|
'Amelia' soars but doesn't reach for the stars
![]() POST-DISPATCH FILM CRITIC
If a generation of girls grows up without hearing the word "tomboy" used as an insult, it's partly thanks to Hilary Swank, who has won two Oscars for portraying gender-role rebels. For those girls' grandmothers, a heroic role model was Amelia Earhart, the Midwestern girl who became the first woman to fly across the Atlantic. In the biopic "Amelia," the actress and the aviatrix are a match made in heaven, but surrounding the soaring performance is a movie that's mostly earthbound. The mix of rapture and realism does produce some sparks. "Amelia" has an astute sense of the publicity apparatus that turned a gawky girl from Atchison, Kan., into a global celebrity. In 1928, a year after Charles Lindbergh's solo flight across the Atlantic, New York publisher George Putnam (Richard Gere) seeks a qualified young woman to duplicate the feat. Apprentice pilot Earhart (Swank) convinces him that she's got the necessary skills and courage. Although she literally takes a back seat to a male pilot and navigator, the successful flight from Newfoundland to Wales earns her a ticker-tape parade. As Earhart tours the country, enlisting investors and competitors for new challenges, Putnam uses her to test his theories on something called public relations, and eventually he proposes matrimony as a strategic alliance. Although Earhart insists she's a "vagabond of the air," she agrees to a trial marriage if it doesn't entail obedience. That loophole opens the door for another suitor, a flight instructor named Gene Vidal (Ewan McGregor) with a star-struck son named Gore. (Yes, that Gore Vidal.) Although it illustrates Earhart's independence, the love triangle is sketchily executed. Director Mira Nair ("Monsoon Wedding") seems more engaged by the critique of commercialism — a montage of product endorsements is worthy of Busby Berkeley — and celebrating the sensation of flight. As Putnam and/or Vidal fret below, Earhart soars over scenic wonders. Although "Amelia" is too conventionally constructed to attain the heights of Martin Scorsese's "The Aviator," the cinematography and Depression-era props are splendid. Swank, of course, is too. And the last segment of the film, in which the ill-fated Earhart and an emotionally scarred navigator named Fred Noonan (Christopher Eccleston) hopscotch across the Southern Hemisphere, is heartbreaking. But since it isn't tethered to a suspenseful ending, there's no reason why "Amelia" shouldn't have aimed for the stars.
Write a letter to the editors |
Subscribe to a newsletter |
Subscribe to the newspaper
|
'Amelia'
‘Amelia’ director has charted her own course
Mira Nair is worldly — born in India, educated at Harvard, married to a Ugandan, at home in New York — but the director of the new biography “Amelia” found a kindred spirit in a girl from a small town in Kansas. “I come from a place that’s even smaller than Amelia Earhart’s hometown of Atchison,” she said in a recent phone interview. “I know what it’s like to be born without money or privilege, to want to see the world. “When I was 10 years old, an airport opened near my village. I used to go there and watch the Fokker Friendships come and go, and I knew that I would be on one of those planes someday.” Unlike Earhart, Nair didn’t pilot the plane that transported her to a new life; but the director has proved that she’s not afraid to take risks. Her films include a Oscar-nominated drama set in the slums of Mumbai (“Salaam Bombay!”), an interracial love story set in the American South (“Mississippi Masala”), an epic romance set in 19th century London (“Vanity Fair”) and a multilingual, matrimonial comedy (the hit “Monsoon Wedding,” which was released as a special-edition DVD this week by the Criterion Collection). Nair also contributed a segment to the anthology film “New York, I Love You,” opening locally next Friday, in which 10 directors were given two days to shoot mini movies about life in the Big Apple. Nair, 52, teaches film at Columbia University, but she spends several months each year in her professor husband’s native Africa. That’s where much of “Amelia” was filmed, in the actual places where the pioneering aviatrix stopped on her flight around the world in 1937. The project gave Nair her first experience directing special effects, yet she kept the focus on a singular human. “The point of the effects and the wide-screen cinematography was to convey the ecstasy of flying in an era when it was still mysterious,” she said. “I wanted you to feel the beating heart of a life fully lived.” Although Earhart and her navigator disappeared en route to a tiny Pacific fuel stop called Howland Island, Nair doesn’t think of it as a tragic story. “Amelia was a very modern woman who lived life on her own terms, but with grace. She set an example that women from humble origins can accomplish things that were never imagined.” By Joe Williams yesterday's most emailed
9. Two costly?
|