Lee Enterprises newsroom and editorial were not involved in the creation of this content.
A customer calls a business after hours and gets the familiar message: “The office is closed. Leave a voicemail, and someone will get back to you.”
For some callers, that is perfectly fine. For others, it is the point at which they start looking elsewhere. A Nextiva Customer Patience Benchmark survey found that 28% of customers abandon a product or service after a missed response window.
Someone calling at 8 p.m. may want to make an appointment, check whether a service is available, or deal with a problem that cannot wait until morning. If the only option is to leave a message, the customer has to decide whether waiting is worth it.
People are also reading…
Increasingly, businesses are finding that it may not be.
Why “Leave a Message” Falls Short After Hours
Voicemail was built for a world in which the next step could wait. A caller left their name, number and reason for calling, and an employee dealt with the message when they returned to the office.
That arrangement still works for some conversations, but it becomes less useful when the customer wants to take action. For example, someone looking for a service provider or trying to schedule an appointment may find an available competitor online. Similarly, someone with an urgent problem may not have much patience for a callback the next day.
The point is not that voicemail has suddenly become obsolete. It is that voicemail no longer guarantees that the conversation will continue.
What a Modern After-Hours Answering Experience Looks Like
Modern answering systems give callers options before they ever reach voicemail.
The first is simple: Answer the call. Automated systems can now handle many routine questions without requiring an employee to sit by the phone all night. A caller might ask about business hours, services or availability, and get an answer immediately.
For example, XBert, an AI receptionist made by Nextiva, handles calls, answers questions, books appointments, resolves routine requests and routes more complicated conversations to employees.
The next step is understanding what the caller actually wants. Instead of storing an audio message and leaving an employee to work out what to do with it later, an answering system can collect details, identify the request and record the interaction. That typically gives the business something to act on.
There is also a limit to what automation can handle. Some calls need a person, particularly when the issue is complicated or urgent. In those cases, the useful handoff carries the conversation’s context with it. The employee should know why the customer called and what has already been discussed.
Ruby’s answering service takes a similar approach with live receptionists supported by AI, handling message intake, appointment scheduling and call routing around the clock.
Neither approach makes human employees unnecessary. It gives them a different role. Instead of spending the next morning listening to a queue of messages and working out what each caller wanted, employees can potentially step into conversations that already have a reason to carry on.
The New Question: What Happened to the Opportunity?
Once a business can do more with an after-hours call, the old measures look limited.
A phone report that shows 100 calls came in and 80 were answered may tell a business something about staffing. It typically does not tell the business whether those 80 callers got what they needed or what happened to the 20 who did not get through.
A more useful view can potentially track the outcome. How many callers booked appointments? How many received answers without employee involvement? How many requested a callback? How many needed human interaction? How many urgent issues reached the right employee? How many calls ended without a useful next step?
That moves the focus from answered calls to potential captured opportunities.
This also explains why customer information is becoming more important across business communications. A call should not exist in isolation from the customer’s other interactions. If the person eventually speaks with an employee, that employee should have enough context to continue the conversation rather than ask the customer to repeat it.
What Customers Should Expect From an After-Hours Call
Consumers are accustomed to booking, checking information and getting responses online at almost any time, so a call recording that simply asks them to wait can feel out of step with the rest of the experience.
That does not mean customers should expect every business to have a human employee answering calls around the clock. They should, however, be able to expect a useful next step.
That might mean getting an answer to a basic question, giving the business their details, booking an appointment, or getting connected to someone when the issue requires human attention. If the conversation moves to an employee, the customer should not have to start over simply because the first part happened after hours.
What Business Owners Should Look For
For owners, customers expecting a more productive outcome raises an immediate concern: What happens between the moment a customer calls and the moment someone on the team can act on the request?
A business can potentially start by looking at its own call records. How many calls come in after hours? How many result in voicemails? How many callers hang up? How often do those calls involve appointments, new business or urgent requests? And when an employee follows up the next day, how often has the customer already gone somewhere else?
The next step is to consider what the modern answering system can actually do with those calls. Can it answer routine questions? Capture the caller’s information? Schedule an appointment? Recognize a request that needs a person? Pass useful context to that employee?
Voicemail will remain useful for customers who simply want to leave a message. But it no longer has to be the default ending for every after-hours call.
