Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
Home > Rides > Old Car Column
 
Edsel: Wrong product at the wrong time
1959 Edsel
A "horse-collar" grill distinguished the 1959 Edsel. (www.Plan59.com)


Edsel Super Express V-8 Trivia Question of the Week: 1. What is the origin of the name ‘Edsel’? 2. Who was president of the United States in 1959? Was it, A. Eisenhower; B. Kennedy; C. Roosevelt or D. Truman? 3. Name the song title and the artist who performed the 1959 hit song containing the following lyrics: "I was standing on the corner when I heard my bulldog bark, he was barkin’ at the two men who were gamblin’ in the dark". 4. On November 18, 1959 a multimillion dollar epic movie was released by MGM. It was a Technicolor film starring Charlton Heston that was critically acclaimed and eventually won 11 Academy Awards, a record held until 1998 when Titanic became the first film to equal that record. What was the name of this classic movie? 5. On October of 1959, this 19-year old, former U.S. Marine emigrated to the Soviet Union announcing that he would "never return to the United States". He did return, however, in 1962 and a year later would be arrested in connection with the assassination of president John F. Kennedy. What was his name and what was the name of the man who shot and killed him as he was being taken into custody? 6. What could be considered ‘the X-Files of the fifties’, this classic science fiction anthology series by Rod Serling was released on October 2, 1959 on the CBS television network. What was its name? 7. Who was leader of the Soviet Union in 1959 during the so called ‘cold war’? 8. What state was admitted to the union on August 21, 1959?
"Aim was right, but target moved!"

