Musial secure as 'Greatest Cardinal'

Share |
Musial secure as 'Greatest Cardinal'
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size
sp CL cards musialpujols01.JPG

More

In another decade or so, when Stan Musial would be 100 and Albert Pujols 40, the comparisons really could have begun.

If Pujols' next 10 years would have been anything like his first 11, the Cardinals' first baseman legitimately could have challenged, at least statistically, the revered Musial as the Greatest Cardinal of Them All."

Now, with Pujols fleeing to the Los Angeles Angels, Musial, as he has had for the last 50 or 60 years, will hold that title in undisputed fashion -- for our lifetimes and those of many others.

Pujols would have had to step it up a bit to catch Musial for career batting average as a Cardinal. He finished three points behind at .328 and 1,557 hits behind at 3,630-2,073.

Home runs would have been no contest. Musial wound up his 22-season career with 475 homers as a Cardinal. Pujols already has 445 on his way probably to 700 or more.

Runs batted in, the third part of a hitter's trifecta, also would have fallen to Pujols. Musial ended with 1,949. Pujols already has 1,329 and would have had to average only 70 or so RBIs a year to pass Musial there.

The runs scored category would have played out roughly the same way as Pujols trailed Musial by less than 700 at 1,949-1,295,

Musial, a speedster in his youth, won the triples "crown," at 77-15. Nobody gets a triple anymore these days and Pujols has had one or none in each of the last six seasons.

Two-base hits would have gone to Pujols, who lagged behind Musial by 270 at 725-455.

Pujols already had captured the stolen-base race at 84-78. Musial won three National League Most Valuable Player awards as a Cardinal. Pujols also has three.

But Musial won seven league batting titles to Pujols' one. Musial never won a home-run title while Pujols has two. Musial led in RBIs twice to once for Pujols.

The eras in which they played are/were vastly different. There are 30 big-league teams now, compared to 16 when Musial played, meaning there are 150 or more pitchers employed as big leaguers now and surely some of them aren't very good.

But in Musial's day, there were, at first, no non-Caucasian players. Even when he finished, there were very few Latin American players and almost none from Asia.

Musial, for most of his career, didn't have to travel west past St. Louis. And he didn't have to play nearly as many night games as Pujols.

But Musial had to wear wool uniforms, for the most part, as compared to the more comfortable garb of today. They played lots of doubleheaders 50 or 60 years ago. If they do now, they're contested as split twin bills.

Musial didn't have to put up with ESPN or blogging or tweeters. Pujols didn't have to put up with train travel and overnight Pullman cars.

The lefthanded-hitting Musial didn't have to face lefthanded fireballer Randy Johnson. The righthanded-batting Pujols didn't have to face righthanded fireballer Don Drysdale.

Musial will finish with one substantial edge in mid-season honors. Abetted by a couple of seasons when there were two games, Musial was on 24 National League All-Star squads as a Cardinal. Pujols was on nine.

For the moment, at least, Musial also finishes with a substantial edge in popularity. He had a chance to leave the Cardinals for Jorge Pascual's newly-formed Mexican League for $125,000, plus a $50,000 signing bonus, in 1946. Musial, earning $13,500 with the Cardinals at the time, didn't go.

 

Copyright 2012 stltoday.com. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print Email

Sponsored Links

videos

most popular