watchdogs. Free markets are a failure, public officials are lapdogs to the industry involved, and the status quo is firmly entrenched. Oh, woe is us!
And yet, somehow, THIS President and THIS Congress give us a chance! Glory be! Somehow, this same ordinary politician become Chief Executive, and a collection of Congressional losers that would make a Cubs manager lose all hope can yet pull our chestnuts from the fire. That, or they’ll blame it on (a) global warming, (b) evangelical Christians, military veterans, or Rush Limbaugh, or (C) George W Bush/Dick Cheney.
With apologies to Bart Simpson, “I puke. THE END.”
The Great Conciliator? Wow, that’s a riot. Well, I guess you could say that he has brought conciliation to a diverse group including Michael Moore, Al Franken, Jesse Jackson, and Ted Kennedy. I don’t think he has gone far enough to pacify Ani DiFranco or Cynthia McKinney, but you can’t please all of the people all the time … right?
Obviously you think more highly of the socialism FDR set upon our country than I do. Unfortunately President Obama hasn’t found an area yet not to expand the Federal Government just like FDR.
If your aim is to control everything, then there’s no time to lose; rush it all through quick! Wait till these controls start bumping into each other, and directly into us – individuals. We’ll get yet more controls to cope with the failures of the months-old controls.
Endemic of our times – his plan on c/c contracts is to keep the text plain, simple and short. This from the guy(s) that signed a 6,000 page stimulus bill – never bothering to read it.
It’s about time the editorial hacks at the PD got around to printing their April Fools piece.
The Great Stutterer (uh,uh,uh,uh) is going to save us from those greedy banks, global warming and greedy doctors. Good one. But first he has to fly to Chicago to play pick-up basketball.
“This from the guy(s) that signed a 6,000 page stimulus bill – never bothering to read it”
True — but at least our Senators and Representatives read it. They did… didn’t they ??
My eleven year old grandson spends most of the money he earns mowing yards on cheap plastic toys.
Obviously we need a federal youth piggy bank Czar and a federal toy advertizing Czar. Hurry!
Well here is the Post trying to make a virtue out of a reality. What Mr Obama is quickly learning is that it is one thing to run for office and another to actually govern. While running for office, he’s out there taking pot-shots at everyone, making all sorts of feel-good statements and promises. Now he has to govern, and he’s quickly finding that it isn’t quite so easy (although a lap-dog press certainly helps!)
What I love is that so many of the Obamaniacs are starting to refer to this administration as Bush’s third term. I guess he’s learning that ‘dumb old George’ actually made some good and well-informed decisions.
vfdgirl-or like Reagan, who added 60,000+ to the federal payroll?
Again with the picture with Obama with the Presidential Seal directly behind his head to create a subliminal “Halo” reference that he’s divine, a Messiah figure.