Skip to main contentSkip to main content
You are the owner of this article.
You have permission to edit this article.

How Mel Gray's 'Phantom Catch' became part of St. Louis football lore


They were called the Cardiac Cards for a reason. In what was then a 14-game NFL schedule, eight of the football Cardinals' contests in 1975 were decided in the final minute of play.

The Big Red went 7-1 in those games, with none more spine-tingling than a 20-17 overtime victory over rival Washington on Nov. 16 at Busch Stadium II. With 20 seconds left in regulation, quarterback Jim Hart threw a 6-yard pass to wide receiver Mel Gray for a touchdown.

Or was it?

With former Cardinal Pat Fischer defending for Washington, the ball was in and out of Gray's hands quickly. Two game officials signaled touchdown; one signaled incomplete pass.

Officials huddled for three minutes — an eternity in the days prior to instant replay — before finally ruling it a TD.

"I think I had it good," Gray said. "I'm sure I broke the plane (of the goal line). On that play somebody broke my facemask tackling me. I was over when I caught it and then I think I got hit from the side."

Gray also had some advice for Fischer immediately after the catch. "I told him dirty teams don't win."

Jim Bakken's extra point sent the game into OT tied 17-17 and the win launched the Big Red on a late-season run culminating in the Eastern Conference title and an 11-3 record.

Nov. 16, 1975: The phantom catch

Big Red players signal in unison that an official had signaled "touchdown" on Mel Gray's disputed catch in the Nov. 16, 1975 game against the Washington Redskins at Busch Stadium II. (Post-Dispatch photo) 


Post-Dispatch sportswriters Jim Thomas and Ben Frederickson present their all-time St. Louis pro football team (first published on…

Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News


National News