Web Search powered by YAHOO! SEARCH
Home > News > Special Reports
 
Coleman's attorneys get 2 judges disqualified in murder case
Christopher Coleman (rear) exits the Columbia Police Department in Columbia, Ill
May 11, 2009 - Christopher Coleman (rear) exits the Columbia Police Department in Columbia, Ill, with his attorney Bill Margulis. (Erik M. Lunsford/P-D)
ST. LOUIS POST-DISPATCH

WATERLOO — Defense attorneys for Christopher Coleman, accused of killing his wife and two sons in Columbia, Ill., sought and received a disqualification Thursday of two judges from the case.

Their motion specifically sought to exclude Circuit Judge Dennis Doyle, who ruled last week that there is probable cause to bring Coleman to trial, and Circuit Judge Dennis Hatch.

"The defendant has reason to believe that Judge Doyle and Judge Dennis Hatch are so prejudiced against him that he cannot receive a fair trial," said the document filed by William Margulis, one Coleman's attorneys.

Pretrial changes of judge are common in Illinois criminal cases.


Chief Judge John Baricevic will appoint a replacement from among other judges in the 20th Circuit, presumably one who is certified to hear capital cases. Multiple killings and the killing of children qualify for a death sentence under the statute, but Monroe County State's Attorney Kris Reitz has not said whether he will seek one.

If he does, Coleman could get access to the Illinois Capital Litigation Fund to pay for his defense, provided he can convince a judge he is indigent.

The fund was set up in 2000 to provide better representation, after revelations that innocent people were sometimes being sentenced to death. Last year, a Post-Dispatch investigation revealed widespread abuse of the fund. The newspaper documented cases in which out-of-state private investigators charged taxpayers hundreds of dollars an hour for their time driving or flying. One investigator's travel time alone cost the fund more than $11,000.

In one instance documented by the paper, a defense team charged the fund more than $10,000 to build a mock-up of a crime scene for trial, then never used it.

A bill to overhaul the system in response to the Post-Dispatch disclosures is awaiting Gov. Pat Quinn's approval.

The capital-case certified judges of the 20th Circuit are Judges Milton Wharton, Annette Eckert and William Schuwerk, and Associate Judge Richard Aguirre. Both of the disqualified judges, Doyle and Hatch, also are certified. The circuit includes Monroe, St. Clair, Randolph, Washington and Perry counties.
MORE COVERAGE
bullet PHOTO GALLERY
bullet Family guestbook photos
bullet Photos from the scene
bullet EARLIER STORIES
bullet Warrants: Coleman told girlfriend they'd wed in 2010; had alibi for murders
bullet Coleman text message to girlfriend is revealed
bullet New judge named to handle Coleman case
bullet Coleman gets jail visitors
bullet Sheri Coleman's family sues Chris Coleman
bullet Inquest now planned in Coleman murders after toxicology results come in
bullet Coleman arrested in killing of family
bullet Coleman family neighbors are left wondering and in limbo
bullet Husband of slain woman, children, resigns job
bullet Family wins burial delay from court
bullet Police question alleged girlfriend of man whose family was slain
bullet Police return house to Coleman
bullet Community mourns slain family at vigil in Columbia, Ill.
bullet VIDEO
bullet VIDEO: Police press conference on Coleman arrest
bullet Neighbor reflects on Coleman's arrest
bullet RAW VIDEO: Coleman family files wrongful death lawsuit
bullet VIDEO: Coleman family press conference
bullet Christopher Coleman arrives in court
bullet Major Case Squad investigates Columbia, IL murders
bullet SEARCH WARRANTS
bullet PDF: Coleman search warrant complaint
bullet PDF: Chris Coleman search warrant
bullet PDF: Coleman house search warrant
bullet PDF: Second house search warrant
bullet PDF: Search warrant for straw bails
bullet PDF: Coleman vehicle search warrant
bullet COURT DOCUMENTS
bullet PDF: Coleman's first mortgage on Columbia, Ill. home (first, last pages)
bullet PDF: Coleman home refinance document (first, last pages)
bullet PDF: Quit Claim deed removing Sheri Coleman's name
bullet PDF: Joyce Meyer Ministry's proposed confidentiality agreement
bullet PDF: Sheri Coleman family lawyer response to confidentiality request
bullet PDF: Chris Coleman W-2 forms
bullet PDF: Chris Coleman signs Meyer Ministries employee handbook agreement
bullet PDF: Christopher Coleman employment agreement
bullet PDF: Coleman's raise at Joyce Meyer Ministries
bullet PDF: Joyce Meyer Ministries email policies
bullet PDF: Memo of termination to Chris Coleman's personnel file
bullet PDF: Joyce Meyers Ministries media policy
bullet PDF: Notification of Coleman's departure
bullet SIGN MEMORIAL GUESTBOOKS
bullet Sheri Coleman guestbook
bullet Gavin Coleman guestbook
bullet Garrett Coleman guestbook


If the death penalty is sought, Margulis and his father, Art Margulis, would need to be certified by the state to continue on Coleman's defense.

Coleman, 32, is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the strangulation of his wife Sheri, 31, and sons Garett, 11, and Gavin, 9, whose bodies were found in their home on May 5.

William Margulis says his client "maintains his innocence."

Write a letter to the editors | Subscribe to a newsletter | Subscribe to the newspaper
Read the latest news stories | View all P-D stories from the last 7 days

 
yesterday's most emailed
P-D
Yahoo HotJobs
spacer
the list classified ads