Such was the quote by a prominent historian back in ‘the day’. The unfortunate Edsel’s reputation has been maligned ever since the controversial car was publicly introduced on Wednesday, September 4, 1957. Had it been introduced just nine days later, it would have debuted on Friday the 13th– although I don’t know how much worse the outcome for this ill-fated marque could have possibly been.
At least one dictionary lists the name ‘Edsel’ as synonymous with ‘loser’. Jokes swirled around the name for decades after the marque was cast aside to join the ranks of ‘orphaned’ automobile makes. The Edsel debacle has been the subject of numerous marketing studies and theses through the years. One of the most common misconceptions by many, is that the Edsel was a ‘bad’ automobile, plagued with mechanical bugaboos and malfunctions. Let The FIN MAN set the record straight. The Edsel was a mechanically sound automobile, developed under a flawed marketing program... a prime example of the wrong product at the wrong time. Edsel became a sparkle in the eyes of Ford Motor Company president Henry Ford II and chairman Ernest Breech in 1954 as Ford was recovering from disastrous sales and near collapse of the company in the late forties. They studied rival General Motors with their five-brand model lineup and believed that Ford needed an equally broad base of models. Edsel was intended to be a ‘super Mercury’ if you will, adding another mid-priced brand to the Ford lineup. Pre-production promises of exciting and revolutionary technology, including a ‘steering bar’ with twin, circular rings at each end of a horizontal bar, never made it to production models. In addition to futuristic feature let downs, prospective automobile buyers never warmed up to Edsel’s controversial styling cues, the most prominent of which was the ‘horse-collar’ grill.
The new car, dubbed the ‘E-car’ and the focal point of Ford’s M-E-L plan (Mercury-Edsel-Lincoln)was the result of a lengthy marketing production. Naming it was no small task either. Writers, advertising and marketing experts were all called upon to come up with suggestions. Henry Ford’s family never wanted it to bear the younger Ford’s name and Henry said he never wanted to see Edsel’s name spinning round and round on a hubcap. Breech got tired of waiting for a decision and took the bull by the horns, naming the car Edsel, despite opposition from Ford family members.
The end was near for the much anticipated new line from Ford, almost before it began. Only in its second production year, already the line was being watered down, moving from four models in the ‘58 lineup, to just two for 1959. Gone was the Pacer and the glitzy, high line Citation of one year prior. Only the Ranger and Corsair were offered in the second year of production. Gone too were some of the highly touted futuristic features of the Edsel, namely the ‘Teletouch’ gear selector... a push-button arrangement much like Mopars, but mounted centrally in the steering wheel hub. The selector buttons remained stationary while the steering wheel itself rotated around them. Another interesting feature was the horizontally positioned drum type speedometer. The numbers were imprinted on what resembled a small dish, placed upside down and centrally located at the upper portion of the instrument panel. A vertical line appeared in the middle and the dish rotated as speed increased allowing the imprinted speed numbers to pass the center line mark. The ‘59 models had a much more conventional instrument panel and a standard, column mounted shift lever. What was promised in all the preproduction advertising hype, an advanced, futuristic car with features never seen before, became merely a dressed up Ford, all to similar in form and function to the Mercury, but with dubious aesthetic qualities.
Convenience and appearance options were much like typical Ford and Mercury cars. Edsels were built on Ford assembly lines. 1958 models were built in one of six plants including Louisville, Kentucky; San Jose, California; Somerville, Massachusetts; Madwah, New Jersey; Wayne, Michigan and Los Angeles, California. By 1959, only the Louisville plant assembled Edsel automobiles. First year model production was predicted by Ford management to hit 200,000 units, but only a little over 61,000 were actually built. Production for the 1959 model year peaked at just under 45,000 units.
Despite all the negatives, Edsel did produce some new and promising features and is today a highly prized collectible automobile which can often be bought ‘for a song’ compared to many other brands– that’s IF you can find one. According to the Old Cars Price Guide, a ‘59 Edsel Ranger, like the one illustrated above, would run between sixteen and seventeen thousand dollars in near number one, trophy winning condition... a reasonable outlay for a car so rare and with such a fascinating history.
Puruesing a recent copy of Auto Trader’s Classic Cars & Parts, turned up not one Edsel. But check back in a month or two and you’re likely to find one here and there. Go to a big car show in your neighborhood this summer and you’ll see a number of ‘57 Chevy Bel Airs, but there would be little chance of seeing an Edsel. One place that you may have a better chance, however, is the upcoming Easter Car Show at the Municipal Opera, upper parking lot in Forest Park. Organized by the Horseless Carriage Club of Missouri, this annual event, held on Easter Sunday, can be one of the biggest and best, or one of the biggest disappointments... depending on the infamous St. Louis weather. Last year it was cold, windy and rainy... so I think we’re due for a nice one for 2009. Be sure to stop by and walk the entire show. If the weather is good, there will be a great display with row after row of historic automobiles. You’ll see cars there that you won’t find at most community shows. Whether you’re just a tire kicker, a collectible car owner or and Edsel fan... you’ll enjoy the day. A bonus, and for a good number of people the feature draw on Easter Sunday, is the hot rod and custom car show on the lower Muni lot. Talk about unique... that’s what custom rods and street machines are all about. Each creation is a work of art unlike any other anywhere in the world. The promoters like to call this one "The REAL Easter Show".
If you’d like to learn more about the infamous Edsel, visit the Edsel Owners Club at www.edselclub.org. National clubs like this one, have local area chapters from sea to shining sea, and they provide a wealth of information for owners, prospective owners or those who merely are fascinated with the cars. Ownership is typically not a requirement for membership. Monthly newsletters are common and included in your membership fees. These publications always include classified ads by members for cars and restoration parts.
Don’t forget to mark your calendars. Join The FIN MANTM at St. Clair Square in Fairview Heights, Illinois THIS Saturday, March 7th, 2009 for the Make-A-Wish Foundation, Illinois Chapter mall walk. Registration is at 8:30 a.m. on the 7th. Watch the FIN MAN’s web site for details. http://www.thefinman.com.
You can e-mail The FIN MAN at mailto://the_fin_man@msn.com. ‘The FIN MAN’TM is available for your group’s special occasion. In addition to his seminar schedule, he has been a guest speaker at group meetings including car clubs, engineering clubs and other professional associations. He has also acted as host or emcee at a number of special events including trivia parties, holiday parties, social and professional club events, benefits and fund raisers. We are now accepting bookings for calendar year 2009. During his appearances, he presents an overview of the collector car hobby plus a detailed look at American cars from the fifties and sixties. His program includes a fascinating Power Point presentation with images of collectible automobiles and various associated nostalgia and Americana. Guests also have the opportunity to play "FINS for FUN," the video game he produced in 1987 which inspired his nickname, in which players compete to identify the year, make and model of cars from tightly cropped photos of fins and taillights. Those who score the highest win auto-related prizes donated by supporting Fin Man sponsors. For more information, click on this link: http://groups.msn.com/the-fin-man/seminaragenda.msnw.
Bruce Kunz is a member of the Society of Automotive Historians, the St. Louis Chapter of the Buick Club of America and the Monte Carlo Owners Association of America. He welcomes your comments and suggestions. To e-mail him, click here > mailto:the_fin_man@msn.com.

Join the FIN MAN and friends on Saturday, March 7th for the Make A Wish mall walk at St. Clair Square. Details at www.thefinman.com.

Bruce Kunz- a.k.a. "The FIN MAN"

Write a letter to the editors | Subscribe to a newsletter | Subscribe to the newspaper
Read the latest autos stories | View all P-D stories from the last 7 days

reader comments

COMMENTING RULES: We encourage an open exchange of ideas in the STLtoday community, but we ask you to follow our guidelines. Basically, be civil, smart, on-topic and free from profanity. Don't say anything you wouldn't want your mother to read! And remember: We may miss some, so we need your help to police these comments. Please identify the comment, the story and why you think it's objectionable. Read the commenting guidelines
 
yesterday's most emailed
new start career training
Dead end job? Search here for the training you need to revive your career today!