Skip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.
Outside review stalls for troubled St. Louis County jail

Outside review stalls for troubled St. Louis County jail

St. Louis County Justice Services Advisory Board

The St. Louis County Justice Services Advisory Board meets via Cisco Webex videoconference software on Friday, Aug. 28, 2020. (Post-Dispatch)

CLAYTON — Members of an advisory board pressing for changes at the St. Louis County Jail said Friday they were frustrated by the lack of progress on a promised independent investigation of the troubled facility.

County Executive Sam Page on Aug. 28 announced that his office would hold an outside review of jail operations and meet the advisory board to get members input.

On Friday, advisory board members were told the County Counselor’s office needs to finish an internal personnel investigation before the outside review can start.

Mary Zabawa Taylor, a member of the Justice Services Advisory Board, said that was news to her.

“I sit here today eight weeks out about something we thought was pretty urgent, without the board hearing anything about our recommendation,” Taylor said during the board’s regular monthly meeting.

Taylor is one of seven people Page appointed to the board in mid-2019 to help reform the jail after a series of inmate deaths at the troubled facility. But the board has complained that it has had to fight for information and a larger role in reforms.

“We’ve fallen back into old patterns of no communication with this board,” said Taylor, who was the first to call for a wide-ranging outside review shortly after then-jail director Raul Banasco resigned Aug. 26 amid allegations of misconduct after nine months on the job.

Taylor said Friday the board did not hear anything from the Page administration about its request to be involved in the outside review since meeting in early September.

County Counselor Beth Orwick told the board Friday that Page asked her to inform them that her office needed to finish its personnel investigation before proceeding with its request.

“He does expect to take a deeper dive, it’s just not the appropriate time right now as that first investigation is ongoing,” Orwick said.

Doug Moore, a spokesman for Page, said after the meeting that the internal investigation is meant to survey employees about issues they’ve identified within the jail, but that it would also help and inform the scope of an outside review.

The county hired Vera Causa Group, a consulting firm whose principals are former St. Louis Circuit Attorney Jennifer M. Joyce and communications consultant Susan C. Ryan, to survey jail employees for Orwick’s office.

“When that personnel-based investigation is complete the advisory board and the public will be notified and we can discuss next steps,” Moore said.

Still, the jail advisory board approved a motion by Taylor to formally request Page’s office give the board a detailed report at its next monthly meeting. Board members Jeff Smith and Tim McBride echoed Taylor’s criticism. They voted with Taylor and board members Spring Schmidt and the Rev. Phillip Duvall to approve the motion. Two other board members were not present for the virtual meeting.

“If there is going to be an investigation, there is going to need to be someone that we’ll need to talk to,” Taylor said.

In other action Friday, the advisory board agreed to appoint a new chair in November to replace Duvall, who stepped down in late September because of health concerns.

Jail officials meanwhile, updated the advisory board Friday on COVID-19 infections at the facility, including how the pandemic has exacerbated staffing shortages in its medical division.

For two months, staff have been required to work overtime to fill in the gaps, said Valerie Nelson, chief operating officer for medical services at the jail.

“It’s really at a point that it cannot continue like that anymore,” Nelson said.

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Reporter covering breaking news and crime by night. Born in Algeria but grew up in St. Louis. Previously reported for The Associated Press in Jackson, Mississippi and at the Wichita Eagle in Wichita, Kansas.

Related to this story

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Blues News

Breaking News

Cardinals News

Daily 6

National Breaking News