Phyllis v. Ike v. Nelly



One more quick question before Phyllis Schlafly gets her honorary sheepskin (from an honorary sheep, perhaps) from Washington University on Friday….
Though the situations are not precisely parallel, the controversy nonetheless recalls two other recent honors kerfluffles:
• Mayor Clarence Harmon’s refusal in 2000 to issue a proclamation in honor of Nelly, the local rap superstar. Nelly fans were outraged. Mr. Harmon’s successor, Francis Slay, countermanded that decision in 2001.
• But Mr. Slay last year refused to extend similar recognition to rock ‘n roll pioneer Ike Turner, earning the mayor raspberries from rock fans across the nation.
Phyllis, Nelly and Ike — who had the biggest impact on American life and letters?



Kevin Horrigan is deputy editor of the editorial page. He writes editorials on local, state and national politics and public policy and also contributes a signed column to the Sunday Commentary Page. "The Old Sport" is a former sports columnist for the Post-Dispatch and for 10 years hosted radio talk shows on KMOX and KTRS in St. Louis. He lives in South St. Louis with his wife, Kate, and a dream of one day starting a professional catfish noodling tour.
I’ll take the bait.
Ike Turner was a drug-addled musician with a penchant for beating women.
Nelly is a semi-literate rap “artist” whose “music” (like most all rap music) celebrates thugs, drugs and misogyny.
Phyllis Schlafly is a Phi Beta Kappa graduate of Washington University, a graduate of Washington University Law School, and she received a Master’s in Political Science from Harvard University at the age of 20. She’s authored or edited 20 books, and her radio commentaries are heard on 500 stations. Ladies Home Journal named her one of the 100 Most Important Women of the 20th century, and Good Housekeeping named her one of the 10 Most Admired Women in the world. In her spare time, she raised 6 kids and stood as a beacon for conservative family values against a tidal wave of progressive decadence.
Ask most anyone on the oh-so-nuanced left, however, and you’ll hear that Ike Turner was a rock and roll pioneer, Nelly is a thoughtful urban poet, and Phyllis Schafly is an anti-intellectual threat to women everywhere.