|
Chamber of Commerce is selectively indignant about use of the courts
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce was royally punked earlier this month, falling victim to an elaborate ruse by a group of political activists. The business group is peeved, calling the prank "commercial identity theft masquerading as social activism." Now it has filed suit. That's an odd place for an aggressive proponent of tort reform — and ferocious opponent of "lawsuit abuse" — to find itself. Consider the facts: A group called the "Yes Men" is the object of the Chamber's ire. The Yes Men, which recently released a movie, is a self-described ensemble of actors "best known for posing as corporate executives in order to reveal how corporate greed negatively influences public policy." In l'affaire de Chamber, it developed a dummy Web page that mirrored the Chamber's online presence. It announced the startling news that the Chamber had made a dramatic "about face on climate policy" and now favored "a stiff carbon tax and correspondingly strong incentives for industries."
FIND MORE EDITORIAL AND OPINION
But that's simply not the case. Far from a narrowly cast trademark protection lawsuit, this is blunderbuss, seven-count complaint filed by a major Washington, D.C., firm in U.S. District Court, with the Chamber asking for an injunction (including removal of YouTube videos), a jury trial, damages, attorneys' fees and "such other relief as may be appropriate." The Chamber protests that it is "a strong proponent of free speech and encourages public debate on issues of the day." But the Chamber is trying to stifle free speech and punish political parody with its superior resources and army of high-priced lawyers. The Chamber counters that "the defendants are not merry pranksters tweaking the establishment. Instead, they deliberately broke the law in order to further commercial interest in their books, movies, and other merchandise." We'll see. Ultimately, that's what the federal court will decide. Members of the public, meanwhile, can view the evidence online and render their own judgment. There's already ample proof to support this conclusion: The U.S. Chamber of Commerce's complaints about our litigious society shouldn't be taken seriously.
Write a letter to the editors |
Subscribe to a newsletter |
Subscribe to the newspaper
|
yesterday's most emailed
9. Two costly?
|